Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Way OT -- Inoperable car door

Posts

Way OT -- Inoperable car door

#1

A.J. Hamler

Way OT -- Inoperable car door

A.J. Hamler

>This is a fishing expedition, in hopes someone else here has experienced this and found a fix.

I can't unlock the back door/hatch of my 2003 Saturn Vue. The locks on the front driver/passenger doors can be locked/unlocked with the remote, with the ignition key from outside, and from inside with the manual lathces. The rear passenger doors can be locked/unlocked with the remote or from inside with the manual latches. The hatch, however, can be locked/unlocked only with the remote -- there is no keyhole on the outside, and no manual latch on the inside. The remote continues to control all other doors normally, but for some reason no longer controls the hatch.

Facts: I have two remotes, and neither controls the hatch anymore. I've replaced the remote batteries with new ones. I've tried the remotes from varying distances, and right up against the door. Very occasionally, about once in 30-40 times I use the remote to unlock the car, the hatch -- Suprise! -- goes "click" and unlocks. However, it will not unlock on subsequent tries. (And, no, once it unlocks on one of these rare occasions I can't simply leave it unlocked -- all car doors lock themselves automatically when the car starts moving.)

Living in Middleofnowhere W.Va, the nearest Saturn dealer is about 85 miles away. While traveling a few weeks ago I saw a Saturn sign off the interstate and pulled in. After explaining my problem to the guy at the service desk, the conversation went like this:

He: It's probably your remote. Just needs a battery replacement.

Me: I don't think so. I have two remotes and they both do it. Plus, I've replaced the batteries in both of them. I think there's something wrong with the door itself.

He: We have batteries here, and I can give you new ones.

Me: They have new batteries.

He: Yeah, but you never know. (chuckles in a friendly manner)

Me: But if that's the case, why do the other four doors work fine? I think there's something wrong with the hatch.

He: Well, if you battery's weak, it may not have enough juice for that door.

At this point he takes my remote, pries it open, and pops the battery halfway across the room where it rolls into oblivion. He goes and locates a new battery and installs it, then suggests we go try it. We stand behind my car, where he notices my license plate.

He: 'Star Trek' fan, huh?

Me: Yeah.

He: (His face brightens) Hey, this is just like a phaser, huh? Well, let's try it.

He points the remote at the car, presses the button. The driver's door goes, "click." He presses the button a second time, and the front passenger and back doors go, "click." The hatch remains locked. Pressing the button a third time, all the doors relock themselves. He continues this cycle several times.

He: Hmmm, I think there's something wrong with the door. I think you'd better bring it in.

Me: But, I am "in."

After explaining I'm from out of town and can't schedule a time to "bring it in," I have to get back on the road to continue our trip. Now, my quandry is that with the nearest Saturn dealer 85 miles away, I can't just drop my car off -- it's either a 170 mile trip where I bring a book to read while I wait for them to get around to working on it, or it's two 170 mile trips if I leave it there and have to go back to get it.

Obviously, the problem seems to be in the remote receiver in that door, but does anybody have any idea what fixing this might entail -- Can I have this done more locally? Can I order a part and do it myself? Is this going to be so expensive that I should try to ignore it till I hit the lottery?

TIA

A.J.

Re: Way OT -- Inoperable car door

#2

Re: Way OT -- Inoperable car door

John E in SC

>This probably won't help you, but I would hazard a guess and say that you probably have a loose wire / bad connection somewhere between the remote receiver and/or battery (of the car) and the hatch lock. I say that because it occasionally opens. I doubt the remote receiver is actually in the hatch. I don't know anything about Saturns, but I think the receiver is usually up near the dash, which then sends the signal to the actuator on the lock. You might try seeing if you can get to the actual latch and start checking wires back from there. With a hatch, there's got to be a pivot point somewhere where wires move / bend every time the hatch opens, so that would be a likely area to check.

Good luck,

John

Re: Way OT -- Inoperable car door

#3

Re: Way OT -- Inoperable car door

John McGaw

>Well, there is no special receiver for that particular door -- they are all controlled centrally. While it could be a programming problem with the locking system it could equally be an intermittent ground/connection problem with the solenoid operating the rear hatch lock. I would lean toward the latter given the way modern cars are wired and assembled. This really should be a simple thing to troubleshoot if/when you get the attention of a competent mechanic possessing the required information -- there just isn't much involved. Simply disconnecting and re-connecting all of the plugs between the controller module and the rear latch and ensuring that any grounds involved are tight and clean would go a long way toward a fix (or so I suspect). If the latch solenoid is disconnected from the harness and the proper power applied it should activate cleanly and quickly and this would confirm that it is operating.

Re: Way OT -- Inoperable car door

#4

Re: Way OT -- Inoperable car door

Lee Schierer - McKean, PA

>It sounds like the door solenoid is not working. In a 4 year old car, I would suspect that the solenoid has gone bad or the mechanism needs lubrication. Put your ear to the hatch and have someone operate the button. You should hear the latch try to open. If you hear it and nothing happens, then the mchanism in the door is not working and the cause is most likely lack of lubrication. If you don't hear anything in the rear door, then it may not be getting a signal or the solenoid coil is bad.

Lee

Re: Way OT -- Inoperable car door

#5

Re: Way OT -- Inoperable car door *LINK*

GolfSteve in Calgary

>Hi A.J.

Sounds like my VW dealer. Your case sound like a perfect fit to my motto:

"If it's broke it probably ain't gonna cost much more if I try to fix it myself".

I found a link on the Internet with info on a similar problem to yours - there's some pictures of how to access to lock mechanism. If I were you I would take it apart and see if you can find the problem. If there are no obvious mechanical problems, get out your multimeter and see if the motor is getting power, etc.

If everything seems to be in working order, probably the part is defective. Order a replacement part and install in yourself. Sometimes you can order OEM replacement parts over the internet at a serious discount to what the dealer charges.

I would also log onto that Saturn forum, do a search for similar problems, and if you can't find an answer, post a question.

Cheers,

Steven

Who has spent waaay too much time taking apart his VW Golf to fix stupid things that shouldn't break.


Saturn Forum with info on Hatch Release Problem

Re: Way OT -- Inoperable car door

#6

Re: Way OT -- Inoperable car door

John in Calgary

>Funny, I was going to say something similar about fixing the hatch release on my Passat a few years back. The dealer replaced the lock in the hatch, but didn't hook the release cable to the latch mechanism when they were done. I successfully ended up crawling into the back to try to break into my hatch through the inside (note that this is not for the faint of heart, I had visions of splitting the interior trim in half while I was doing it) to try to trouble shoot it.

I always say - you gotta have passion to own a VW, as the dealership will do everything in their power to make you hate your car (and I have the passion - like you, Steve, I end up doing the simplest repairs myself to save myself the frustration of a dealer experience). Sample conversation - me: there is an intermittant power bog at 2000-2500 RPM; dealer: alright, we'll look into it; dealer later: mechanic didn't find anything, you do know about turbo lag right?; me: of course I know about turbo lag, this is definitely not turbo lag, did you hook it up to your computer to pull any codes?; dealer: uh, no; me: so I guess I'm not paying any of your diagnostic time then, am I (leave shaking head...).

Back to the OP, hit the button until the rear hatch opens, then take trim panel off and leave it off. Try to figure out how you can reopen the hatch by popping the latch manually from inside before you go any further (at least this way you can reopen it to trouble shoot and replace parts). Beyond that, I would start with the mechanical latch release and work my way back through the electrical system as noted above.

John

Re: Way OT -- Inoperable car door

#7

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Read your manual...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>The others have given all the advice I would have, but if you want to leave it unlocked, there is probably some sort of procedure for turning off the auto-lock feature. I did that on our minivan (albeit not a Saturn), because I don't care for it. I was also able to turn off the annoying honk(s) when I locked/unlocked the doors with the remote. If you don't have the owner's manual, try an online owner's forum of some sort.

Jason

Re: Way OT -- Inoperable car door

#8

Valet setting?

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

>Our 2002 L300 has a switch in the trunk lid to activate a "valet" setting that prevents it from opening using the remote or the valet's key. Any chance your Vue has a similar lockout feature you've accidently activated, like the child-proof rear doors.

Re: Way OT -- Inoperable car door

#9

Lee Gordon

Re: Way OT -- Inoperable car door *LINK*

Lee Gordon

>If only you had taken some literary license and claimed to have locked a stack of hardwood inside your vehicle, your story would have gone from "OT" to on-topic and you could have posted it as your next blog entry.

I'm hearing someone ask, "AJ has a blog?"

Why, yes, he does. The link is below.

BTW, a 170 mile round trip to the dealership? Now you know why it's called a Saturn.

And next time you manage to pop that bad boy open, it probably wouldn't hurt to shoot a little graphite lube into the lock mechanism.


AJ's Blog

Re: Way OT -- Inoperable car door

#10

A.J. Hamler

Thanks, all

A.J. Hamler

>Thanks, everyone..

Sounds like a lot of my troubleshooting may take place up front, so I'll start there. Examining the latch or anything that's behind the panel on the rear hatch is problematic, though, since the hatch has to be in the open position to remove the panel -- all the access screws are on the edge, out of reach when the hatch is closed.

If I can't find it up front, then I'll just keep hitting that remote button hoping that the occasional unlatching occurs, then I'll check the manual to see if there's a way to shut off the automatic locking till I can get it fixed.

In answer to the question of it making any sound when the remote button is pushed, no, it doesn't. No clicking or anything (except on those rare occasions where it surprises me and unlocks when I'm unlocking the other doors -- it makes the normal clicking sound then, but otherwise it makes no sound when trying to open it).

Thanks again,

A.J.

I'll also check the manual

Re: Way OT -- Inoperable car door

#11

Perhaps a fuse?

Brian in Brighton

>This might be far enough away from the other latch mechanisms to warrant it's own fuse. That's at least something you can look at quick enough.

If that does not work, you can always drive it to the dealer to fix something in the back.

Dealer: Hey, do you know we can't get your hatch open?

You: Gee, I just had it open this morning to get things out of it before I brought it in. What did your man do to it?

He he he.

Brian in Brighton