>I am in the process of building a ne 26x32 ft workshop. This shop will have 10 ft walls and a cathederal ceiling. There will be no beams across the building.
What can I use to light this space. I know I could have 2 or 3 rows of flouecent lights hanging down about 10 ft high but I was hoping to avoid this as it will obstruct the view to the roof.
Any ideas ,lights that would mount on the roof itself or maybe lights fastened along the top pereminter of the walls
>The objective with lighting is to provide an acceptable/appropriate number of lumens for the task at hand. Light bulbs and fluorescent tubes put out a certain number of lumens, and the number that reaches the work surface depends on the distance from the source to the surface and how those lumens are directed/reflected or focused by the light fixture.
You can put your lights up in the rafters but you'll need lots more of them to make up for the distance and they won't be much fun to change when they burn out. Still, it can be done. I took this picture at Lee Grindinger's shop in Montana and he had pretty much the same setup as you described. I doubt that the light level at workstation height meets BIFMA standards, but it's good ambient light and probably adequate for a lot of tasks. For anything requiring higher intensity lighting, you could have a rolling fixture with a couple reflectors pointed wherever you need the added light.
>Ellis is right, it was great ambient lighting. There were four rows of T8 fixtures. In the main work area I used bulbs that were nearer natural light, 95% full spectrum, and the light was fantastic. I still needed task lighting for close and very small work like some carving but the power tool stations were all adequately lighted. Were I redoing that shop I'd move the outside fixtures closer to the walls but leave the higher ones where they are, I'd also add another strip near the benches were were not lighted very well.
Plan your lighting to eliminate shadows, fluorescents are good for this since the light doesn't come from a point. Remember, lighting creates heat so the further you can be from the source the better, especially sources used for task lighting like incandescent or halogens. One other bit of advice- use multiple switches so you only light where you're working. Bench work can consume a great deal of your shop time and it's pointless to illuminate your table saw when all it's doing in collecting dust, I had three lighting zones in a 30' by 50' workshop.
>I like the look of this setup. However my shop will have a much greater slope on the roof and the roof is natural wood not painted white. My walls are 10 ft high also. I was leaning towards something that was mounted around the walls but I guess this will not be possible. What about a double strip of flourcent along each wall at 10 ft height ?
>Striplights at the eaves will not project much light into the center of the shop. You'll have too much light at the margins and not enough in the middle. I wouldn't worry much about the natural wood ceilings if you use adequate reflectors behind your bulbs. For more lumens per square foot, you can buy high-output fluorescents, but they're likely to be quite a bit more expensive.
One thing that nobody has brought up yet is the possibility of putting hi-hats in your rafters and using bright reflector floods. This is expensive lighting to buy and maintain, but the color temperature is a lot warmer and it might just fit into your expectations for the design of this space. You could still use your wall-mounted fluorescents at the perimeter and just fill the center with your floodlights. Most of the lighting manufacturers and showrooms will be able to show you how to calculate spacing and wattages to get the kind of distribution and intensity you need. Let the pros help you get it right.
>but do I spy radiant heat in the ceiling? If so, how did that work for you? Brand (I know a guy who is the regional distributor for CoRayVac)? IIRC, the winters where you lived weren't much different than here in S. Minnesota, and I'm considering radiant natural gas for my shop area.
>The heater was Re-verber-ray, LP Gas. Mine was two stage, 50,000 and 75,000 BTU I think. It was far and away the best heat I've ever had in a long list of workshops. I'd suggest you look very hard at a two stage because the only criticism I have is that directly under a heater it can be too warm and the lower BTU setting was very comfortable, as a matter of fact I very rarely used the higher setting. The heater warmed the floor, the cast iron, the wood quickly- I never had condensation problems due to cold cast iron. Finishes could be cured more quickly by raising them closer to the heater. The efficiency was great as well. If you have the ceiling height I'd highly recommend radiant tube heat. It was easy to install and consumed no shop air so it was mostly explosion proof.
>According to my brother in law, GE lighting engineer, different people have different ideas about what color light is best for detail work. I like sun light equivalent, especially in the winter, but some find my shop dazzeling.
>hi Paul, I used T8 flourescents with the Daylight color, about 5000K. For task lighting I have track lighting in different areas. I've replaced the regular incandescent bulbs with full spectrum flourescents.
Also on all the flourescent tube fixtures I used electronic ballasts with an A sound rating. Cheaper fixtures will have noisy ballasts.
The best advice I got when I was doing this was to get a lighting plan done by a professional. Most electrical wholesale places will have somebody trained to do a lighting plan, and they will usually do the plan for free in hopes you'll buy the fixtures from them.
>The day after I had my new shop wired (ain't it always the case?) I ran across what I thought was a very helpful article by FWW. Written by Jack Lindsey, it was originally published in FWW #154 (Jan/Feb 2002), and it's recently been reprinted in a "Best of FWW" magazine entitled "Workshop Solutions," which you can now find on a stand at the Borg (it reads "Display until June 30, 2008" at the bottom of the cover). If you're a member of FWW online, you can also see it in .pdf format at http://tinyurl.com/3leu5n. It has some very helpful guidelines and formulas that help you calculate distances and recommended wattages, etc., along with some good explanations. If there's anything lacking (and it's minor), it might be a revision reflecting (no pun intended) advances in lighting technology since 2002. One text box reads, "In the future, look for the smaller, energy efficient T8 lamps to become more common" -- but T8's seemed to be almost a foregone conclusion as far as my electrician was concerned.
Good luck (and get more than you think you need -- !)