Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

OT - new laptop - Linux?? Dan?

Posts

OT - new laptop - Linux?? Dan?

#1

OT - new laptop - Linux?? Dan?

Carol - now in NC Nebraska

>My ol' tank of an IBM ThinkPad has become unreliable. It goes to sleep and fails to wake up. The local geek shop got it running again and failed to get it to fail. So they speculate that there is a bad connection in the power train somewhere, and it will cost the earth to repair.

Time to replace it, me thinks. It the past I have purchased used ones and generally feel I have gotten my money's worth. This time I may go with a new one - looking at the Lenova ThinkPad. Would love to try a Mac but my checkbook sneered at me when presented with the proposition.

The issue, I think, is with operating systems. I am not eager to go to Vista. I can get one with XP, but that seems to have diminishing returns.

So the question is, can a laptop run with Linux? Any particular things I need to know when ordering the hardware with the idea to install this OS? Where can I get some help with this project? Sites, etc.?

Thanks.

Re: OT - new laptop - Linux?? Dan?

#2

Re: OT - new laptop - Linux?? Dan?

Bill Howatt

>If you really want Linux I would go to a computer store that specializes in Linux so they can get it setup properly for you. I have read a number of articles from Linux gurus outlining installing some variant of Linux on machines and am always amazed at some of the complex gyrations necessary to get things like wireless network running.

The other thing, and this is very important, is to check out whether or not the applications you wish to run have a Linux version unless you want to fool with an emulator.

Bill

Re: OT - new laptop - Linux?? Dan?

#3

Yes! *LINK*

Craig Daymon

>I installed the Debian Linux distribution on a relatively high end laptop with only one VERY minor issue at my last job, about 2 months ago. This was a Sager laptop from Power Notebooks. It had a dual core Intel processor in it with 3GB of RAM and a 100GB hard drive. It had a 17" screen with a 1920x1200 resolution. It was VERY fast! Total price (since Power Notebooks will sell it without an operating system) was about $2020. I think it was the Sager NP5793 with additional RAM, upgraded processor, the Nvidia 8700M GT video card, 1920x1200 screen and the 100GB hard drive upgrades.

The only minor problem was that running at that higher resolution, the DPI on the screen was higher than on our typical 24" screens we used with the desktops. This resulted in our text being bigger than desired for the application we were trying to demo on the laptop. This should NOT be an issue for anyone using the laptop as their primary machine.

If you did want to alter it, there is a setting that goes in the "Display" section of the Xorg.conf file that corrects the issue. You might need to do a web search to find the exact settings.

-Craig


Power Notebooks

Re: OT - new laptop - Linux?? Dan?

#4

Debian is an easy install, Ubuntu even easier. *LINK*

Craig Daymon

>There are well over a hundred different distributions of Linux. Of those, Debian and Ubuntu are near the top in popularity. If you want it to work/look a little more like Windows, install the KDE desktop. There is a version of Ubuntu called, Kubuntu, that will do this automatically for you. Fedora is the free version of RedHat.

More important than whether a particular application is available is whether there is an application that will do what you want. I edit Microsoft Word documents with Open Office and save them without any problem. Open Office (which is available free for Windows as well) has everything MS Office has and a program or two more. (I don't think MS Office has a drawing program.)

Since you would be new to this, Ubuntu or Kubuntu might be your best choices. There are a number of specialized distributions for different groups, but I haven't found a woodworker's distribution yet. Mostly for teachers, scientific, multimedia and for special platforms, like the XBox.

-Craig


DistroWatch - Linux Distribution information

Re: OT - new laptop - Linux?? Dan?

#5

I've got three going now...

John in New Mexico

>One dual boot XP and PClinuxOS, one semi-antique running just PCLOS, and one really antique running Damn Small Linux. The most modern machine was really fairly trivial to set up, the semi-antique needed a little fussing to get the sound working, but not something that required a lot of skill just some creative thinking, and the DSL machine works well with a direct install but has a few problems like not printing that I've never bothered to fix, having other options.

I'd say in general if you mostly do your own windows maintenance and minor fixing you'll find linux much easier to cope with than windows. If you tend to send it out, then you'll hear lots of "oh, we can't do that" - so a mac would be perhaps a better option. Most linux distributions are available now as live CD's. You can download them and burn a CD as a bootable system that runs without installation on your hard-drive. Great for trying out different flavors (most are free, though its awfully nice to send a donation if you like it), and also very helpful for system recovery if you're up for that kind of work.

If you're still interested, check out www.distrowatch.com. Somewhat informational, mostly useful as an index of popular distributions with links to reviews and download mirrors.

Re: OT - new laptop - Linux?? Dan?

#6

Thinkpads aren't the same as they used to be....

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>I don't sell/support alot of ThinkPads, but they sure don't seem to be the bulletproof, neverfail laptops they used to be.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT - new laptop - Linux?? Dan?

#7

Re: Thinkpads aren't the same as they used to be..

Carol - now in NC Nebraska

>So you would suggest.....

....something you would sell/support???

Re: OT - new laptop - Linux?? Dan?

#8

Re: OT - new laptop - Linux?? Dan? *LINK*

Dan Donaldson

>Like all answers, It depends. Linux is getting more and more mainstream and form, it is much easier to work with, stable, and also free ;-) This does come at a price though, and that is that anyone contemplating it will have a learning curve.

Take a look at the link. There is a lot of information there. Particularly read the "Is Linux for You" item.

In general, you can get very good results with any computer, but you need to do some homework to make sure that the hardware you want to use is supported. If it is, installation is usually a breeze, if it is obscure or not well supported, then it can be a nightmare.

As someone mentioned, if you are thinking about Linux, go to a store where they know about it to make sure you get the right hardware.

If you can do so without costing yourself too much, I would recommend getting an XP machine with the proper hardware, and then playing with the live CD for linux for awhile. It will run slow because it is on a cd rather than a hard drive, but you can get the flavor without modifying your computer. If it works well for you, then install it as dual boot with Windows to give yourself time to learn. Then if you like it and can get it figured out, you can dump Windows, or if you really need it for some specific thing, run Windows in a Virtual box.

Take a look Here and get a feel for the forums. I have had very good luck at getting help and with very few exceptions, no one looks down on beginners. (or, like here, the ones that do get hammered by the rest of the community ;-))

Read the stuff, and then if you have questions, shoot me a note, or if you like, let me know and I can send you a phone number if that would be easier for you. Good luck, it is a fun ride ;-)


Linux info

Re: OT - new laptop - Linux?? Dan?

#9

Don't give up on Mac

Joe Pack

>The 13" Macbook is a great laptop. I was skeptical about the 13" screen, but when I went to an Apple Store to check it out, it was much easier to see than I thought it would be. The screen is almost as wide as the 15" she has now, just shorter. With the SuperDrive, 160 gb hard drive and standard warranty, it will run about $1300 (3 yr. warranty/tech help is extra). It is WiFi ready, and has an opperating system that is almost crashproof. If you will not be doing DVD editing, the Apple Store techs told me the regular Combo Drive instead of the dual layer SuperDrive will do everything you ever need, but for $200 less.

The Mac OS will read/save MS Office documents/files. I-Works is a fantastic word processing/document program Go one step farther and pick up Office for Mac (the OLDER edition, not the newest) and you have the best of all worlds.

I suffered through the XP horrors (service packs, conflicts that neither Microsoft or the vendor would own...) on my own desktop PC and finally returned to Mac (a 20" I-Mac dual OS). Multiply those horrors by 27 or more and you have the hassles I have endured with my wife's laptop. They are so bad that I refuse to install anymore "updates" from Microsoft...all they do is blow the computer again. She has 2 months left in the school year. All of her school records are on her laptop. I don't want to lose them, so we will endure two more months. But she will have the 13" Macbook on her desk next August.

If you can get to a retailer, check out the 13" Macbook. Great things DO come in small packages!

Re: OT - new laptop - Linux?? Dan?

#10

Re: OT - new laptop - Linux?? Dan?

Chuck Taylor

>I have a laptop that I set up to dual-boot so that it runs either Vista or Ubuntu Linux. I'm normally a die-hard Linux fan, but I've found a couple of issues with Linux on a laptop. The main one is that it doesn't always wake up from hibernation, and the other is that it is sometimes a little flaky about connecting to wi-fi. I find that I boot it to Vista most of the time. I'm not a big Vista fan, but it has worked reliably for me for over a year now. The only application I have encountered that doesn't work on Vista is a certain VPN (and if you don't know what that is, you don't need it).

If you do decide to go with Linux, make sure that you get a laptop with the Intel wi-fi chip (better Linux compatibility than Broadcom) and built-in bluetooth (for a wireless mouse). Come to think of it, you should look for those same things for Vista.

Re: OT - new laptop - Linux?? Dan?

#11

Re: Thinkpads aren't the same as they used to be..

Howard Norman

>Carol, I bought my last Thinkpad almost three years ago. It as well as my previous Thinkpads have been great machines. I expect that the quality may have gone down some since IBM is no longer involved but I would still buy another Thinkpad today if I needed a new laptop. One on my sons bought a new Thinkpad about three months ago and it is a great machine.

Howard

Re: OT - new laptop - Linux?? Dan?

#12

Why not XP?

Curly Smith

>SP3 will ship sometime in the 2nd quarter of this year and XP support won't end until at least 2014. There's also a very large user base that refuses to move to Vista (or, in many cases, move back to Vista). The OS won't quit running when MS throws the switch, although MS would like it to, so you won't be impacted by the lack of support. You *might* have some difficulty finding new software after 2014 but, unless you're running cutting-edge software, most software is backward compatible.

What's the projected lifespan of your laptop? Are you planning to buy all new software or just load your existing stuff - the stuff than now presumably runs on XP?

There's nothing wrong with Linux but there's nothing wrong with XP either and it might be a whole lot simpler for you.

Re: OT - new laptop - Linux?? Dan?

#13

I sit here and type this on a Dell

Dustmaker Mike

>I use alot of Dell laptops at work. We have something in the neighbor of 15,000 or so right now. I have three I use daily. I bought the LOML a SONY VIAO a few years ago and she loves it. I liked the look size and weight of it. We have not had one problem with it (knock on wood). I would buy another one in a heart beat.

Re: OT - new laptop - Linux?? Dan?

#14

Why I don't own 3 ThinkPads

Ron in Drums PA

>I own 3 laptops and two of them are ThinkPads. The oldest ThinkPad is 10+ years old and still going strong. I use it in my shop to run WoodTurnerPro, FireFox and a couple of other programs.

At one time ThinkPads where built like tanks. But since Lenevo (a Chinese company) purchased the product line, the quality has greatly depreciated. Repairs are handled by Solectron and there have been numerous complaints about unsatisfactory repairs and overcharges from users.

Now you know why I don't own 3 Thinkpads.

Re: OT - new laptop - Linux?? Dan?

#15

Concerning Linux

Jerry

>If you would like a Linux laptop and don't want to spend a lot of time searching Linux forums trying to learn how to make your computer do what you want, I would suggest looking at Dell's lineup of Laptops with Ubuntu Linux already installed and working. Beside that, the denizens of the Linux forums are far less polite than the folks here on the woodworking forums. I do quite a bit of playing with different Linux distributions (my primary desktop and my laptops are still 100% Windows) but then I am just a geriatric technogeek.

Jerry

Re: OT - new laptop - Linux?? Dan?

#16

Good first timer package from The Linux Store *LINK*

Craig Daymon

>There looks to be a good package for a Linux first timer available at the Linux Store. It includes the 7.10 release of Ubuntu and all packages (programs) available (6 DVDs of programs) along with the book, "Ubuntu for Non-Geeks". They sell it for about $48, which is not bad for 6 DVDs and a book.

-Craig

P.S. With the full bundle of packages, you can choose to install KDE to geat a more "Windows-like" look.


Ultimate Ubuntu 7.10 Package at the Linux Store

Re: OT - new laptop - Linux?? Dan?

#17

KDE

Jerry

>I have heard the comment about KDE looking more like Windows numerous times but I have tried several Linux distributions having the KDE desktop and I can't really see that it is anymore "Windows like" than gnome. After trying KDE, fluxbox, and Xcfe, I still find that I prefer gnome but that is just me and others will have their own preferences. Presently, in addition to playing with Ubuntu 8.04, I have one removable drive set up to dual boot Ubuntu 7.10 and LinuxMint 4.0 with a common /home partition. I think I like LinuxMint a little better but the Ubuntu forums are far more active. Of course most of the information on Ubuntu also applies to LinuxMint. I am very interested in seeing LinuxMint 5 in a couple of months.

Jerry

Re: OT - new laptop - Linux?? Dan?

#18

Re: Why not XP?

Carol - now in NC Nebraska

>That is interesting and good news about XP. Thanks, Curly. I am much more comfortable adding XP back into the mix.

Re: OT - new laptop - Linux?? Dan?

#19

Re: Why I don't own 3 ThinkPads

Carol - now in NC Nebraska

>I like my "real" ThinkPads. They are built like tanks! But...I heard that Lenova took the ThinkPad down the trail towards the landfill.

Now I need to decide on make and model of hardware. Dell and Gateway have proprietary issues for me. And my classmates steer away from them as well. Sony and Toshiba are still in the running. HP not so.

Any other comments about brands and models?

Re: OT - new laptop - Linux?? Dan?

#20

OT - desireable Laptop features?

Carol - now in NC Nebraska

>Help me design my dream laptop. Assume I cannot afford the MacBook.

Maybe it would be helpful to know the features I think I need.

Reasonable proven robust construction.

Biggest screen - old age is hard on the eyes.

Ability to connect a projector or second monitor (large flat screen TV?) - for PowerPoint presentations and watching DVD's.

Wireless - I travel some - nice feature for road warriors. Also runs my GPS in the car. (via USB and power inverter).

DVD/CD RW combo drive - though I have to learn how to more effectively use this feature :)

Fast as I can afford - comments, please, on processor speed and whatever other kinds of speed I might be concerned about. Must handle DV video.

Hate swizzle stick cursor control. Have no experience with a touch pad. Would rather use a wireless mouse. Can the receiver for this be integral, or must I use a USB port?

Battery type?

Anything I missed that you thought useful? The above is what I use it for now.

New, or proven used.

XP over Vista - waaay over! Linux is a serious possibility.

Dislike Dell & Gateway & HP - proprietary reasons. Still in the running - Toshiba and Sony. Any others I might consider?

Under $1000 - the further under the better! Have sympathy. I am still a student.

Thoughts, comments, recommendations, opinions, etc.?

Make and model, please. Source?

Re: OT - new laptop - Linux?? Dan?

#21

All laptops are pretty much

Dustmaker Mike

>what you see is what you get. So with that said Dell Gateway Compaq and HP Desktops are well I will not say it here this is a family fourm. Laptops on the other hand are not really upgradeable anyway. Maybe some ram or new hard drive but not to much more then that. You could use the PCMCIA to add features or USB. I like the SONY and Dell laptops. The only other laptops I have worked with are HP Compaq, I am not impressed. My Daughter just bought a Dell Latitude for under 1k and it is pretty nice. She got it from Dell recondiditioned or used site. It comes with the same warrenty as a new one but she got upgraded RAM and Hard Drive size. The Sony I bought my wife has a nice wide display nice and clear. Just about any laptop will do Video out to a projector. The DV out will be the tough one to find under the 1k mark.

Good Luck

Re: OT - new laptop - Linux?? Dan?

#22

Re: OT - desireable Laptop features?

Ron in Drums PA

>After using a ThinkPad, you will find the typical consumer class laptop under $1000 a piece of junk. There is a reason why they are cheap and the further under $1000 the crappier they are.

No free ride here.

Buy a business class laptop, they last a whole lot longer

Re: OT - new laptop - Linux?? Dan?

#23

Re: OT - desireable Laptop features?

David Yoho

>We have two business class HP laptops here and both have been excellent. You might have trouble finding a laptop to do all you listed for under $1000.

David

Re: OT - new laptop - Linux?? Dan?

#24

Re: OT - desireable Laptop features?

Carol - now in NC Nebraska

>I wonder what I listed?? My old ThinkPad does all of that. The only thing it doesn't have is the touch pad. It has a swizzle stick.

OK, I just remembered, it only has a CD drive - read only. But I have seen DVD/CD RW combo drives on the used sites for less than $600. My understanding is that they play a DVD, but can read or burn a CD. My head screwed up on this feature?

So Sony or Toshiba? I can get a real IBM with XP for even less. I have set aside the Mac idea until I am out of school and earning a living again. One more year. Then a year to catch up on money. So two years to a Mac. The least I've gotten out of a used ThinkPad was 3-1/2 years.

Only one of you commented on the Sony. Nobody using Toshiba's? They get good reviews on the web.

Re: OT - new laptop - Linux?? Dan?

#25

Re: OT - desireable Laptop features?

Dan Donaldson

>I really don't have much knowledge about laptops. I don't need the portability and am not willing to give up the performance and better reliability of the desktop.