Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

TS technique: anyone else find this dangerous

Posts

TS technique: anyone else find this dangerous

#1

TS technique: anyone else find this dangerous

Dan Mitchell

>Saw this technique in "Time Life Books, The Art of Woodworking: Shaper Furniture". It's part of a plan for a bench. The technique involves pushing the workpiece laterally across the TS blade to mill a dished out section in the bench seat. Anyone ever do this? Seems risky to me. Apparently uses a non-dado blade, though I'm not sure if that's better or worse.

The instructions read "Cutting the recess in the seat top. Adjust the blade to a cutting height of 1/16 inch. Slowly feed the seat across the table with one hand, while pressing it against the guide board with the other. Make as many passes as necessary until the blade outline on the end of the stock disappears (left), raising the blade 1/16 inch at a time. For a smooth finish, raise the blade very slightly and make a final pass".

Dan


img

Re: TS technique: anyone else find this dangerous

#2

Book title should be "Shaker Furniture"

Dan Mitchell

>

Re: TS technique: anyone else find this dangerous

#3

JL

Re: Cove cutting...

JL

>It is typically done when cutting coves. Yes, it is dangerous. I'd prefer to have two "fences" and do it at an angle.

When I shape seats, I typically use my angle grinder.

Re: TS technique: anyone else find this dangerous

#4

Re: TS technique: anyone else find this dangerous

John McGaw

>Looks like the standard cove-cutting procedure applied to a different task. Done as shown it probably is a bit dangerous. But if two "fences" are used a piece of plywood can be bridged between them to keep fingers from getting too close to the blade. The addition of a couple of fingerboards to apply downward pressure will make the cut more controllable. My biggest problem with the method is not safety but that I never seem to be able to achieve the profile that I want.

Re: TS technique: anyone else find this dangerous

#5

Re: TS technique: anyone else find this dangerous

steve mackay

>I've also done it with two fences. Just useing one I've had slop movement that really butchered it with just a small slip. And that last " finnishing " pass doesn't get it. When you get off the TS theres a whole lotta sand'n go'n on.

Re: TS technique: anyone else find this dangerous

#6

I've done that, but with featherboards

John in New Mexico

>But usually when making molding. As others have said, its a bit of a pain to clean up, but a pretty useful techinique.

Re: TS technique: anyone else find this dangerous

#7

Rookie teaching woodworking 101

Keith Newton, LR, Arkansas------WebKitFormBoundary

>For starts, it looks like they are starting with 4/4 lumber, thinning it to 3/8", Yep, I like that!

But I don't see a lot of danger.

Next, a saw blade is designed to cut wood which is fed into it from straight on. A better way is to use some sort of shaper cutter, with the top of the cutter tilted toward the direction from which the lumber is being fed. Something with a cove profile toward the top will give a much better finish.

Feeding more from the front, angling across at an angle, rather than straight across will help with presenting the work to the proper cutting edge.

I fail to see how a second fence provides anything. I would like to know what I may be missing, if someone can explain the hazard, or benefit.

Re: TS technique: anyone else find this dangerous

#8

Re: TS technique: anyone else find this dangerous

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla

>Almost everything done on a table saw has a degree of danger. Your example is pretty high up in degrees. I have done it numerous times with extreme care and in very small increases in the height of the blade. I worked in a shop in the early 80's and saw a fellow remove just about the entire amount of flesh on his palm and fingers in a heart beat. Of course he was badly hungover and didn't pay attention.

He couldn't stay around to clean all the blood off the machine, so it was left for the rest of us to do while he was rushed to the hospital.

Never saw him again because he couldn't return to work before I left that shop to work in another.

Re: TS technique: anyone else find this dangerous

#9

Re: TS technique: anyone else find this dangerous

David Yoho

>Dan, I've cut coves on my tablesaw without issue. However, I'd never try what they're showing in the illustration.

When I've used that technique, I always clamped two fences on my saw for the exact width of stock I was cutting. Raise the blade for very minimal cuts each time until you cut out the profile you want. The shape of the cove profile is influenced by the angle the at which stock is presented to the blade. It can also be influenced by the tilt of the blade. I always use push paddles like usually come with a jointer. I really like the ones I got from the Shop Smith store online. They're bigger and beefier than the normal ones you see around.

In the end, be prepared for a lot of sanding or scraping to get a good smooth surface for finishing.

I'm starting to replace that method with the Horizontal Crown Molding Bits from Eagle America and Infinity with my router table. Just draw the outline on the end of the stock and set the bit height to take light cuts, staying within the outline. Move the fence as needed and work until done. This takes a little more time but I like not having to work as hard cleaning the profile up and I feel like it's safer.

David

Re: TS technique: anyone else find this dangerous

#10

Ellis Walentine

Caution!

Ellis Walentine

>Tablesaw coving is a well-known practice and just requires a few extra precautions unique to this technique. That said, I found a few things confusing if not troubling about the illustration.

First, the amount of material he's taking off. The text may say to do it in 1/16" increments, but the illo is saying do it all at once. That will cause the blade to deflect and heat up, which could in turn make the blade start to wobble because of the metal expansion.

Second, the illustration doesn't make the blade direction clear enough. Someone who isn't familiar with this technique or who isn't mechanical enough to figure it out might think they can get away with a fence on the wrong side of the workpiece. Two fences can help keep the piece from camming up off the table, but decent downward pressure like David suggested works just as well, and there is no blade force directed to the outboard side fence, so one is technically adequate.

Third, I've never done this technique at right angles to the blade. It's usually done at some oblique angle that allows the cut to be made with the tips of the teeth. The trouble with the perpendicular arrangement shown here is that all the force is directly against the side of the blade. There is no forward vector at all. If you're going to do that, you should be using a blade that has a pronounced side relief, or else the tendency to burn will be exaggerated. The smoothest cuts by far for this type of operation, with the least damage to the cutter, are made with a molding head with a half-round cutting profile. It eases nicely into and out of the cut and leaves a very nice surface compared to the scratchy surface left by a carbide saw blade.

Ellis

Re: TS technique: anyone else find this dangerous

#11

tips on setting up for a cove cut

Robin Corell in Atascadero, CA

>A couple responses mentioned the difficulty in making the initial set up for a cove cut. I use an adjustable parallelogram to make the set up quick and accurate. The parallelogram is just two long sticks (36") and two short sticks (12") connected at the corners with machine screws and wing nuts.

The parallelogram is set at the width and the blade is set to the depth of the required cove. Place the parallelogram over the blade and adjust the angle of the parallelogram to the blade until the appropriate tooth makes contact at the front and the back. I use a fine line sharpie to mark the opening of the parallelogram in several places so I can then measure for the un coved portion of the board and then position my fence(s). Be sure to lower the blade before making the first pass.

Due to the fact that the blade is not making a cut that separates two pieces of wood there is no chance of binding and a greatly reduced risk of kickback when making a cove cut. I will add that by using two fences the risk of binding is re introduced. I do occasionally use two fences and I run all my stock through with the saw off to make sure nothing binds. Also be aware that your out feed support may need to be changed.

I have also found that using a non thin kerf ripping blade gives a significantly smoother finish and that I can remove as much material as the radial height of the carbide tooth (1/4�) in each pass but I reduce that to about 1/32� for the final pass and reduce my feed speed by half. The results still require a bit of sanding but not as much.

Robin

Re: TS technique: anyone else find this dangerous

#12

Re: Grr-Rippers make this a lot safer

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>in my mind. However it is a standard technique. Since I purchased my set of Grr-Rippers, I feel a whole lot safer with one of them between my saw blade, router bit or joiner cutters and my fingers. I slipped off a piece of wood once and "planed" the bottom of my left thumb. I really didn't like the results although I did heal ok. Since that time I ALWAYS use the grippers when doing any operation like this. If it does slip (never has so far), I can replace the Gripper for a whole lot less than the cost of the E-room (and without pain or blood).

Re: TS technique: anyone else find this dangerous

#13

Re: Anyone else find this dangerous? - Yup.

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

>I've read and seen pictures of this technique at least a dozen times. I don't like the 90 degree angle to the blade. Too much side pressure as Ellis has pointed out in his response. The illustration gives me chills. The blade has no way of easing into the material and once it does, looks like an accident waiting to happen. I would want a mess of hold downs and fingerboards on a setup like this.....if.....if there was no other way or if you didn't have more tools at your disposal.

As I sit here typing I can picture a real simple jig that could be built that would make doing this with a router a whole lot safer.

There's more than one way to skin a cat as the saying goes.

My 2 cents worth,

Ray

Re: TS technique: anyone else find this dangerous

#14

Re: TS technique: anyone else find this dangerous

Dan Mitchell

>Thanks for the interesting replies. I'm not planning to build anything with such a detail anytime soon, but the images sure struck me as hair-raising. I also noted how they saw 1/16", then show the blade up all the way, with material down to the table. Yikes.

This reminded me of the person who recently posted pics of several newly-severed digits, a result if I recall of trying to mill out a box with a dado blade.

I can see that running at an angle would make better use of the blade's natural cutting surfaces. If I did use the technique, the additional board would definitely make me feel more secure.

Dan

Re: TS technique: anyone else find this dangerous

#15

"There's more than one way to skin a cat... "

Dan Mitchell

>Like having him try this technique!

Re: TS technique: anyone else find this dangerous

#16

Agree here!

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>That's how I'd do it myself...

DC

Re: TS technique: anyone else find this dangerous

#17

Re: TS technique: anyone else find this dangerous

Barry Irby

>Dan, I have cut a number of coves this way. What I did was tilt the blade so that the cut was made with the tips or the cutting edge of the blade. I also only raised the blade about a 1/32 to a 1/16". A curved card scraper and a five inch ROS made pretty quick work of the clean up. You can cut an amazing variety of coves by changing the tilt and the angle of approach to the blade.