Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

A cost comparison.

Posts

A cost comparison.

#1

A cost comparison.

ken raddon

>I saw a shelf in a mag recently so I wanted to make one. Well it would cost four to five times as much to make one as it would to buy one. I modified it and made it out of melamene (sp). It turned out great for about a third the cost of making it out of hardwoods.

I even thought about making a bed for the master bd room but hell the cost is many times what it would cost to buy.

Please give me a better way of looking at this hobby. The cost of it all is killing me.

Ken Raddon.

Re: A cost comparison.

#2

Re: A cost comparison.

Chuck in ND

>Ken, I hear your pain. A few years ago I bought a mission style bed at a furniture store because of the same reason you stated. I just learn to be happy with what I have in equipment, and do my own thing, even if it's just building small stuff for myself. I've allready went through the stage of wanting to make a liveing at wood working, and failed, and I certainly can't keep up with the big tool craze either. Now I'm just trying to lay back and enjoy it all again.

Re: A cost comparison.

#3

Re: A cost comparison.

Steve in Denver

>What about buying rough cut lumber, that might help to level the playing field. When you build it, you know the quality vs store bought. There's also the satisfaction of being being able to say, "I built that." If it's a hobby, it should be more about the enjoyment you get out of the process and not the $$$$ going into it.

Re: A cost comparison.

#4

You have to factor in...

Bill Hammond, Oregon Coast

>You have to factor in the $150 an hour you are not paying the shrink while getting your head together building things.

You really can't compare the cost of what you make with a store bought item. It's a hobby, it should be fun and relaxing. If the end result is useful, all the better. If your hobby was fishing you would not factor in the price of a boat, trailer and new truck to pull it against the price of fish at the market. You would not even factor in the price of gas to get there to fish. So don't do it with woodworking. The I can do it less expensive was just a way to rationalize it with your wife and perhaps that bean counter that hangs around in your right brain. If you are trying to beat the price then it's another job. You don't want to be working another job nights and weekends. So keep it a fun hobby, after all, it's less expensive than chasing women!

Bill, who has a good idea of what the table saw would be used for if he were caught chasing women.

Re: A cost comparison.

#5

Moses Yoder

Re: comparison to what?

Moses Yoder

>I would question what you are comparing your work to. If you are comparing it to Walmart, forget it. It's just too ridiculous. If you are comparing it to a typical furniture store like Art Van or something like that where they import furniture built with a labor cost so low that it is not even factored in as a cost, forget it. It's not fair to us to compete against slave labor. If you are comparing your furniture to good quality stuff made in North America your materials cost should be lower than the cost of the furntiure. Because factory built furniture is built so efficiently you still will not get paid a dime an hour for your time, but you have the fun of building it.

As has been said already, buy it and be happy with it. Enjoy life. Spend time in your shop learning and enjoying the wood. I have spent the past three months working on a sideboard at about 10 - 15 hours per week that the shop I work in would have built in aproximately 16 hours. But I have chosen every board carefully, which is something you don't find in the average furniture store. You might in some of the special gallerys, but there is where you find the furniture you should compare your work to. I have designed and built this baby from the ground up, and it's my baby. I will actually hate to see it go to it's rightful owner. I have another month or so of work building the drawer boxes for it and finishing it.

Re: A cost comparison.

#6

Well said -- Great Points (LONG)

David Yoho

>I couldn't have said it better.

Ken - Adding to what Bill said and getting at a finer point, you have to seek out and use wood that costs less whenever possible. Case-in-point -- I try to buy my hardwood lumber rough when I can. It's cheaper than already surfaced and I can get a better yield from the stock by resawing thicker stock into 1/4", 1/2", and up versus planing 3/4" down to 1/2" when needed.

Now, I have two suppliers I deal with locally and two long distance. When I need rough in small amounts I usually drop by the local WoodCraft store. However, when I need larger amounts I go to one of my long distance suppliers (a one-hour drive to get there). It just happens that this supplier is the WoodCraft store's main supplier too. So I bypass the middle man and save some more money. If they were closer, I'd go there every time.

Many years ago I built my own computers because not only did I find it fun but back then you could actually build one yourself for less than buying new. Things have changed and today I can't build for less than new. However, my reason for it today would solely be to get one exactly the way I want it.

I find the same thing with furniture and the small business I run. I see pieces out there for less than I can build them. The thing is - I know the difference between them and what I'd build would be night and day in both materials and quality. So whenever I have the chance and time to build for myself, I don't worry about the cost nearly as much as putting quality and craftsmanship into my work while building as fine a piece as I know how. In the end, I have something truly special that will stand the tests of time and live on as a reminder of one of the things I did while on this Earth. I guess I'm one that finds a great value in that sort of thing.

The other part of this cost issue for me is when building for someone else. I have often built projects that used materials and hardware to get the price in the realm of what the customer could pay. I do much less of that these days. I'm at a point where I'm building more for those who see the value in solid hardwoods and are happy to pay for my craftsmanship and to get exactly what they want. These folks can sure keep a guy like me busy but I enjoy the work so much more!

In the end, we're all in this craft because it's a love inside of us to create with wood in all of its beauty and splendor. If you don't feel that way, then you might want to re-think your reasons for doing it. However, if you do feel that way, then Bill's point is right on the money.

If it's your hobby, then look for ways to reduce your materials costs when you can and work on sharpening your skills as you go. It's a hobby that's not going to be cheap but you can always look for ways to save without sacrificing quality. You can't put a price on the journey of learning the craft of working wood.

David

Re: A cost comparison.

#7

a quality comparison

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>If you don't value a bed made from quality lumber any more than one made from plastic and MDF then you need to pursue woodworking as a hobby and not as a way to save money on home furniture.

Many woodworkers get into woodworking because it enables them to have the quality of furniture they want, that they could otherwise not afford. Others pursue the hobby as a satisfying way to spend time without regard to economics.

Re: A cost comparison.

#8

Golf isn't cost effective either

Curly Smith

>Well, that Tiger fellow seems to made a go of it...

Let's look at your shelf example:

- assume you could buy it for $25

- assume the cost from hardwoods was $100 (4x the cost)

Would you have gotten $75 of pleasure from building it? Evidently not as you built from other materials for $33. Did you derive $8 of satisfaction from figuring out how to build it within your budget and then building it? It sounds like it. Did you get a better quality shelf than you could have for $25? I'd say it's likely that you did and you'll almost certainly enjoy having it in your house more.

WW is just like your golf swing, you need to find the sweet spot in your budget, your skills and your projects. There's nothing wrong with using MDF or hardwood veneered plywood if that's all that your budget allows. Use the cheaper materials and trim with the expensive stuff and you'll probably be the only one who knows.

Re: A cost comparison.

#9

Re: Golf isn't cost effective either

ken raddon

>Thanks I needed that attitude adjustment. The shelf sits right above my computer and I did it on the cheap and had fun figuring it out and modifying it to within my budget.

I am going to take your advice and spend more time exploring the hardwood places (they are fun to look through) and find the prefect wood so I get that much more out of looking at it every day.

BTW My other hobby is fly fishing and I gave up golf for it so you guys are hitting the nail on the head (get it I used a wood type referrence) with those comparisons.

I guess I am a budding hardwood woodworker trapped in a pressed wood budget.

Thanks again.

Ken Raddon.

Re: A cost comparison.

#10

Re: Golf isn't cost effective either

mdclor

>I have been able to convince LOML that the things I build are on a par with Stickley (in my dreams :^)), but that is what I strive for. Then I can justify a new tool to and still be money ahead on the project. Besides I usually try to learn a new technique with each project.

HTH,

Merle

Re: A cost comparison.

#11

Re: A cost comparison.

Ron in Drums PA

>I really can't understand the comparison of melamine to a hardwood such as oak or maple.

But lets look at it a different way.

The best made melamine bookshelf or bed may have the life expectancy of 8-10 years.

The best made oak bookshelf or bed may have the life expectancy of 3-4 generations.

Having a great-grandchild say, "My Great-Grampapy made this when he was a young man" is priceless.

Re: A cost comparison.

#12

Re: A cost comparison.

Justin Fields

>I'll add in along the lines of what others have said.

If you are doing this as a hobby, you have to pick and choose. Between materials, tools and time, I don't know of anyone who doesn't have to make compromises and sacrifices.

The way I look at it, I judge my materials/tools/time budget and pick something within that which would give me satisfaction to build and to own (or give away). The care in selecting the project and knowing your limitations is a big contributor to your happiness with your involvement.

For some concrete examples, the home office my wife and I share has lots of wooden shelving and two wooden modular wall unit desks. It is cheap pine stuff from IKEA, because I didn't want to put the time and effort into this project, so I bought. On the other hand, I made a spice rack recently. That is an item you can buy anywhere, but I wanted mine a very specific way. It holds 184 spice bottles in an efficient horizontal orientation. While spice racks are everywhere, the exact thing I wanted could only be had by making it myself.

I also made a religious candle holder as a present for my wife. If I were to compute the time and materials that went into it, it would be incredibly expensive and I would never have done it. But I don't think of it like that. I want to make something she would savor, and which I would feel proud to have made. I also wanted it made a specific way. So cost wasn't the issue.

For me, it breaks down as follows:

A) I can't buy the item I want

B) I can make or buy, but I can do it cheaper AND would enjoy it

C) I can make it, and enjoy the process, regardless of cost efficiency

D) I can make or buy, but project doesn't interest me

E) I can't make it

If it is A, B or C, I make the item. If it is D or E, forget it.

If you try to compete with the WalMart, Home Depot and IKEAs of the world, you are in for nothing but disappointment. You can't look at it in those terms.

Justin

Re: A cost comparison.

#13

Don't compare fresh apples to dried fruit

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

>Try to buy a quarter-sawn white oak shelving unit. You probably can't because they are not made for sale at mass-consumer stores or even better furniture stores. And if you could, it will surely cost more than the materials to build it yourself. You can buy a shelf cheap, but it will not be made of the same quality stuff you're comparing it to.

Re: A cost comparison.

#14

Re: A cost comparison.

Roger Lance in GR, Michigan

>Given your point of view, you should get out of the hobby and stop the feeling of the cost killing you.

Re: A cost comparison.

#15

Re: A cost comparison.

ken raddon

>Thanks for all the advice. Getting out while good advice to some won't work for me I am too stuborn. I really like the a,b,c,d,e, approach.

Thanks again. I will stick to stuff I can make within my budget and/or stuff that if passed on to future generations makes it invaluable. I guess I never thought of it like that see I just needed an attitude, and/or perspective, adjustment.

This is a terrific bulletin board, you guys are great. Now if someone wants to come by and show me how to work this new dovetail jig I'll buy the beverage of choice.

Ken.

Re: A cost comparison.

#16

How about a bottle of....

Ron in Drums PA

>1787 Chateau Lafite

Re: A cost comparison.

#17

Re: Golf isn't cost effective either

Phil Joines Krum, Tx

>Depending on where you live and your tooling it's possible to used wood from downed trees. Most of my favorite woods aren't commercially available.

Re: A cost comparison.

#18

Re: Golf isn't cost effective either

Chuck in ND

>Golf isn't hazzardous or bad for your health like wood working is.

Re: A cost comparison.

#19

Re: A cost comparison.

Jim Engel

>In my experience one of the primary reasons for wood working

is that I can build exactly what I want in terms of size and

configuration. If you live in a smaller home, and we all have

space limitations, the ability to build a desk, table or set

of shelves to fit a space and application is to me one of the

primary benefits of woodworking.

Try this exercise. Design a very specific slightly odd sized

desk or cabinet and see what the price would be at a custom

shop.

That is a more more valid comparison.

But even here a custom shop probably has a spray booth set

up or contracts it out, may have a number of shapers and

saws set up for specific operations, may make standard parts.

So your hours building a project where you have one saw, one

shaper or router table etc is going to be very, very time

consuming compared even to a custom shop.

For me setting up a spray finish operation is a hurdle I

have not been able to get over in terms of space, and setting

up to finish one pice is always going to be inefficient.

I really enjoy being able to make a specific piece for a very

particular application.

And some things, like dining room chairs, I buy because the

investment in tools and skills and the fact that we can buy

exactly what we want makes going to the high end supplier

sensible for us.

It seems to me that there are two reasons to build furniture,

the desire of the artist to create an object as perfect as

possible for its own sake and the ability to have exactly what

you want.

If a piece of furniture is available in a commercial outlet

there is just no way you can put any value on your time at

all and duplicate it in a home shop, that is the nature of

mass production.

And this is a good thing, for large scale mass production

is the basis of the good life we lead.

If you don't believe it, make your next car as a home

project.

If the cost comparisons take the joy out of woodworking,

you should, as someone has said, take up another hobby.

Re: A cost comparison.

#20

Nice, But

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>The cost to chase is a pittance compared to the cost when you catch one, and is infinitesimal when compared to the cost to turn one loose again.

mm

Re: A cost comparison.

#21

Re: A cost comparison.

Pete in Holland, MI

>Ken -

It appears you are going to the local store to find your source of hardwoods. Yup, places like Woodcraft, Lowes, Menards & such would be the last place I would look for domestic hardwoods. Exotics are a different story. In Michigan, where I live, oak, maple, cherry, pines & poplars are very plentiful, but don't go the first board store around the corner. Talk to other woodworkers for their sources. My parents live in northern Michigan and I have been buying my oaks & maples up there from a farmer who has a small mill & kiln operation for less than half of the going rate here in in lower Michigan. When I make a trip up that direction, I bring back a lot of wood for my inventory (100-500 bd ft). If you need and only want to buy a board at a time, you might not have much of a choice but to pay the long dollar. Most of us who are serious in the hobby have the ability to buy a lot of wood at a time & store it, and use it as needed.

My 3 cents (adjusted for inflation)

Re: A cost comparison.

#22

Re: A cost comparison.

Paulo

>This may help a little--> http://www.woodworkingtips.com/etips/etip25.html

Re: A cost comparison.

#23

Not too sure about that ;-)

Dan Donaldson

>I have seen some golfers raise their blood pressure to dangerous levels on some shots ;-)