>This comment is not going to win friends this AM, and no I am not in a bad mood. I was disappointed with the judging. I anticipated a tool making contest where the utility and novelty of the tool would be paramount. The winners to a large extent look to be winners in an art contest with tools as the medium. To wit, the best functioning plane, according to one judge's comment, was awarded third in the Function category. Without question the tools are beautiful and no doubt the workmanship unsurpassed, but I expected more practical novelty and utility such as found in the clever back packing saw design. I was hoping to see tool designs, execution or material that would show up in the LV catalog some day or that I would be compelled to own or make.
>If function were paramount would not most of the furniture you build be graded much lower in favor of more durable and more functional but less aesthetic forms? After all, a useful table should be able to handle scalding pots, severe abrasion and sharp blows without suffering damage, right?
I would think wood is a lousy choice for furniture in this day and age if function and utility is the only or primary consideration.
Honestly, I have not looked deeply into the contest but am most impressed with the winners.
Lee
p.s. I'm sure you all know where I stand on the subject of aesthetics.
>I was looking for winners the equivalent of the wheel marking gauge, the roller sharpening jig, or for that matter the Krenov plane, had these items not been already invented. Instead, to carry your analogy forward, the winners, with one exception, looked like they were the best-in-show of the "period furniture reproductions" category.
I was left feeling that had Krenov entered his first novel, functional, practical, plane design it would not have made honorable mention. These attributes would not have overcome its lack of refinement in the judges evaluation. Their comments would have been- planes as well as any entry , comfortable in the hand, easy for any woodworker to make in a variety of sizes and bedding angles, yet its shaping was not refined and the iron wasn't polished.
I hope I have made more clear that I had hoped that judges would include fewer beautifully made reproductions and more novel designs.
That said, congratulations to the winners and their exceptional workmanship.
>Bill, I understand your comments. Maybe, should they do the contest again, they could have a dedicated category for "innovation". Or perhaps they should have a separate contest all together.
I was impressed with the tools in this contest but I agree it would be fun to see a contest whose focus is on innovation or invention. That can often be the birthplace of great new ideas.
So maybe some food for thought for the next tool contest eh?
>I think I understand what you are trying to say but in a field of Krenov planes the one with the beautiful finish and polished blade must be picked over the others and in a field of polished Krenov planes the one with a bit of decoration must be picked over the others, and in a field of decorated krenov planes....
I suspect this was the case carried out to extremes with this contest. As you suggested about an inovation catogory for next time, I agree that it would be worth considering and no less difficult to judge.
Hats off to Kyle, a rising star to be sure. I look forward to seeing what ever this young craftsman makes in the future.
>Many of the winning tools, while nicely made, obviously useful and pleasing to view, would've likely evoked the somewhat disdainful "derivative" criticism from the arts community where novelty trumps execution. I, too, believed the contest would promote a dialogue of innovation above workmanship. Interesting and inspiring nevertheless.
There will be three (3) "first" prizes in this contest: one for craftsmanship, one for utility, and one for aesthetics....Judging criteria will include technical achievement (craftsmanship), design elegance, ergonomics, performance, originality, problem-solving excellence, materials selection and engineering. The judges' decision will be final."
If you read the above, it doesn't look like innovation was given an especially high priority, and that there were many factors besides that led to the judges' decision.
You may have wanted to see more innovation in this contest (and who wouldn't?), but that's not how this particular contest was set up.
Thanks to Ellis and the judges for setting this contest up!
Some of my personal favorites didn't even place in the competition, yet speaking as the contest sponsor, I was very pleased with how hard the judges worked to come to a consensus - as they often had very different perspectives (as will most of the people looking at the tools). There were no snap decisions here...
We'll give it another go next year, and may tweak the categories a bit...but only to keep it interesting, and perhaps allow for more prizes...there sure could've been a whole bunch more awarded!
>All the tools featured in the Contest results page are fine tools. I'm surprised to see so many winners coming from my country, including even one from my home town. May be it's because the sponsor was LV and many LV customers saw the contest ad at one of the stores and decided to give it a try. LV doesn't have a presence in Quebec but that doesn't stop woodworkers in Quebec shopping at LV online or dropping by one of the stores in the nearby provinces whenever they can (Ottawa and T.O. are a few hours away). But then there was even one winning entry from the Down Under - perhaps a LV branch store in Australia one day?).
>Bill, thoughtful comments are welcome. You don't need to worry about losing friends. I'd hate to hear your comments when you *are* in a bad mood though. :-)
I don't agree with your criticisms though. You start off by saying you were disappointed with the judging, but then add, in essence, that it was actually the contest parameters that you didn't care for, at least if I read you right. I think the judges did a fine job with the definitions and constraints that were set forth in the contest instructions. Utility was a top criterion in each of our three prize categories, because a tool that doesn't work is like a car without a motor, no matter how well made it is or how nice it looks. Novelty (or innovation, if you will) was one of the factors that added extra weight when comparing tools of otherwise similar qualities, but it was not a stated objective of the contest. Maybe next year, we'll have an innovation category. The winner will still have to function well in order to claim a prize.
So here is a point of departure for a constructive discussion of what a toolmaking contest can and/or should be, and I will appreciate all constructive input on this. We plan to do another toolmaking contest next year, with some significant tweaks to make it more clearly defined and manageable. We also want to be sure we give appropriate weight to the important factors. Is innovation truly the issue, or even a preponderant issue? As I see it (and everyone is entitled to their own viewpoint here), the spirit of this year's maiden voyage was to reward people who made their own tools for whatever reason, with the understanding that no tool should be made without regard to function, even if it is a decorative tour de force. How did we choose to reward them? We picked the best looking ones, the best made ones, and the ones that worked best -- three valid and discrete differences in motivation for tools -- and rewarded them all. (I say "we" because I was there, in attendance, as the referee although I was not a voting judge.) The judging parameters were pretty ambitious and left a lot of room for debate, but when we defined the contest to begin with, we didn't know what kinds of entries we were going to have. We were sticking our toes in the water and working from some fairly thoughtful assumptions, and the rules evolved from there.
Now, back to innovation. To make a beautiful, nicely crafted or supremely functional tool doesn't require any innovation at all. The styles, construction techniques and designs required to do so have all been invented already. A contest with a premium on innovation is a completely different animal, or at least there is little overlap with our current contest. I'm not even sure what kinds of innovations people might have submitted or how we would judge if they were truly innovative. But, more importantly than that, we decided early on that we did not want to encourage patentable entries -- that is, ones that were so novel and groundbreaking that exposure in a public contest such as this would have jeopardized or ruined their opportunity to receive patent protection. Lee Valley and other tool manufacturers are keenly aware of the value of secrecy and intellectual property protection, and we expressly wanted to avoid compromising that.
I'll be interested to hear how others would suggest writing the rules for the next contest. I have a feeling that it's going to be a blockbuster.
>I think innovative tools & ideas are already being rewarded in other places. The FWW tips column comes to mind, where about 7 winners are rewarded handsomely every year or something like that. I am glad to hear that you'll have another contest, because I just could not get my ^&%$ in gear this year. On the other hand, my entry would have been pretty far down on the curve. My own personal opinion is that function should rate higher than the appearance of a tool but it would make a very time consuming and subjective contest. Perhaps the contest could have a $100 entry fee so that judges could be hired and paid for their time ;) I can't imagine the time and effort that went into this contest and hope that the judges were properly thanked for their time.