Rob Cosman Videos
Wayne Carson "TX"
>Has anyone viewed his videos on dove tail making. Are they worth the money??
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Rob Cosman Videos
Wayne Carson "TX"
>Has anyone viewed his videos on dove tail making. Are they worth the money??
Re: Rob Cosman Videos
jerry mayfield
>I have all his videos and they are great.
Regards
Jerry
highly recommended
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>We used it for the club dovetail courses. I consider it the best resource on the topic.
Re: Rob Cosman Videos
ScottS
>Cosman's videos are well-produced, informative, and entertaining. I received his dovetail video and "Rough to Ready" for Christmas. The dovetail video does a good job of explaining the steps necessary to produce a hand-cut dovetail joint. If I have any criticism, it's that Cosman makes the process look almost too simple. With a smile, and a workshop full of high-end Lie-Nielsen tools, Cosman makes you think that cutting the perfect dovetail joint should be a walk in the park. Those without the ability to saw accurately to a line or pare deftly with a chisel may find that executing the joint it more difficult than Cosman makes it appear.
It's been a while since I've watched the video, but I don't remember if Cosman spends much time talking about basic technique or how to fix a joint if you ruin it with a newbie mistake. I know I've seen both, I just can't remember if they were in the Cosman video or some other. In any event, I was quite happy to receive the Cosman video and would definitely suggest it to anyone who already has some hand tool experience. If you have NO hand tool experience, it's still a good video but you may need to spend some time on basic techniques (e.g. sawing to a line) before the video is truly useful.
See my reviews in the Articles Section
Garrett in Victoria
>
And get his new shop manual.
Charles R. Smith
>I would agree with the other opinions that the DVDs are excellent. I watched the three of them in the order they were released -- Hand-Cut Dovetails, then Advanced Hand-Cut Dovetails and finally Mastering the Dovetail Saw. But I agree with Rob that one would benefit from watching the Dovetail Saw DVD first.
An added bonus is his new shop manual, which gives you the information in the DVDs in a practical way that you can use it in the shop, almost like having him standing beside you. I think he has a combination DVD/book special on his website (robcosman.com).
Maybe you should buy the DVD/book package. Since Rob is no longer representing Lie-Nielson in Canada, he could probably use the business. Especially since baby number 10 is one the way. :)
Charles (who learned to cut dovetails thanks to Rob's DVDs and manual)
Re: Rob Cosman Videos
Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.
>I have the first one of the series, "hand-cut dovetails". Excellent overall, this video has had more influence on how I do my dovetails than any other source. I don't follow his methods religiously, but the influence is definitely there.
I also have the one about Alan Peters, and that one gives me an uncomfortable meeting... Not because of what's presented, but because Alan is definitely not in very good shape in there, I would have liked to see him in better shape in there, but there's nothing one can do about that... That video should have been shot 10 years earlier IMHO...
DC
a case for a good saw
Bill Tindall, E.TN
>A quality saw will greatly help you to learn to saw reliably. The problem is there is not unanimity on which quality saw is best. I can't saw with a Japanese pull saw, but some students in our classes take to it much better than a western saw. Anyway, if you are having trouble learning to saw reliably and you have a cheap saw, a better saw may help a lot. I use a LN saw.
Re: Rob Cosman Videos - uncomfortable
North of the Border
>I don't own the Alan vid and I only saw the trailer on Rob's website. But yes, my first impression was that Alan looked fragile and his voice was weak. I don't know if he's as old as Sam Maloof but Sam seems to be much physically stronger at least in appearance. No disrespect in any sense to Alan and it certainly is no fault of anyone that he was what he was in the vid. Most celebrated woodworkers are old and we just hope they'll be around for decades to come and to share with us their woodworking glorious time. As we all get old one day (if we aren't old enough yet) and I guess it's part of human nature that we'd rather be old than be seen old.