I guess it's a regional thing...
steve antonucci
>15 minutes in my local would not be a big deal. We wait 15 minutes to go to TGI Fridays around here (NY Metro).
As far as the steak goes, if it was wrong, you should have said something immediately. A good steak house in NY has the waiters by the table within a minute of the steak being delivered and they always ask if it's right. Of course, since they're in the steak business, it's always right too. Unfortunately, it's not $20, but more like $35-50 depending upon the cut you like.
And if you want a salad with it, it's usually ordered on the side (not included with the steak). When we go out for steaks, we usually pick the best steakhouse in the area (on vacation), and we don't have to worry about these things. Honestly, I've never gotten one that was "wrong" and usually the exact opposite of your situation- waiters hovering around the table because they know their tips depend upon it.
My philosophy is simple- the waiter is your personal connection to the restaurant. It is their job to make sure that the kitchen gets it right. People are human and make mistakes, but my waiter needs to treat me like I am the only table he/she has while I am there. I am not a high maintenance customer, but I shouldn't need to ask for waters to be refilled, where my food is, or correct his/her mistakes with my order (who gets what at the table). Once the food is on the table, go away.
I have 4 kids from 9 to 2 years old. Some of the best waiters I've ever found work at Disneyworld. Want to know why? Because they recognize that everyone at the table, even the kids, colors your dining experience. All it takes is one person to be unhappy to ruin a meal, and they treat every guest with the same level of commitment.
Next time you are out, if something is wrong, say it. A good restaurant will fix it, and a bad one won't. Don't tell them how to fix it, just that it's wrong. This will put the resolution to the problem on them and you won't look like someone looking for a freebie.
A true story- Three of us went to a restaurant and ordered dinner. Just the guys. We were eating, talking, and had a little wine. I order a pasta dish, and half way through, I found what appeared to be an earthworm in my dish. I pushed it aside, and continued eating, figuring I hadn't died with the first half. My buddies were telling me it was a mushroom or something else. At the end of the meal, with about 2 pieces left, our waiter came over and asked how everything was. I asked her "what's this?" and the color drained from her face. She grabbed the dish and ran to the kitchen.
In about 2 minutes the manage came over and began apologizing. They used fresh herbs in all of their cooking from the garden outside, and the "worm" may have been on the basil plant... she told us to order desert, offered to bring me another dinner (I told her I was stuffed), apologized again and then comped our meal. Then, she gave me her card, and told me to call her the next time we were coming in, and she'd comp THAT meal too. ( I never took her up on it)
So, you see, if there's something wrong, just say it and you'll know where you stand...
Steven