Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

OT: HVAC: Which make/model?

Posts

OT: HVAC: Which make/model?

#1

OT: HVAC: Which make/model?

Dan Mitchell

>Well, it seems the ~15 y.o. heat pump I had posted about yesterday has crapped out entirely. It had been running on the "Aux Heat" resistive elements more & more, this morning as an experiment I disconnected them entirely. Heat pump ran for about 2 hours, raising the inside temp from 64 to 66, after which it stopped running completely. Outside temp is mid-50's. Haven't checked the compressor unit thoroughly yet, except for the 2 fuses, which are fine, I'll do that tomorrow. But in any event, it's an old, inefficient unit whose time has passed. So, I'm wondering if anyone has any particular suggestions about the following:

1) Make/model for a replacement. I do want something more efficient, which shouldn't be hard to do. On the other hand, we may not be here all that long, so I don't wnat to invest in something requiring 5+ years for a pay-back. We don't have access to gas, but around here the electric supply is hydro & relatively cheap. I've heard rumors that gas can be added now, but frankly I think it might actually cost more to run than a heat pump in this relatively mild climate (Seattle area).

I've had bad luck with Lennox.

2) Can anyone recommend an HVAC dealer in the Seattle area that isn't made up of incompetent, dishonest, bungling, "don't give a damn" thieves? Did that come out as cynical? Sorry. It's just that my personal experience with service companies of all types has been abysmal. Which is why I try to do everything I possibly can myself.

3) To that last point, what is the feasibility of installing a replacement DIY? I really am quite handy, if I do say so myself, and frankly, this ain't brain surgery. I've done quite a lot of electrical work, as well as automotive AC. My main concern is the weight of the equipment (getting it in place) & getting it charged. Bob suggested in my earlier post that pre-charged equipment is available. Any have experience with this?

Any insights into the above will be greatly appreciated!

Dan

Re: OT: HVAC: Which make/model?

#2

JL

Re: OT: HVAC: Which make/model?

JL

>I had to replace two heat pumps in the past couple of years. On the old house, I got a Trane. The size was compatible with the heat exchanger coil in the air handling unit.

The new house has an Amana Dual Fuel heat pump/furnace. I really like this unit. It has worked very well. The furnace runs on propane.

You may be a handy person and could probably do the job. I don't know if you have all the equipment though (good vacuum pump, test gear, etc.). Many locations also specify that only licensed HVAC people work on residential equipment.

I wouldn't want to solder on pre-charged equipment. The heat exchange "fluid" has a tendency to expand quite drastically when heated.

My $0.02.

Re: OT: HVAC: Which make/model?

#3

Re: OT: HVAC: Which make/model?

Dan Mitchell

>Thanks for the reply. I have heard good things about Trane, though like wood working equipment, if you search enough, no doubt someone out there has had trouble ;-)

I wasn't aware Amana made HVAC equipment. We have a propane tank for the gas stove, but would have to get a larger one if using it for heat. Electric is about $.08/KWH, if memory serves (have to pull out a bill to be sure) which I have been told is about half what it is in some parts of the country, so given that & the mild-ish climate, I do think a heat pump makes sense.

I pulled off the cover on the HP & got it working again. The high pressure switch on the discharge muffler needed to be reset. For the moment at least, it's putting out cheaper heat.

I also discovered the unit was installed in 1990, so it's definitely on its last legs.

I will probably get some estimates on an installation. It's been a long time since I had an HVAC install done, reading some posts on it in various places, apparently it's not unusual to pay as much for the installation as for the equipment. As for DIY, naturally, I want to save as much $$$ as possible, but honestly I've had such bad experience paying people to do things, it's my aversion to getting ripped off or a hack job as much as it is the money. I've read where some people have installed everything, then paid someone to handle the refrigerant. Even if I had to buy some equipment, it would still be much cheaper.

You may be correct about the laws, I'd have to check on that.

Dan

Re: OT: HVAC: Which make/model?

#4

Re: OT: HVAC: Which make/model?

Barry Irby

>Dan,

Locally, and I think nationally, we are required to replace failed existing equipment with 13 Seer (or higher) units. This will require that you replace both the inside and out side units. The new units will be substantially more efficient than your existing unit, but also substantially larger, physically. (Apparently they had to make the units bigger to get more surface area in the coils to make them more efficient.)

Even more efficient equipment is available, but I would not recommend it. Stay with good solid plain Jane middle of the road stuff. Some of the high end stuff is rather exotic. When it breaks, who you gonna call? Ghost Busters?

Trane is an excellent brand. I would recommend it, but it is likely to be more expensive than "builder" brands like Amanna or Goodwin (Janitrol). Trane is owned by American Standard and they make equipment that is more of a builder grade under their own name. I know several people that swear there isn't much functional difference and that you should save your money and buy the cheap stuff.

I think you will find you have to replace both units and the tubing. It may be possible for you to do this yourself. The tubing is bought as a package or kit. You buy the length you need and it has fittings on both ends that have threaded couplings and they screw on. The fittings pierce the each other and do not require silver solder. It is my understanding that the factory charges may not be correct for every installation and may require some adjustment. Locally, they are considered a holding charge. HVAC contractors hook them up in new houses and leave them until the house sells and then come back and tune them up.

You might be able to find a contractor that will come and tune your system up and double check your installation.

Be aware that the air handler might not be a direct substitute and require some transitions (square funnels or reducers) in the ducts to make it fit.

Re: OT: HVAC: Which make/model?

#5

Re: OT: HVAC: Which make/model?

David Yoho

>Last year we replaced one of the original Janitrol heat pumps with a builder's grade Trane (inside and outside units and digital thermostat). Wow, what a difference it made in the upstairs of our house! This unit was a little larger tonnage-wise but it didn't require running new lines between the units, which was a good thing.

I picked the model we got because we didn't plan the be here more than a few more years and it didn't make sense to buy a more expensive unit.

I plan to go Geo-thermal next time we build but if I was going with a conventional heat pump again I'd go with Trane in a second.

David

Re: OT: HVAC: Which make/model?

#6

JL

Re: OT: HVAC: Which make/model?

JL

>We pre-bought 600 gallons of propane for this past winter (under $2/gallon at that time). We haven't run through all of it yet.

Our SEER rating on our heat pump is 15 SEER. The furnace, heat pump and ducting for the basement ran under $7 K about 2 years ago. The furnace runs when it is colder than the set point. The heat pump runs the rest of the time. It currently has two zones (basement and the rest of the house) with two thermostats.

Re: OT: HVAC: Which make/model?

#7

Re: OT: HVAC: Which make/model? *LINK*

Jim Dillon

>Dan,

About 4 years ago, we had a heat pump installed along with new ductwork, blower etc. (there had been none before as we had baseboard heat and no AC). IIRC, the heat pump/blower came to around $3K (4 ton unit + 45K BTU heating coil) and the install was $7K all done in a 3 foot tall sub basement with access through a 18 x 30 inch trap door; those installers really earned their money IMHO. Anyway, I called 5 HVAC contractors for bids. Two never showed, one did but never provided an estimate, while the remaining two provided an estimate. Both estimates were surprisingly within several hundred dollars of one another. But one of the two contractors did a complete heat/cooling load calculation for our log cabin. That gave me more confidence in their work. York, Trane, Carrier, Comfortmaker, American Standard are popular around here (MD/VA). We settled on a middle-of-the-line Trane (SEER 14) and have been very pleased. The newer control systems avoid the sudden rush of cold air in the winter and are reasonably quiet. The heat pump/blower unit/auxillary coil/thermostat are much more integrated now to work as a package to give you more comfort and efficiency. Our electric bill actually went down. SEER 13 is now the required minimum. The very high SEER heat pumps are quite expensive and likely would never give you payback if your electricity is relatively cheap. If you are planning to move within 5 years, I would go with a minimum SEER 13 unit with the appropriately sized blower installed by someone you feel comfortable with.

Here is a link to a HVAC forum that I found to be very helpful and it has a good search function. However, do NOT mention you are interested in DIY as it gets them riled up a bit 8-). Good luck.

Jim


HVAC-Talk Forum

Re: OT: HVAC: Which make/model?

#8

Re: OT: HVAC: Which make/model?

Dan Mitchell

>Jim-Sounds like yours was considerably hairier than my replacement will be. The setting here is pretty straightforward.

Thanks for the link to the HVAC forum. I've seen that one as well as a few others, such as http://www.hvacmechanic.com/forums/forums.htm as well as a couple HVAC NG's; you're correct, this field seems unusually hostile about "diy".

Dan

Re: OT: HVAC: Which make/model?

#9

Re: OT: HVAC: Which make/model?

Dan Mitchell

>Thanks Barry, I see Trane's "entry level" HP is SEER rating "in the 13.00 range" and HSPF of "up to" 8.0. You have to go up several models to get much of an improvement. Don't know about price differences yet. I'm also checking out American Standard, parent company of Trane, whose products many are saying are the same internally to Trane models.

The pre-charged lines sound ideal, and the threaded connections are probably similar to what I have dealt with on automotive AC.

The aspect of transitioning the air handler to the ductwork is really the only part I have much reservation about. Seems unlikely the unit will be of exactly the same dimensions, so new transitions will likely have to be fabricated. Hopefully, there's a shop in the area willing to do that.

The old unit seems to be running ok for now, but its days are numbered. I'm fortunate that, given the time of year & temperate climate here, I should be able to take my time with this.

Re: OT: HVAC: Which make/model?

#10

Re: OT: HVAC: Which make/model?

Dan Mitchell

>Thanks David, if we were likely to be here for a decade or so, I'd look into geothermal as well, though our lot (heavily wooded) may not be an ideal candidate.

Dan

Re: OT: HVAC: Which make/model?

#11

Re: OT: HVAC: Which make/model?

Jim Dillon

>Dan,

LOL! The only thing that seems to get them riled up more is a lawyer looking for an HVAC expert to testify against another HVAC contractor; talk about blood on the forum floor! 8-). Anyway, the least expensive approach woud be a simple change-out (the "bread-and-butter" of the HVAC industry) with a new heat pump using what you have already. May not be the most efficient, but might be the most cost-effective.

Jim

Re: OT: HVAC: Which make/model?

#12

Re: OT: HVAC: Which make/model?

Dan Mitchell

>I have been wondering about the feasibility of keeping the existing air handler, simply changing the heat pump/lines/inside coil. This would totally sidestep the potential problems around the ductwork connections, etc. Worst case scenario, I have to replace the blower motor down the road, no big deal. The heating elements aren't likely to fail, and the rest is sheet metal.

Too funny about the lawyers. Seriously, what's up with these HVAC people? I've always had very broad interests, you name it, I've taken it apart/worked on it/built it/fixed it. The internet is generally a very rich source of advice for such endeavours. Like HERE, for example. I don't ever recall someone getting their head bitten off by some mechanic for have the temerity to suggest they might do their own brake job/clutch replacement/engine overhaul. Just in searching today, some poor slob was laid into for proposing he might install a split AC unit. You'd think he was asking the NRC about installing a light water reactor in his basement. Seems like insecurity, if you ask me...

Dan

Re: OT: HVAC: Which make/model?

#13

Re: OT: HVAC: Which make/model?

Jay Sharp

>It is not really a DIY project. The EPA requires the installer to have a EPA license to purchase refrigerant. The old unit has to have the charge reclaimed and documented as to how much of refrigerant was recovered. The heat pump, indoor unit, and duct work have to be properly sized to your home. You probably want to replace the heat pump, air handler, and copper line set. If you don't replace all three, most manufactures will not warranty the new equipment. They want everthing properly matched in the Seer rating and tonnage. If you decide on a certain brand, find out who the local distributor is and call them. Ask who they would recommend, they will know who will do a good job. Please get at least three estimates. Make sure they are estimating the same equipment and required ductwork; the old saying apples to apples. Make sure they have a current license and insurance, you don't want them to get hurt or damage your home and come back on you and your homeowner's insurance. You might save some money by removing the old equipment, after the refrigerant is reclaimed, by scrapping it yourself. Scrap metal prices are up and copper is paying well, dismantle and seperate the metals to get the best price.