Re: Pocket Screw Question
ScottS
>There are a number of reasons why you probably wouldn't want to use pocket holes for building a deck. Here are a few:
1) Strength. Most of the pocket hole jigs I've seen aren't designed to work with the large screws normally used in deck building. Eb-Ty and other hidden fastener systems use small screws, but gain mechanical advantage from the "clip" or fastener used. I'd be a little worried about long-term holding power if you're planning to use a Kreg jig and the standard-sized pocket hole screws.
2) Reversibility. Remember that pocket hole screws must be used with glue to produce the strongest joint. If you glue all of your deck boards to the joists, you'll have a heck of a time replacing one should the need arise! Not that any of the hidden fastener systems are great in this regard.
3) Time. When I built my deck using Eb-Ty fasteners, I found that it was a relatively time-consuming process. Eb-Ty requires cutting one biscuit slot per joist, on both sides of every deck board. I was using Trex decking, which cuts like butter. I could literally cut the slots as fast as I could move and it still took a considerable amount of time. One nice thing about the Eb-Ty system is that it didn't require a great deal of precision. You couldn't be completely sloppy, but if there was a situation where a deck board or joist wasn't quite in the right place (due to cupping, bowing, twisting, etc) it wasn't the end of the world. Pocket screws strike me as being a bit more fussy to work with, and thus more time consuming. For a small deck, this may not be a problem. For a large deck, the time factor may be more significant.