Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Bent Lamination Questions

Posts

Bent Lamination Questions

#1

Bent Lamination Questions

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I want to assemble a curved leg by laminating strips. The leg is about 5/8 x 3/4 by 28" long and the deflection from straight is 1 3/8"- not much.

1. !/8" thick pieces ok for thickness of strips?

2. How close together might I need clamps to squash out the excess glue?

3. After assembling the stack should I add a backing piece (caul) to clamp against?

4. I am presuming glue will seep out everywhere. How do I keep the leg stack from becoming one with the curved clamping jig? I was thinking of lining with wax paper if I can keep it in place.

The legs are for a plant stand. The legs will curve like the profile of the cooling tower for a power house or the venturi of a rocket nozzle. (I got inspired by watching "Shadow of the Moon" on the Apollo program)Three legs will capture a circular disk near the top and a second one up from the floor some.

Re: Bent Lamination Questions

#2

Re: Bent Lamination Questions *LINK*

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>1/8" is fine at that length and deflection. Make your strips 6" longer than the finished pieces need to be to account for any cracking or excess squeeze on the ends.

Yes, you'll need cauls, actually, better yet, is a 2-sided form to sandwich your laminated strips like a steam bending form.

I use paste wax on the form plus wax paper. I also use TB-III that I tint to get close to the wood's finished color.

I use clamps every 4".

There's a chart somewhere on spring-back with various woods being laminated. I seem to remember Wood Mag. tried to calculate spring-back both the only thing I've found is the Woodweb exchange (link) pointing to trial and error. Since the spring will occur, I have tended to add 20% to the radius as a trial. For cherry that has gotten me pretty close to my goal and I just fudge from there.

mm


Spring-Back

Re: Bent Lamination Questions

#3

Re: Bent Lamination Questions *LINK*

Mike Schwing from Md.

>Bill, have you heard of compwood? I have been using it quite a lot in my creations. It is real wood, treated under great pressure and heat, that will remain flexible, VERY flexible, as long as it remains wet. Yes, even cold it remains totally flexible! When dry, it is as strong as regular dry timber.

It is not cheap, but it can save a lot of time, is extremely unique looking, and no glue mess.

They send it to you wrapped in plastic, and it remains bendable as long as it remains moist. I have bendable white oak, beech, cherry and walnut.

I'm not suggesting it is the perfect thing for you, but it might be!

Link below


Compwood

Re: Bent Lamination Questions

#4

Re: Bent Lamination Questions

Dave Mount

>Hi Bill--

"1. 1/8" thick pieces ok for thickness of strips?" -- Yes, with that little bit of bend, you could even go a little thicker.

"2. How close together might I need clamps to squash out the excess glue?" That depends on a lot of things. If you make mating pieces to distribute clamp force, you can get away with many fewer. If you don't want to fuss with making mating cauls, then I'd just apply clamps initially every 3-4" or so and observe the squeeze-out to decide whether you've got even pressure. Putting something crushable in the assembly, like a piece of carpet, can help spread the pressure a little. If you make your form to go against the inside curve, it would be easy to make cauls that would have two contact points by hollowing the middle of a short wood block. Wedges can also be used in place of regular clamps. Mounting the mold to a backing (e.g., OSB) allows it to align things in all three dimensions and also gives you something to attach blocks that you can wedge against.

"3. After assembling the stack should I add a backing piece (caul) to clamp against?" You can build a full mold or, if the curve is reasonably fair (meaning it is a curvature the wood would largely take naturally if you just bent a piece) you could just bent over a few points on the curve and just clamp the stack together at the intermediate points. Probably less fuss to just build a mold.

"4. I am presuming glue will seep out everywhere. How do I keep the leg stack from becoming one with the curved clamping jig? I was thinking of lining with wax paper if I can keep it in place." Waxed paper works. You can also paint your mold with wax; that's what I did when I built a strip canoe. Waxed paper is probably easier in this case.

Sounds like fun -- good luck!

Dave

Re: Bent Lamination Questions

#5

Lee Grindinger

Are you after a laminated look?

Lee Grindinger

>The bend you have in mind could be done with a 3/4" thick piece of air dried steamed, perhaps even kiln dried.

If you want the look of laminations I'd make both a male and female jig and use something like plastic laminate or galvanized steel for the jig faces, you'll want a surface the laminations can slide against as the pressure is applied.

I'm guessing you're aware of this but for the sake of the discussion I'll mention using a rigid glue like PPR and leave the yeller PVA glue in the bottle.

Lee

Re: Bent Lamination Questions

#6

Re: Bent Lamination Questions

Jesse Cloud

>Hey Bill,

For what its worth, here's how they teach bent lam in the school I attend:

1)Plan on about 50% yield from the wood you slice (e.g., if you want to wind up with a piece thats 1 inch thick, slice lams from a piece thats two inches thick).

2)Plan for a few inches extra length. Make a few extra lams just in case one of your machines decides to eat one. Cut your lam about 1/4 inch wide to allow for cleanup.

3)Make a mold of layers of mdf screwed and glued together. Start with a 1/4 inch piece, fair the curve nicely, mark the shape on a 3/4 piece, bandsaw roughly, glue and screw, trim with a router with a flush bit, add more 3/4 pieces as needed. Put wax (we use cheap parafin canning wax) on the business side of the mold.

4)Mill a square corner on your stock, leave 2 edges rough. Mark a triangle on one edge to show the sequence the lams come off.

5)Slice a lam on a well tuned bandsaw, maybe 1/32 thicker than you plan to use. Run the lam thru the planer using a cheater board and taking a very light cut. When smooth, take the lam to the mold and see if it will bend into it (in your example, I think 1/8 would work fine, maybe thicker). If it won't bend into the form, adjust the bandsaw to take a thinner slice and try again.

6)Now, if everything works, joint the stock flat, slice another lam, joint, slice, etc until you have used all the stock. While you have the bandsaw set up, slice a lam from poplar or something to use as a cover sheet to protect your real outside lam from glue.

7)Take the lams to the planer and plane as little as possible to get them smooth.

8)Assemble the lams in their original order (use the triangle you marked) and measure for thickness.

9)Almost showtime. Take the lams to a bench covered with something to protect it from the massive glue squeezeout about to happen. Assemble every clamp you can find. We put the clamps as close together as the bends will allow, not unusual to use 6-8 per foot. Make a bunch of blocks from scrap as long as your lams are wide and about 3/4 to 1 inch on the sides - these will be clamp cauls.

10)Lay your cover sheet near by. Spread glue on a lam or a few at a time and stack them in the proper order. No glue on the very last lam. When done, place the cover sheet on top - no glue!

11)Start from the middle and clamp to the mold, using the cauls on the coversheet. Alternate clamps so some handles are on one side and some on the other, to allow room to tighten.

12)work toward the ends, being careful that the lams stay in the same plane.

13)examine the edges for voids, adjust clamps if any found.

14)let it sit overnight.

15)unclamp and remove the cauls and the coversheet. If the coversheet has stuck to the piece, a scraper will fix that with a little elbow grease.

16)There will be squeezeout on both edges. Take the best edge and clean it up with a scraper (or on a bandsaw with an old blade, being careful to stay parallel with the other edge. Take this to the jointer and keeping the face flat against the fence, clean up the edge. Check for square.

17)Take that edge to the bandsaw fence and trim off the other gluey edge. If you have multiple pieces, stop here until they are all ready so that you can trim them all to the same width. One pass on the jointer and you are done!

We use titebond II glue.

Our teacher discourages two sided molds on the ground that unless they are really perfect, they will encourage voids. He also greatly prefers to put the lams on the concave side of the curve, so that the springback force is directed against the mold and not away from it.

Buy your buds some brew and get some help for that glue-up - pretty intense.

Hope this helped. Thanks again for your pieces about how lumber is made.

Re: Bent Lamination Questions

#7

Re: Bent Lamination Questions

Clay Foster

>Bill Tindall,

I've done several projects with bent laminations. This is a plant stand I did many years ago.

1/8" thick laminations work well. The thinner the laminations, the less spring back. Band saw a caul to the shape of the curve you want. Make the caul a couple of inches longer on each end than the final length you want. Put a piece of wax paper on a piece of MDF or plywood and screw the caul on top of that.

Use as many clamps as you can. 3" apart would be a minimum. I like to clamp against a convex shaped caul.

Cut enough laminations to do a test piece.

Use one of those glue squeeze bottles with a roller. It's a lot faster, and easier to get enough but too much glue.


img

Re: Bent Lamination Questions

#8

For that slight bend

Keith Newton, LR, Arkansas------WebKitFormBoundary

>And light duty service, I would just find a board with a slight grown in crook, or bend in the grain, then just saw the shape from solid stock. Don't look in the FAS stack. It will be easier to find in the #3 stacks.

Even a little grain run-out should not be a problem for this use. The plants won't be pushing back from the table and leaning back on the back legs, which can be a major problem with chairs.

Since I saw a lot of my own wood, I have a good supply that I have sawn from crooked stems just for this purpose. If I were trying to market it, that would mean a lower grade, but for sawing a curve that follows the grain, sure saves a lot of work, and time.

But if you are stuck on laminated bends. I would suggest that you cut your laminates as wide as you can easily achieve, then put them in a V-bag, then bend it around your form.

You can then just saw off a bunch. There is economy in multiples.

Re: Bent Lamination Questions

#9

send three legs to address below

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>just kidding. Those legs are just what I am after.

Re: Bent Lamination Questions

#10

Wow, thanks all....

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I can't miss with all that detailed advice. These responses would be nice to assemble into the Articles section.

Re: Bent Lamination Questions

#11

Ellis Walentine

Wait, there's more

Ellis Walentine

>To spread the clamping pressure and reduce the number of clamps, I always used multiple strips of 1/8" Masonite outside the actual laminate stack. You could easily use thicker strips for such a slight bend as this. Use lots of paste wax on the strip that comes into contact with your outer laminate and also on the edges of the stack. Clamping pressure radiates from the clamps at more or less 45� angles, so a 1"-thick stack of strips would allow you to place your clamps about 2" - 2 1/2" apart.

Male and female forms are even better for optimizing the number of clamps, but as someone noted, you can get holidays in the glue lines if the forms aren't perfectly matched to the actual lamination, which changes the relationship of the inside and outside curves. I used to line my forms with a strip of 1/8" cork to take up any slight imperfections.

I recommend Weldwood Plastic Resin glue rather than PVA because it doesn't creep and telegraph to the edges of your laminations. Plastic resin glue squeeze out is like razor wire, though, so you need to handle the dried laminations carefully. I like to use a 6" rotary sander with very coarse sandpaper to grind off the excess glue. Once you're down to bare wood, you can fair and flatten with the usual complement of tools and/or machines. Just be aware that the gluelines will dull your plane irons faster than usual.

Happy laminating.

Ellis

Re: Bent Lamination Questions

#12

Re: Wait, there's more and a little more

Barry Irby

>I have done a few of these. I like to use a "male" form, that is, clamp around the outside for the form. I find it easy to "chase" the voids out to the end. I either start clamping at one end and work to the other or in the middle and work both ways. When I try to use a concave or "female" form, I end up with voids that appear to be "wrinkles" trapped in the layers.

I coat my forms with Clear packing tape and sometimes polyethylene, like flimsy plastic bags. The tape works well. The plastic bags work well too, but give it something of a homeless look.

Also, In case it was not clear, there is a second reason to make the forms longer than you might think. Often, the ends of the stack will not conform nicely to the form. It takes three or four inches for the curve to fair and be tight. Also, its difficult to clamp the very end and the laminations will be offset. So add about four inches on each end and then cut out the sweet part.

For such slender pieces, have you considered making a piece four times as wide as you need and then ripping three out of it? One third as many to resaw and smooth, one glue up (harder, but not much), and only one or maybe two edges to clean up.

The last project I made, I made a form and then used "shackles" made of oak 2X2's and All-thread rods in place of conventional clamps. My little impact driver with a deep well socket made quick work of driving the nuts home.