Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Drill Press Safety Planer

Posts

Drill Press Safety Planer

#1

Drill Press Safety Planer

Justin Fields

>I've been looking at drill press safety planers. Right now, I see two, one of which is one sale.

The one on sale is a foreign-made one from Woodworker's Supply, Inc.:

http://woodworker.com/cgi-bin/FULLPRES.exe?PARTNUM=24760&LARGEVIEW=ON

The other one is a Wagner brand domestic one:

http://www.woodcraft.com/family.aspx?familyid=3189 or

http://www.stewmac.com/shop/Tools/Planes/Wagner_Safe-T-Planer.html

So, the real question is, who has experience with one or both? The pictures look darn near identical. Leaving the political aspect of the import/domestic issue aside for now, what do you think of the products themselves? Does Woodworker's Supply usually sell good quality stuff, or is it like a woodworking Harbor Freight? To me, Harbor Freight is a place where you can get really good deals on some stuff, if you understand what you are buying, the quality of it, and what usage it will be. Other stuff they sell is such junk I just steer away completely.

The price difference is substantial. The planer and a spare set of cutters come to about $100 for the Wagner and $35 for imported one.

Any thoughts?

Thanks!

Justin

Re: Drill Press Safety Planer

#2

Re: Drill Press Safety Planer

Robert R clough - Thorncraft

>Justin, I had such a planer several years ago, perhaps 15. I do not remember which I had but I'd guess the Wagner. It did work ok but no more than that, and at a relatively slow speed. Also, a light touch is required!! I found the device a tad troublesome and a bit less than satisfactory, I switched to a router planer box with a large bottom cleaning bit. Then, because of a lack of space, I went with a 16/32 drum sander and a hand plane.

Re: Drill Press Safety Planer

#3

Re: Drill Press Safety Planer

Carol - now in NC Nebraska

>There are many ways to plane wood. From a safety standpoint, this would be my very last.

Here is an opportunity to learn how to sharpen and use a hand plane, if inexpensive is one of the objectives. Many times it is also the fastest way to get the job done. I am not a hand tool junkie, just like to use the most efficient way.

Planing can also be done with a router - another whole subject.

But the reasons for planing are many and varied.

I am curious. Please give an example of what you planned on planing with this cutter.

Re: Drill Press Safety Planer

#4

Re: Drill Press Safety Planer

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla

>I used the Wagner years ago but only in a Bridgeport Vertical Milling Machine with automatic feed. It is a rather slow process and if there is any wobble in the drill press I think the results may not be as good as you would like. You can use a router to achieve the same results and possily pick up somewhere a used 12' portable for a couple hundred dollars.

Re: Drill Press Safety Planer

#5

Re: Drill Press Safety Planer

Binen

>These are very useful for very specific jobs. General planing don't bother. I have one and use it for 2 jobs. First when I turn center of a small pedistal table. I have a jig made up I can plane 3 or 4 flat surfaces for the feet. I also have a jig made up that allows me to taper small pieces when needed. Other than those unless you have a job in mind they are not much good.

Binen

Re: Drill Press Safety Planer

#6

Re: Drill Press Safety Planer

Justin Fields

>To clarify a couple issues based on responses:

The whole reason I'm considering buying this would be to gently smooth segmented turning glue-ups. If you can visualize a half or whole donut of glued segments lying on its side, this would be used to take out the thickness variation so that it could end up glued cleanly to the layer underneath it.

This is obviously a less than ideal method, which seems to be a drum sander. But in another thread, I asked about drum sanding alternatives, because I don't have a shop of my own. So even if I bought one, I'd have no place to store or use it.

Thanks.

Justin

Re: Drill Press Safety Planer

#7

Sounds like....

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>Sounds like you're trying to avoid the cost of a $400 lunchbox planer or more expensive drum sander. I can appreciate that. But if you have a router, instead of this drill press thingy, I'd spend the money on a good router bit and along with some scraps of wood or aluminum/steel angle iron, you can make a jig to use your router to do the planing.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Drill Press Safety Planer

#8

Re: Drill Press Safety Planer

Mike Schwing from Md.

>I once listed this exact tool on a forum thread as the biggest waste of tool money I ever spent. I would still list it today.

Re: Drill Press Safety Planer

#9

lathe sanding disk

Phil Joines Krum, Tx

>make a sanding disk for the lathe using a faceplate and a piece of plywood.

Re: Drill Press Safety Planer

#10

Re: Drill Press Safety Planer

Justin Fields

>That is a strong statement.

Is it that the tool doesn't function very well at all, or that it works okay, but for very limited usage? If the former, then I'll probably pass on it. I'm not looking to replace a regular planer, which I have access to, or use it to remove any substantial thickness of stock. I'm only looking to smooth off about an inch or so wide glue up.

Just curious what about it you found lacking. I do appreciate the feedback and take it seriously.

Justin

Re: Drill Press Safety Planer

#11

Re: lathe sanding disk

Justin Fields

>I'll give that a go the next time I get into the shop.

When you have worn down the abrasive, do you usually scrape it off, or just glue another layer on top? If you use the lathe-sander for the same thing I'm going to, what has your experience shown to be the most suitable grit?

Thanks.

Justin

Re: Drill Press Safety Planer

#12

Re: Drill Press Safety Planer

Stuart Johnson

>Justin, You can easily flatten your ring on the lathe. Use Cole jaws to hold the ring. If you don't have a chuck then hot glue the rough ring to a disk attached to a face plate. Use your gouge or a scraper to roughly flatten then use a sanding board to bring flat. Once you have one side flattened you can glue the flattened side to your piece and go through the same flattening steps to the other side.

You might want to post your turning questions over on the turning board.

Re: Drill Press Safety Planer

#13

Second that.

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>> You might want to post your turning questions over on the turning board.

And while you're there, ping Mark Kauder. Although I'm sure there are other segmented turning specialists, I know Mark is one, and I've seen his work. I'm sure he could help point you in a good direction. I haven't seen him post in a while, though. I hope he's still turning.

Rod

Re: Drill Press Safety Planer

#14

Re: Second that.

Justin Fields

>I actually did post over there earlier, and got suggestions, one of which was the safety planer. Others were offered as well. I was over here just to ask about the safety planer specifically, but we've digressed back to the bigger issue.

Good and varied suggestions both times, though. I'm working my way towards at least one solution I can get comfortable with.

Thanks!

Justin

Re: Drill Press Safety Planer

#15

Re: Drill Press Safety Planer

Jesse Cloud

>Hey Justin,

I agree with the advice above about the "safety" planer, I bought one years ago, never used it, sold it.

Woodworker's Supply is a solid company, not a Harbor Freight. Most of what they sell is name brand and they do stand by their products. Not to say that the particular thing you are looking at is a quality product - just about every dealer, even Lee Valley, has some cheap junk in the inventory. But I deal pretty often with Woodworker's (one of their three warehouse/stores is nearby) and have no complaints.

Re: Drill Press Safety Planer

#16

I Have The Saf-T-Planer for Drill Press

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Morning Justin,

I bought the Wagner a few years ago to help thickness smnall pieces of wood for furniture repair/parts replacement. I found the device of good quality material, fit and finish. The cutters are reversable and replaceable. It requires very close attention and very shallow passes for it to be "SAFE". I bought it as a cheap alternative to other tools and methods because I couldn't afford better at the time. The Wagner works. However, I recommend you carefully consider other methods expressed above because they are better.. I don't use my Wagner anymore.

George

Re: Drill Press Safety Planer

#17

Mike and Justin, get together on this

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

>Mike says it's one of his waste-of-money tools. Why not send it to Justin for the cost of shipping?

Re: Drill Press Safety Planer

#18

If I still have it, you got it

Mike Schwing from Md.

>However, I found it to be terribly lacking. The tool is strong and will throw the workpiece off of the table if not extremely well clamped down. I recall it throwing the piece off the table at me with surprising force. I didn't use the thing more than once or twice because of that. Forget holding the piece by hand. And since it has to be adjusted with every single "press" of the drill press, it is an interminably long procedure.

I can do the same job, much better and faster with hand planes and scrapers. But then again, I have about 100 hand planes..

If I can find it, and I think I know where it is, Justin can have it if he sends me his shipping address.

Re: Drill Press Safety Planer

#19

the Wagner is worth the money

Robin Corell in Atascadero, CA

>This was how I used to use a safety planer with the best results. They are slow and leave a less then finished quality surface. In fact I think you would find the surface quality unacceptable for your application.

I have used both the wagner and the import planers and found the wagner to be worth the money. The arbor on the sharpening stone for the iport was not acurate enough to be able to use it to sharpen the cutters. also the cutters are not as high quality and loose their edge much faster and the geopmetry is just diferent enough to cause a bit more friction and toast the tips faster.

Another method that would work for your application is to use a small disc mounted in a dril press. I use the twist lock discs and cut the center out and then glue them onto a madrel I made. My mandrel is a 3" diameter piece of 1" thick aluminium with a 1/2" shaft pressed into it. With this set up I can remove as little as .005". With a 36D resin coated disc I can remove as much as .020" in a single pass. it is very controlable and very acurate with a much better surface quality than the safty planers. I use weather strip adhesive and let it dry over night.

One of the items I make is a segmented table lamp. I flatten one side on my disc sander and then use a small disc in my drill press to get the other side parellel. in batches of 10 lamps with 3 layers for each lamp it takes me about 45 minutes to do all the layers. I should add thatr I don't bother planeing my stock before hand as this step takes care of that so you can subtracct the time for that.

I have also used this same little tt=hickness sander for thicknessing shop made veneer down to .030". I don't do any veneer work but use it for shims and repair ocasionaly. It is nice to be able to make it out of any wood I choose.

Robin

Re: Drill Press Safety Planer

#20

Re: If I still have it, you got it

Justin Fields

>I'll give it a go. E-mail sent.

Thanks!

Justin

Re: Drill Press Safety Planer

#21

Re: Second that.

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>Justin,

I would stay away from the Safety Planer. I have not heard very many good things about the results.

I concure that using cole jaws, or just a piece of plywood attached to a faceplate with sandpaper on it are a better and safer solution. You need only flatten one side, then glue to the bowl, and then true it up on the lathe. To me this is the basic process whether you use cole jaws, sanding disks or a performax.

Mark

Re: Drill Press Safety Planer

#22

Re: I Have The Saf-T-Planer for Drill Press

Paul Waddle

>Want to sell the Wagoner? I have one and used it extensively until the blades gave up. Seems they cost as much as the tool. Its a good tool for making small desk signs. pw

Re: Drill Press Safety Planer

#23

Re: lathe sanding disk *LINK*

Phil Joines Krum, Tx

>I use preglued rolls from Klingspore and remove them when dull. Grit depends on how much material you need to remove but 120 is a good place to start.


PSA rolls

Re: Drill Press Safety Planer

#24

Re: I Have The Saf-T-Planer for Drill Press

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Afternoon Paul,

No Paul. I think I'll hang on to it. Thanks for asking.

George