Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

wood movement on wide miters

Posts

wood movement on wide miters

#1

Louie Lovas

wood movement on wide miters

Louie Lovas

>I'm getting close to starting my next project, it's a coffee table. It's got quite a large top (36" x 58"). The design has a centered panel of maple with a mitered cherry frame. I've included an image of the top (drawn in Google Sketchup). The maple panel will fit into a groove running around the interior perimeter of the frame, the design should easily handle any movement of the panel. However, the cherry frame is going to be 5" - 6" wide which means quite a long miter joint at the corners. I plan to use splines to reinforce the joint - with the grain running parallel with the cherry frame. My concern is with season movement of 5" wide cherry frame boards and the impact on the miter joint. Will the miter joint, which will be close to 8" long survive the seasonal movement?


img

Re: wood movement on wide miters

#2

Re: wood movement on wide miters

Sgian Dubh

>Almost certainly not.

The images below illustrate the likely end result. The mitred European beech squares were 300 mm (12") along each edge at glue-up. Diagonals measured roughly 425 mm (16-3/4"). Half diagonals are therefore, ~212 mm (8-3/8")

I made them to demonstrate mitre joint failure. Slainte.



Re: wood movement on wide miters

#3

Ellis Walentine

Design your way out of this one

Ellis Walentine

>Without a doubt, I would do this entire project with veneer, but I can't speak for everyone. As Sgian says, the miters will open, and the panel will move too if you use solid wood. I prefer tight seams and no panel gaps on tabletops. If you want the durability of solid wood, saw your own veneers to approximately 1/10" thickness and use solid wood edges on your substrate.

My 2¢,

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: wood movement on wide miters

#4

Use pocket crews

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>I made some dressers and night stands with a frame and panel type top for my son and his wife a number of years ago. The first one I made the corners opened after a short while. The last one I made, I reinforced the corners from teh bottom side with pocket hole screws on the miters from each side. So far that joint has not opened despite migrating from Pennsylvania to Arizona and back to New York State.

Lee

Re: wood movement on wide miters

#5

Louie Lovas

Thanks for the feedback

Louie Lovas

>Thanks everyone for the valuable comments. I will reconsider my approach to this to avoid a costly mistake. The pics on that show the miter joint failure sold me.

thanks again everyone.

Re: wood movement on wide miters

#6

Good Demo Richard

Keith Newton, LR, Arkansas------WebKitFormBoundary

>It might be worth noticing that this was with rift cut material, and would have been even worse if it had been plain sawn.

Re: wood movement on wide miters

#7

Re: Good Demo Richard

Sgian Dubh

>Thanks for the compliment, and what you said about the angle of the growth ring intersection to the face of the plank is true.

The growth rings are at about 60� to the face of the plank. Here in the UK growth rings intersecting the wide face between 30� and 60� is classified as rift sawn or bastard cut; 60� to 80� is 'figured'-- applies to oak mostly; and 80� to 90� is quarter sawn.

An assemblage of a truly tangentially sawn plank-- <30� angle of the growth rings to the wide face would have resulted in more movement. European beech is also one of the largest movers-- one reason for its selection. Lastly, I really wanted to use wood that was at about 10% MC at construction. It was a bit drier than I really wanted at 8% MC, but that assemblage still illustrates mitre joint failure more than adequately. Slainte.