Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Shop - wood floor installation method question...

Posts

Shop - wood floor installation method question...

#1

Shop - wood floor installation method question...

John Aniano in NJ...

>Hello All,

I'm about to install 400 square feet of 5-inch wide, tongue & groove, T&G end matched, white oak flooring to my new shop floor. The subfloor for the second storey shop is 3/4" thick T&G plywood over 2x10 floor joists on 2-foot centers. There won't be any heavy machinery in this 2nd floor shop, only a workbench and tool cabinets. The floor isn't "springy".

The oak flooring was bought last summer and has been sitting stickered in the building (unheated) since the summer. The shop is a passive solar design and is very well insulated (~R30) on all sides, floor, ceiling, and walls. I expect to put maybe two coats of a matt polyurethane as a finish, keeping the white oak light color.

My question is this: should I staple and use construction adhesive to glue the floor to the plywood or use red rosin paper and staple through the paper to the subfloor? I have gotten mixed messages on both methods, i.e. floor will buckle, too much seasonal movement, etc. I want to do it so it will stand up to shop use, but don't want to do it twice. Any thoughts or personal experience would be appreciated.

John

Re: Shop - wood floor installation method question...

#2

Re: Shop - wood floor installation method question

Norman Pirollo (Ottawa, Ont.)

>I did something similar a few years back in my own shop here, 2X10 joist spacing is 16 in. OC though..

I would not glue the flooring to the subfloor.. Hardwood expands and contracts and in my opinion this will lead to buckling.

Instead what I did was to power nail the hardwood strips to the subfloor with rosin paper in between. My 1st attempt was with a manual nailer, but within the day went back and rented a power floor nailer and compressor. It went well afterwards.

7.5 years later and the hardwood floor is tight as can be, no probs. whatsoever.

Norman

Re: Shop - wood floor installation method question...

#3

Re: Shop - wood floor installation method question

John E in SC

>I agree w/ Norman, both in the installation method (nails/staples only over paper - no glue) and in the idea to get a pneumatic nailer. I've used both the manual nailer and pneumatic, and unless you have arms like jackhammers, the pneumatic nailer is WELL worth the money. FYI, I actually bought a pneumatic nailer new, which allowed me to take my time doing my floor, and then sold it on e-bay for a minimal loss - about the cost of a days rental! The paper will help eliminate squeaks, but still allow the wood to move.

Good luck,

John

Re: Shop - wood floor installation method question...

#4

Re: Shop - wood floor installation method question

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>Nail only, but the paper is unnecessary. Consider clear one part baterborne garage floor exoxy as the finish.

Clint

Re: Shop - wood floor installation method question...

#5

Re: Shop - wood floor installation method question

Joseph Mulherin, Sr.

>John, I sent you a couple websites that will answer your questions about the flooring installation and finishing. And the other guys are correct...install with a pneumatic air nailer and the pink paper. Leave a space of 1/4" at the baseboards for expansions.

Re: Shop - wood floor installation method question...

#6

Re: Shop - wood floor installation method question

Joseph Mulherin, Sr.

>Sorry, guys, I do not understand how to post a 'link' for you to see what I am speaking of in my responses here on WC....just old age and possibly stupid is the answer I guess.

Anyway, try going to www.woodfloorsonline.com for the info I was reffering John to.

Re: Shop - wood floor installation method question...

#7

Re: Shop - wood floor installation method question

Barry Irby

>I would use an air stapler to fasten it and not use the paper or the glue. I installed my dining room floor that way about ten years ago and it has performed perfectly. No squeaks. (I have beaten the finish to death, but that is another issue.)

It is my belief the paper is a carry over form the days of board subfloor and the paper was an infiltration barrier. In other words, it kept the wind from blowing through all those cracks. With OSB or plywood for a subfloor, this is not an issue. It makes no sense to me to "cushion" the flooring. That would also it to move. The movement is what causes the squeaks.

Also, I would use nails or staples that drive all the way through the subfloor. If the fastener sticks through on he other side, there is less possibility of a nail backing out (a nail pop). Do not drive the fasteners into the joists, that tends to cause nail pops. I would drive three or more nails in each two foot space between the joists.

Be sure the subfloor is very secure before you nail down the flooring. Carefully go over it and screw it down. The idea is that the subfloor is attached to the joists and the floor is attached to the subfloor.

I "nailed" my floor with a stapler that would drive 2 1/2" long half inch wide heavy gauge staples. It was not a flooring nailer, but I modified it for the job. have loaned it out to several friends. Works well.