>We have a mid-90's vintage Lennox heat pump. Living in the Seattle area, the temperature is fairly moderate, rarely much below 35, and then only briefly. I usually turn the heat down to 64 at night, generally 68 during the day. House is about 2300 sq'. The furnace also has an electrical heating element. I understand the effectiveness of an air to air heat pump drops off steeply at lower temps, which is why they include the resistive heat. Also, if you try to go up several degrees in temp, the resistive addition speeds up heating. However, when this kicks in, the cost of the heat goes WAY up. I am considering simply disconnecting these heating elements, in order to save electricity. Very easy to do. Any thoughts on this?
>Can't tell you for sure if it helps or not, but I've always been told that with a heat pump, it's best to leave your thermostat on the same temp all the time, or at most only change a degree or 2. I suspect when you increase from 64 to 68 degrees during the day, your heating elements are kicking in to increase the temp, which can dramatically increase your cost. I put in a heat pump in may new house about 5 years ago, and it was a lot to get used to compared to our old natural gas heat. It seems to blow out "cool" air, even in the winter, and runs more frequently, but we keep it set on the same temp, and keeps it there (somehow!). You might try leaving it set on the same temp and see if your heating bill goes down, before disconnecting the heating elements.
>You may not want to turn down your thermostat at night if you want to save money. Heat pumps don't tend to recover as quickly as conventional heating systems so the energy savings from the set back may all get used up trying to raise the temperature back to the day time setting.
If your electrical company offers a time of day meter you would save more switching to one of those as 64% of your electrical useage would be off peak. You can also put your water heater on a timer and transfer all your hot water electric to off peak.
Or, switch to a geothermal heat pump system and use ground water or a ground loop for your heat source and your back up heat will never kick in. I've heated my house for over 27 years with a groundsource heat pump here in NW PA. I'm in the process of switching to a ground source heat/ac system this year so I get the benefit on the A/C system too.
>Given the age of your unit (10+ years), it may pay to look into getting a new one with a higher SEER. You can also check to see if rebates are available in your area (see link).
>Your thermostat may be a two stage thermostat and the 4 degree difference is telling the thermostat to turn on the heat strips. Most are factory set to call for back up heat if the temp drops more than 2 degrees below the set temp. You can get a programmable two stage that would allow you to program the differential temp so that the elctrical strips don't kick in on a 4 degree temp change, but would on a 5 degree change.
>Dan, I used to have a heat pump that switched the strips in in sequence or steps. As it got colder, it would turn on one section. If it got colder still, it would turn on another. When it got cold enough to turn on the third strip, it turned off the HP. My understanding is they don't do that anymore. They bring on the strips, but they just let the heat pump thrash.
You are correct that it could cost as much as three times as much to produce heat with the strips as it does to run the heat pump. Depending on the unit, at above something like 47 degrees, the HP is three time as efficient as the strips. As the temp outside goes down the efficiency drops off so that at about 17 degrees, they are about the same. At somewhere around 35, the HP is about twice as efficient.
The "irony" is that as the outdoor temp drops and the efficiency falls, your demand goes up.
Your idea might work, if the unit is large enough and it never gets cold enough. (Adding insulation and improving your windows and other energy conservation strategies have the effect of making your house thermally smaller or your heat pump larger.)
You could put some sort of limit switch into the system that would not allow the strips to come on until the outside temp drops below (pick a number). Say Thirty five. So if the strips were locked out and the outside temp was forty, if you cracked up the stat, the strips could not come on, it would just take longer to warm the house.
The trick would be to get that done. I would not recommend fiddling with the wiring to the stat. Its pretty complicated and every time I ever did it, I screwed something up. You might be able to find a control that you could put in the line tot eh strips that would remain "open" until the outdoor temp fell to the "set Point". Finding somebody to pick the right control and wire it in without ruining your equipment and for a reasonable price would be a good trick.
I suppose you could just wire in a manual switch and leave it off until the coldest day of the year and then turn it back on.
>Thanks for the replies. I had read about the 2 degree thing, special thermostats that raise the temp slowly, and that you shouldn't set back a heat pump, due to the resistive heat. Still, absent the resistive heat turning on, it's hard to imagine how 64 for 8+ hours can't be cheaper than 68 for the same period.
I don't have one of those special t-stats, so generally what I do is turn the temp up myself 2 degrees at a time. Maybe I just noticed this, but now I'm seeing that even if I turn the temp up one degree at a time, the tiny "aux heat" indicator (on the LCD panel; easy to miss) is showing. I agree about not messing with the thermostat's wiring, my plan was to simply disconnect the elements themselves inside the furnace, their connections are easily accessible under the front cover.
Just by touch, I can say the high pressure side of the refrigerant line is quite warm, even when the "aux heat" is showing, so it appears the heat pump has not crapped out entirely, something that would not amaze me, given its age. I know the underground heat pump is more efficient, though given the steeply sloped, heavily wooded lot, I'm not sure it's feasible here.
I know I should replace the furnace, but that would put a major dent in my woodworking budget!!!
>Dan, There are small electronic modules that will allow you to delay the start of anything. If you put one of these in series with your second stage heat, you can control how long it will take to come on. Some of these are preset and some are adjustable over a wide range. They reset and start timing on an interrupted signal.
Regarding cost of replacement equipment, HVAC equipment is available with precharged lines and does not require a certified refrigeration mechanic to install. Do an EBay search for HVAC.
>Dan your system sounds about like mine. I have Breakers for each of the resistence elements. just flip the breakeer. That way if you or a future owner ever wants them, just turn them back on. BTW there are actually two breakers for each. One on the furnace and one in the main box.
On one of my home inspections I saw a heat pump that had been modified with a temp sensor in the duct that would not allow the strips to come on as long as the duct temp was above some preset level. It was a temp sensors hooked into the T-stat wiring. It was my opinion that the guy had been sold a bill of goods. He had paid $1800 for it (including some very creative BS). I do not know if it worked, but it would NEVER pay for itself. The installers claimed to have added a similar device to the AC part of the system. (Not possible for that to work, there isn't anything equivalent to the strip heat on the AC side.) The amazing part was that gizmo was not even wired to anything.
So, It might be possible to wire something into the low voltage side, but I would still stay away form it unless you can find somebody that REALLY knows what they are doing.
Some stats now have a very small difference between the system running and bringing on the strip or AUX heat. Drives me crazy on home inspections.
The reason night times set back does not work well for HP's is that you allow the house to cool off and then ask the equipment to replace the heat in the morning, the worst time of the day for the HP, the outside air is coldest then. So, not only are you often bringing on the strips that cost triple, but the HP is not nearly at its peak.
>Dan - I have pretty much the same system as you do except mine is only about 7 years old. And I live in Vancouver just north of you so our climates are the same. When we first installed the heat pump we decided not to install the heating elements. When the temperature dropped to the mid 30's the pump would just quit. I would have to turn the thing off, wait an hour or so to reset and then start again. This would happen regularly. The furnace guy said the elements were necessary not only to provide supplemental heat but to keep the fluid running. Since I installed the elements I haven't had any problems. When it gets cold (around freezing) I fire up my wood stove and just leave the heat pump set at 63. There are dual systems available that use natural gas as a boost rather than electricity. But that would mean a new furnace for you...
>So Barry, you're telling me I can't get COOLING out of a heating element? Not even if I REVERSE THE WIRES?!? Oh yeah, I forgot... Damned polarized plugs!!!
The system has 3 sets of breakers on the panel & 2 on the furnace itself. I can tell when the elements are on using a clamp on ammeter. The wiring for the elements also serves the blower, so in my case the easy approach of flipping the appropriate breaker won't work. The 3 connections to the elements themselves are obvious however, easily reached & disconnected, which is what I have done. Testing the results now.
>During heating mode the actual freon temp is some 10 to 20� colder than the outside air temp. This causes ice/frost (from humidity) to form on outside coils. When the frost plugs up the coils, the HP can not extract any more heat from the outside. Defrost timers along with frost sensors reverse the cycle to melt the frost. This puts the unit into AC mode every fifteen to 45 minutes. The auxilliary strips heat the inside air to keep the 45� AC air from cooling you and your house off.
>Bill - Thanks for the reply. I was aware of the defrost function, according to the installation instructions on mine, it's every 90 minutes, though this no doubt varies with brands/models. I could be mistaken, but from observing this particular HP, I thought it shut down the inside blower during defrost. The model is an 18 year old Lennox HP19. I was assuming when the system again reversed into heat, the inside coil would then defrost as needed. Is this ever the case, or does the inside blower always run during defrost? If so I can certainly see why eliminating the elements could have a "chilling effect" ;-)