>I am going to be putting a fence up in the backyard on my vacation (yeah, I know it sounds like work) and I need a bit of advice. The fence will be 42" x 96" sections of French Gothic preasure-treat, with 4" x 4" posts to attach to. My query is this...6 ft 4x4's on the runs with 8 ft 4x4's on the corners and ends...will the 6 footers be deep enough at 29" buried? Also, I'm not sure how much concrete (Quickrete) I'll need for each post. Will a 40lb bag be enough, or should I use an 80lb bag? The instructions on the bag say to dig the hole 3 times the width of the post, and fill slightly higher than the level of the ground, then slope the top. But I'm not able to visualize how much concrete that will be. I think I need to go back in for a brain/eye/wallet calibration again. Thanx in advance for your advice.
>Here's an easier alternative and just as strong: Auger the hole deep enough to also hold a few inches of stone in the bottom for drainage, then pack the post in place with stone dust or fine gravel, i.e. pound it solid with a piece of 2x4. Go back and pound again a few months later. Far less work and cheaper, too.
My grandfather was a farmer and something of a craftsman. He built barns and fences on the farm he bought in World War II. He was the man all the surrounding farmers turned to when they wanted something built. He told me that only a city slicker would set a post in concrete. Put some gravel in the bottom of the hole and stand the post on it and fill the hole with more gravel. It will allow the water to drain freely and help keep the post dry. Use crushed stones with sharp angles, not round river stone. The broken stone locks together better.
29" should be deep enough in the ground. I have a six foot tall fence that had posts only two feet in the ground and they were fine until two sections blew over recently. The posts were four by fours and they broke. So the gravel was stronger than the posts.
>Stuart, I don't know where you are located. Do you need to consider the depth of the posts below ground, to account for freezing in winter? When I put up fencing for my cattle paddocks, I put the posts almost 4 feet down so that the winter freeze-up wouldn't heave them out of the ground.
And I did the old farmer trick -- I put the post in the hole on top of some stones for drainage, and then poured in a bag of dry concrete mix and a bucket of water. I filled the rest of the hole with packed dirt. With time, the dry concrete mix absorbs the moisture from the surrounding ground and it all sets hard as a rock.
On the other hand, if you don't have the top few feet of your ground frozen solid all winter, please ignore this message!
Charles (whose 3000 pound bulls never defeated these fences)
>>...will the 6 footers be deep enough at 29" buried?
Absolutely. If you use any concrete at all, set the post on gravel, pack gravel/dirt around the bottom, then make a concrete collar near the top. However, I never use concrete on wooden fence posts. A properly tamped post set that deep will not move.
Absolutely the best tool for tamping is a bar available at HD, a flat puck on one end and a digging/root-cutting edge on the other.
>Reading the above posts, I noticed that most folks say don't use concrete around fence posts. Reasons for that make sense, but what about if there's a roof attached to those posts, that could catch wind and given significant "lift" to the post? I'm getting ready to build a roof for my dog kennel, and will be putting posts in the ground. I'm a little hesitant to just pack gravel around the posts - I can see how that would be find if most of your force (wind or otherwise) is horizontal, but with wind under a roof, couldn't it just lift the posts out? Concrete ususally gives pretty good adhesion to the posts. Any thoughts?
Yikes, have you tried pulling posts out of the ground? I've pulled many fence posts when moving pens around the barn. Most were 4x4 PT sunk into the ground 36", mostly with dirt tamped by hand into a 9" hole drilled with an auger. The only way I can get the posts out is to wrap a chain around them and pull them out with the front end loader on my tractor. How big will the roof be? Are there any trees or other windbreak? I'm having difficulty imagining the wind pulling out the posts unless the posts are few, roof is large, and the wind is very strong (hurricane?).
But since you are building a structure instead of a fence, using concrete is easy enough. As mentioned, don't set the post down into a mass of concrete or moisture in the post cannot drain. Instead, put gravel or rocks in the bottom of the hole, set the post, fill a few inches around the bottom with gravel and tamp, then add concrete. For maximum holding power, expand the hole a bit so it is a little narrower at the top. Increase the "holding power" of the concrete by driving large galvanized nails into the wood before setting the post.
Fence contractors sometimes shortcut the concrete mixing by dumping dry concrete mix into the hole then dumping in some water. Natural moisture from the ground and from rain will also set the mix. (Let a a bag of concrete mix get wet and see how easy it sets up!) I've also seen contractors mix cement with the dirt that came from the hole and use it for concrete but I'm not sure I like that method, even though it would be the cheapest.