Re: A cost comparison.
Jim Engel
>In my experience one of the primary reasons for wood working
is that I can build exactly what I want in terms of size and
configuration. If you live in a smaller home, and we all have
space limitations, the ability to build a desk, table or set
of shelves to fit a space and application is to me one of the
primary benefits of woodworking.
Try this exercise. Design a very specific slightly odd sized
desk or cabinet and see what the price would be at a custom
shop.
That is a more more valid comparison.
But even here a custom shop probably has a spray booth set
up or contracts it out, may have a number of shapers and
saws set up for specific operations, may make standard parts.
So your hours building a project where you have one saw, one
shaper or router table etc is going to be very, very time
consuming compared even to a custom shop.
For me setting up a spray finish operation is a hurdle I
have not been able to get over in terms of space, and setting
up to finish one pice is always going to be inefficient.
I really enjoy being able to make a specific piece for a very
particular application.
And some things, like dining room chairs, I buy because the
investment in tools and skills and the fact that we can buy
exactly what we want makes going to the high end supplier
sensible for us.
It seems to me that there are two reasons to build furniture,
the desire of the artist to create an object as perfect as
possible for its own sake and the ability to have exactly what
you want.
If a piece of furniture is available in a commercial outlet
there is just no way you can put any value on your time at
all and duplicate it in a home shop, that is the nature of
mass production.
And this is a good thing, for large scale mass production
is the basis of the good life we lead.
If you don't believe it, make your next car as a home
project.
If the cost comparisons take the joy out of woodworking,
you should, as someone has said, take up another hobby.