Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

OT: XP & Vista Network Problem

Posts

OT: XP & Vista Network Problem

#1

OT: XP & Vista Network Problem

Ken Krawford

>I have an existing ethernet network with 2 XP computers and a D-Link router. I added a new machine with Vista Premium. The Vista machine can see and access the XP machines but not vise versa. I have disabled the Vista firewall. I'm using the MSHOME workgroup name on all computers.

I've searched many message boards as this seems to be a common problem but none of the "cures" worked.

Any suggestions?

Re: OT: XP & Vista Network Problem

#2

Just a SWAG

Dustmaker Mike

>I have not played nor shall I play with Vista. What I would think is that Vista does a different format to the hard drive which can still read the FAT or NTFS formatted drives. The problem comes when you use the older formated drives to read a New and Improved system. If Vista does format NTFS then my guess would be that WIn XP does not understand the new language of Vista but Vista still understands the old language of XP. I am not sure how to get around this if this is indeed the cause. So I guess I was no help.

Re: OT: XP & Vista Network Problem

#3

Jesper, Denmark

Re: OT: XP & Vista Network Problem

Jesper, Denmark

>I am not going to be much help either, as I have the same problem plus the Vista machine does not want to recognize the XP units either.

On top of that, trying to use any of the help areas gets you to some superficial marketing speak, but no real help. After that it takes 20 minutes telling you it is looking for a solution, and finally that it cannot find it.

Re: OT: XP & Vista Network Problem

#4

Re: OT: XP & Vista Network Problem

Chuck W

>Ken,

Does your Vista have SP1 installed? My son's laptop stopped networking after installing SP1 and there seems to be no real help to solve the problem. Attempts to use Help is next to useless. Maybe Vista can be used by "power users" who know the OS well but for Joe Average it becomes and exercise in frustration. Why does Microsoft want to inflict this on their customers? Its beyond me. Anyways I hope they give XP a reprieve as it has turned out to be a fairly trouble free OS with lots of support form other manufacturers. Sorry I cannot offer more help to solve your networking problem.

Re: OT: XP & Vista Network Problem

#5

Re: OT: XP & Vista Network Problem

Ken Krawford

>No, I have not applied SP1 yet. I just got the computer 2 days ago and I'm waiting to see if any other issues surface first.

Re: OT: XP & Vista Network Problem

#6

Re: OT: XP & Vista Network Problem

Binen

>Nice to know I'm not the only one with this problem. I sure hope someone finds a fix to the problem.

Binen

Re: OT: XP & Vista Network Problem

#7

Vista—the new ME

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>When I bought a new desktop and then a new laptop last year, I weighed very heavily (for about 3 µseconds)the choice between XP and Vista. I'd already heard, well, if not horror, then scary stories about Vista, and never having been a bleeding edge consumer anyway, opted for XP. Boy am I glad I did. One year later, Vista is starting to look just like ME did eight or nine years ago. I believe it's going to be an evolutionary dead end, and whatever eventually supplants XP will be an entirely different product not based on the Vista model. One doesn't need to be especially prescient to make such a prediction—I think the record already reflects that likelihood.

For me, I'm going in a different direction. I suspect the two XP machines will be the last M$ machines I'll have. My Ubuntu Linux CD arrived yesterday, and I'm going to try and get a machine up before too long. It really looks like the path I want to take. I hope Dan is reading this, because he's going to be hearing a lot from me before too long.

Rod

Re: OT: XP & Vista Network Problem

#8

Re: Vista�the new ME

Sean Troy

>I remember when XP first came out. Everyone was cursing it and said stay away from it, it is nothing but problems. Why didn't MS stay with the previous OS? I think the same thing will be said for Vista in the near future. Try calling a local computer store that builds systems. Not the big box ones.

Re: OT: XP & Vista Network Problem

#9

Re: Vista�the new ME

Jerry

>I want to maintain a 3 meter pole relationship between me and Vista. I even have two spare unopened upgrade copies of Win XP in case I should want to build a new computer in the near future. If you are going to try Ubuntu, you might also want to look at LinuxMint. It builds on Ubuntu but has a bunch of stuff that is not included with Ubuntu, including MP3 codecs. Right now I have a computer that is set up to dual boot between Ubuntu 7.10 and LinuxMint 4 (with a common Home directory). Networking and printer sharing with a WinXP machine is easy with these Linux distributions. I am still not ready to move to Linux exclusively though but I will do that rather than install Vista. BTW I tried the fancy eye candy stuff in Ubuntu and LinuxMint (Compiz-Fusion, or is it confused fission?) and then turned it off.

Jerry

Re: OT: XP & Vista Network Problem

#10

;-)

Dan Donaldson

>

Re: OT: XP & Vista Network Problem

#11

Just curious

Dan Donaldson

>What was it about compiz that you didn't like? I don't use the eye candy part of it too much, but some of the other features are useful.

Re: OT: XP & Vista Network Problem

#12

Re: Linux Mint

Chuck W

>Jerry,

Which version 4 should I download? There is Gnome Main or Light, KDE and Fluxbox.

Re: OT: XP & Vista Network Problem

#13

Re: Just curious

Jerry

>The simple answer is: It depends on what you like. Gnome and KDE seem to be the most popular while Xcfe and Fluxbox seem to perform a little better on computers short on RAM and/or computing power. I have played with all of the above and prefer gnome but that is just me. In LinuxMint, gnome is officially supported by the LinuxMint developers and KDE, Xcfe, and fluxbox are variations created independently by other members of the Linux community - at least I think that is the way it works. The newest version of Ubuntu, version 8.04, is due to be officially released shortly (it is in beta testing right now)and should be followed in a few weeks by LinuxMint 5. If you are new to Linux, I wouldn't suggest messing with the beta version. Ubuntu and LinuxMint require about the same computer capability as Windows XP.

Jerry (NOT a Linux expert by any stretch of the imagination!)

Re: OT: XP & Vista Network Problem

#14

Oops!

Jerry

>Chuck, look under Dan's post for my response to you. Sorry about that!

Jerr

Re: OT: XP & Vista Network Problem

#15

Eye Candy

Jerry

>I just didn't see that the rotating cube and that kind of stuff did anything useful for me. Same for the squiggly windows. Also, I could tell that they were using up computing resources and slowing things down somewhat. I am probably just a simple minded old curmudgeon who doesn't appreciate the finer things! I don't use any fancy wallpaper either.

Jerry

Re: OT: XP & Vista Network Problem

#16

Re: Just curious

Dan Donaldson

>I was just wondering since you said you didn't like compiz. I use it, but not so much for the eye candy as the easy workspace switching. I also prefer gnome. I have two linux boxes running, both with duo core processors and 2 gig ram. One has 7.10 running on it and the other is set up to dual boot 7.10 and 8.04 (have been running this since alpha2)on two separate 500 gig drives. I may try mint one of these days, but I have everything that I want running even though I had to add some of the decoders separately.

I do have a version of XP in a virtual box that I boot once every few months just to update it, but basically never use it. My second box came with Vista on it because that particular one was not available with linux. I ran it for a few hours, got frustrated with it and dropped in the 500 gig drive and installed linux.

Re: OT: XP & Vista Network Problem

#17

Re: Eye Candy

Dan Donaldson

>On my system, both cores usually are running at about 1-2% except when actually switching and then one of them will momentarily go to 50% utilization or so. on full rotation, one core will go to 100% and the other to about 15% or so, but it drops right back down as soon as I stop rotating. I actually like the "squiggly windows", but have them adjusted so that the wiggle is minimal and highly damped. Each to his own ;-) Nothing wrong with setting up whatever you prefer. I was just curious.

Re: OT: XP & Vista Network Problem

#18

Only One Problem

David Yoho

> I even have two spare unopened upgrade copies of Win XP in case I should want to build a new computer in the near future.

I plan to purchase at least one more copy of XP-Pro for future use myself. I will not use Vista - period! The only problem I see is that hardware manufacturers are already abandoning making drivers for XP. This will be more of a problem as time goes by, especially if you use new hardware in a future build.

I ran into the same problem with Win-98 and that's what forced me to XP. I've already made up my mind that if the day comes, and it probably will, that I can't run XP any longer, there's a Mac in my future!

David

Re: OT: XP & Vista Network Problem

#19

Re: OT: XP & Vista Network Problem

John McGaw

>Once you get all the machines agreeing on the workgroup name I believe you have to diddle the folder/file permissions on the Vista machine to make them available -- just sharing them may not be enough. I don't have Vista here (and don't intend to if I have any say in the matter) so I can't give you a step-by-step but this is a quote from an online discussion of a problem similar to what you describe:

"I was able to change the permission settings as follows: Right click the file on the Vista machine you want to share (to share with XP) Select Share, select change permissions, select drop down box, select Guest, choose permission level to be granted. That will allow XP users viewing the shared file to access the file based on the level of permission(s) granted."

Re: OT: XP & Vista Network Problem

#20

Re: OT: XP & Vista Network Problem

rarebear

>Turn on File Sharing in the CP> Network

It warns you not to but you have to turn it on.....

Re: OT: XP & Vista Network Problem

#21

Re: OT: XP & Vista Network Problem

Ken Krawford

>Thanks so much John! You nailed it. Worked great for me.