Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Yellow Poplar...

Posts

Yellow Poplar...

#1

Yellow Poplar...

john l. blue

>Debarked a 20 year old yellow poplar, how long do I wait until

time to treat it to make it last forever? Thanks in advance! Blue

Re: Yellow Poplar...

#2

Ellis Walentine

Not sure I follow you

Ellis Walentine

>You debarked a standing tree? Or you had the tree sawn into lumber and then removed the bark from the boards? What do you mean by "treat it" and "last forever"?

Lotta questions here. Try to be more specific.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Yellow Poplar...

#3

Re: Yellow Poplar...

John K Jordan

>>...Debarked a 20 year old yellow poplar

Are you referring to the practice of debarking to kill a standing tree and letting it dry somewhat before felling and sawing? I understand this is a technique sometimes used on tropical trees, especially ebony, but I've never heard of it used on domestic trees except for persimmon (a member of the ebony family, btw).

I read a study of this technique used on eucalyptus. The debarked a wide band some feet off the ground and let the tree stand for two years before felling. The overall shrinkage was reduced a small amount by this process, the T/R shrinkage ratio was reduced by about 1/2 percent.

I have no idea if this will be useful for yellow poplar but I'm guessing it won't hurt the wood. I've sawed debarked poplar logs that sat on the ground for a couple of years and they were fine. Of course, freshly sawn green logs were also fine. If there is an advantage to letting the tree stand dead for some time, I suspect it is in keeping it vertical to let moisture exit by gravity. I've read the technique of standing logs, slabs, and boards on end for some time before sawing or resawing tends to speed subsequent air drying and reduce warpage.

BTW, for the best yield from y.poplar and several other species, some experts recommend the SDR technique (saw/dry/rip). For more information, search google for 'saw dry rip'. With this method the log is sawn into slabs which are stickered and dried, then ripped into dimensional lumber. It is claimed in research papers and other publications that warpage of dimensional lumber (8/4 and larger) is greatly reduced. I personally have had almost no warpage from stickered air-dried 4/4 y.poplar but I'm guessing that's because 1" boards dry so fast.

JKJ

PS: Ellis, I haven't forgotten - I'm still on the lookout for persimmon for you that has significant black. So far no joy - every one I've cut has had pencil-thin black heart. However, I've been offered another tree so who knows.

Re: Yellow Poplar...

#4

Ellis Walentine

Persimmon

Ellis Walentine

>Thanks, John. If and when is time enough. I am somewhat pessimistic about finding a section of black persimmon heart that I can get enough black wood out of without including the pith, because, as you know, that stuff expands like nobody's business.

My bigger problem these days is finding the time to turn. :-/

Cheers,

Ellis

Re: Yellow Poplar...

#5

Dale Lenz

Re: Persimmon

Dale Lenz

>I've had the word out 15+ years for some persimmon heart of size. I'm still waiting, : " (

Re: Yellow Poplar...

#6

Re: Not sure I follow you

john l. blue

>Yeah, it was sorta rough when I got around all them limbs.

But, no, it's a 30 footer i cut down, cut it to a 15 ft pole,

just wonderin' how long to let it sit afore treatin' it, and

what's the best stuff to treat it with? Thanks in advance! Blue

Re: Yellow Poplar...

#7

Re: Persimmon

john l. blue

>I'm not sure what you talking about, but Persimmon is

all around where I live in the Sandhills of N.C. blue

Re: Yellow Poplar...

#8

Dale Lenz

Re: Persimmon heartwood

Dale Lenz

>Persimmon is part of the Ebony genius, has coal back heartwood, at least in the green state. As you could guess, a black wood would be nice to have, with out paying for "true" ebony. The problem with persimmon heartwood is the amount in a tree. Most mature trees have a relatively large amount of heartwood in their lumber making stems. Persimmon has a very small amount of heartwood, apparently even in large stems, logs, not much larger than your big toe. As you know, pith-wood of hardwood trees will crack and warp like crazy, so...getting any usable heartwood out of a persimmon tree would be difficult. Like most things in the biological world there may be a few persimmons with a relative large share of heartwood, thats what Ellis and myself have been looking for.

Re: Yellow Poplar...

#9

Re: Not sure I follow you

John McGaw

>Ellis wasn't following you and it appears that I don't either. Why would you want to treat it with anything? The only time anyone does that is to give the wood some sort of unnatural characteristics -- such as surviving contact with the ground, resisting insects, repelling moisture, resisting checking, etc.

What are your final aims for this wood? Is it going to be cut into lumber or will it be left whole? What is it going to be used for in the end?

Re: Yellow Poplar...

#10

pole, "last forever"?

John K Jordan

>>...cut it to a 15 ft pole, just wonderin' how long to let it sit

>afore treatin' it, and what's the best stuff to treat it with?

Are you planning to set it into the ground as a post? If you want it to "last forever" as you mentioned in your original message, either you are joking and I am wasting my time writing this or you are serious and wasting your time - give up and buy a pole.

Y.poplar is a horrible wood for ground contact. Untreated, a y.poplar post might last 2-7 years. Pressure treated it should last 20-26 years by the charts. However, pressure treating is not generally a home process. You can buy a properly pressure treated 15' pole at many farm and co-op stores. A cheap alternative is to make a pole from a black locust tree which will not need treatment.

Home treatment by dipping or soaking or coating is marginally effective. From my favorite fence book, properly treated posts are kiln dried before and after treating. If treated while green, chemicals cannot penetrate to the core. The outside will look solid while the core slowly rots away. According to that book, a possible exception is the use of a solution of borate salts (Tim-Bor) on freshly cut green posts. Note that Hoadley's book (reference below) lists y.poplar as "difficult" to treat on a scale of "least difficult, moderately difficult, difficult, and very difficult".

Some good references on treating wood for ground contact are Hoadley's book "Understanding Wood" and the fence book I mentioned, "Fences for Pasture & Garden" by Gail Damerow.

JKJ

Re: Yellow Poplar...

#11

Dale, and Ellis

Keith Newton, LR, Arkansas------WebKitFormBoundary

>I am not so sure that the blackness is just a matter of being heartwood. I think it is more like mineral streaks due to the sap being exposed from an injury. At least that is what it seemed like I was seeing in the last couple of trees that i found it in.

Unlike in most trees, just having a mineral streak up and down the grain from an injury, or along a line straight in toward the heart, it seems like I recall, there was a V pattern to it in cross section, with the injury at the bottom of the V, and the legs to either side of the pith.

Maybe that was coincidence, but maybe that was how the moisture that moves in and out would move.

The loggers did a clear-cut in the bottom woods across from my camp a few months ago. They left a couple of truck loads of pretty inferior logs over there in a loose pile. I think I spotted a couple of persimmon logs in the piles. When the river goes down, I will try to remember to take a saw over and sample them for another look.

Re: Yellow Poplar...

#12

Dale Lenz

Re: Dale, and Ellis

Dale Lenz

>Keith,

What I believe you are referring to is called compartmentalization, where a tree isolates the injured wood away from the healthy wood. The compartmentalization wood is often darker than the healthy wood. Sycamore has a lot of this around bug invasion, Ambrosia, I think. I intentionally use the injured wood, doctored up, in my woodwork as it give the piece added character.