Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Need help identifying wood, please

Posts

Need help identifying wood, please

#1

Need help identifying wood, please

Joanne Adler in Pt. Pleasant, PA

>They are getting ready to work on the side road by my house. They need to fix the culverts and drainage. In aid of that, they are cutting down some trees. On my way past that corner of my property last night I noticed they�d cut one of my trees right next to the road, and had stacked some logs. I walked up the hill to look today and pulled these down. They looked as if the tree had already died or lost its bark perhaps. I piled some in the yard cart to haul down to the barn. I thought they might make nice boxes or something.

But, while I�m pretty good identifying wood from boards, I am mostly clueless about trees, especially when they are cut down and have no leaves or bark. What is this? Looks a little like cherry to me, but that may be wishful thinking, since I love cherry.

Can you help identify from these shots? I recut a bad piece to see a fresh crosscut. The rest I left whole. Thanks in advance for your expertise.






Re: Need help identifying wood, please

#2

Re: Need help identifying wood, please

Ray Binnicker

>Looks a little like Black Locust. Does it have a unpleasant smell when you cut it? That would be one clue it is locust.

Ray Binnicker

Re: Need help identifying wood, please

#3

Re: Need help identifying wood, please

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>It would be easier to tell from the bark. From the area around here, I would guess ash or oak if the bark is rough or maple if the bark is smoothish. Lotta choices.

Clint

Re: Need help identifying wood, please

#4

Re: Need help identifying wood, please

Rick in Colgate, Wi

>I would guess red elm judging by the split in the wood and the fact that all the bark has peeled. Whenever an elm dies on my lot it only takes a few years for all the bark to fall off, some of the older dead standing elms also has long splits exactly as in your picture.

They only get maybe 8-10" across before they die, probably due to dutch elm disease.

Re: Need help identifying wood, please

#5

Re: Need help identifying wood, please

John K Jordan

>That tree looks long dead. The color and ring appearance of your first picture of the end grain looks very much like black locust but the quartersawn section does not and the smaller end grain sections do not.

You might check where that tree came from and see if there are any living in the same spot that might be the same species and still have the bark. That would help, since many bark structures are very distinctive.

You can can guess all day from a photograph of a log section or board and still be wrong since many species look alike on this level. In the absence of leaves/flowers/bark, examining the structure under a magnifier or low-power microscope is the most reliable way to identify most species.

If you can, take a small piece and using a razor blade clean up a bit of the end grain and look at it with a magnifier. Is it diffuse or ring porous? large or small pores, ??? Cherry is diffuse porous: the pores are distributed evenly through the ring. Oak is strongly ring porous, with many large pores bunched up in the earlywood. Elm is ring porous with latewood pores in wavy bands. Black locust is very heavy and hard wood, strongly ring porous, with pores in clusters or groups, and distinctively abundant tyloses (clear, sparkley, bubble-like membranes filling the large pores. White oak has tyloses, red oak does not. There are many other indicators.

If you are interested in identifying wood in general, it's hard to go wrong with the book "Identifying Wood" by R. Bruce Hoadley. He has photomacrographs of the end grains of various common woods along with descriptions. I'm still an amateur at this, but if you want, mail a small piece that contains at least one complete ring section (usually about 1/2" square by 1/4" thick is plenty) and I'll be glad to take a shot at it.

BTW, the US government will identify up to five samples per year for citizens.

JKJ

Re: Need help identifying wood, please

#6

Re: Need help identifying wood, please

Jim Shaver Oakville, Ontario

>Ditch Wood??!!??

:-)

Looks like an American Exotic to me...

:-)

Re: Need help identifying wood, please

#7

Re: Need help identifying wood, please

John Veerkamp

>looks like elm to me also

Re: Need help identifying wood, please

#8

Chinese Elm?

Robin Corell in Atascadero, CA

>It is hard to tell from the pics but it looks a little like chinese elm. Chinese is a bit harder than red elm and lacks the barn yard smell comon to many elms. I find chinese to have a spicey almost peppery scent. It works nicely and turns well. I have used it for all my chisel handles as well as my carving mallet.

Robin


img

Re: Need help identifying wood, please

#9

Dale Lenz

Re: Need help identifying wood, please

Dale Lenz

>I'd guess some sort of elm also, but from your pictures its difficult to tell. JLJ has the correct ID features down well. Send John and me a small chuck if you wish. I ID wood a few times a year in my job.

Re: Need help identifying wood, please

#10

Dale Lenz

Re: Edit: JKL, sorry John

Dale Lenz

>

Re: Need help identifying wood, please

#11

Dale Lenz

Re: Edit: 2, Gees, JKJ

Dale Lenz

>

Re: Need help identifying wood, please

#12

Re: Need help identifying wood, please

Clay Foster

>Joanne,

If I saw that growing around here in Texas I would say it was elm.

Re: Need help identifying wood, please

#13

Steven Antonucci

Another vote for elm (of some kind)

steve antonucci

>

Re: Need help identifying wood, please

#14

Any smell left ?

steve mackay

>

Re: Need help identifying wood, please

#15

No, doesn't really smell bad.

Joanne Adler in Pt. Pleasant, PA

>

Re: Need help identifying wood, please

#16

Re: Need help identifying wood, please

Don Orr

>Elm is a definite possibility, but has anyone considered Mimosa ? Also known as silkwood tree. The first photo looks very much like a Mimosa tree I took down for my FIL a few years ago. The bandsawn wedge also looks like Mimosa. I don't see any indication of the interlocked grain of Elm in the bandsawn piece, it's usually pretty obvious.

Re: Need help identifying wood, please

#17

Re: Need help identifying wood, please

Al Killian

>Looks like grey elm.

Re: Need help identifying wood, please

#18

Hmmm, Mimosa?

Joanne Adler in Pt. Pleasant, PA

>I have some of that here. I had to take down one of those trees. I'll put some side by side.

Re: Need help identifying wood, please

#19

Re: Need help identifying wood, please

Joe Mohnike

>Looks like mimosa to me. I have used it in the past. I made some bowls and stemware out of it. The color and grain explode when turned and finished. Wish I had more of it.

Joe

Re: Need help identifying wood, please

#20

my guess from examining the sample

John K Jordan

>Joanne,

I got the sample of wood you sent. I counted 38 rings.

Attached is a quick photo taken through my microscope at 10x by holding a digital camera up to the eyepiece. Sorry about the quality. As you see, I didn't take time to prepare the surface properly but I think it's enough to see the structure.

The main features visible are:

- Ring-porus sturcture

- Earlywood: more than one pore wide

- Latewood: Pores in wavy bands (ulmiform)

- Tyloses: none clearly visible

From these features, the wood appears to be either Slippery Elm or Hackberry/Sugarberry as described by R. Bruce Hoadley in his book "Identifying Wood". Hoadley mentions a feature distinguishing between Slippery Elm and Hackberry without using a high power microscope is the color: the heartwood of Hackberry is more creamy to yellowish-grey brown while Slippery Elm is more reddish brown. Unfortunately the small sample you sent appeared long dead and may have lost some color near the surface, but to me it does appear more towards the redish side. (You have to ignore the color in the attached photo since it was taken with a halogen light source and not corrected for color balance.) Also, based on the sample photos that Hoadley includes in his book, your sample does look more "elmy" than "hackberryey". :)

A more certain identification can be made with a higher power microscope by looking at the rays. Hackberry is 10-13 seriate while the elms are 1-7. Someday I hope to get a second microscope with higher power. This one is a good binocular microscope with 10 and 20 power, excellent for "macro" viewing.

Based on the sample you sent and the references I have, I'm going to guess Elm, likely Slippery Elm. Other features rule out American Elm or Winged Elm, the other elms described in Hoadley's book. It will be interesting to see what the experts tell you.

BTW, I tallied the WoodCentral guesses:

some kind of elm - 6

mimosa - 2

black locust, oak, maple - 1 each

Pretty good, considering how difficult it is to ID wood without a magnifier.

JKJ


img

Re: Need help identifying wood, please

#21

Re: my guess from examining the sample

Joanne in Pt. Pleasant, PA

>Thanks again so much, John! I am so impressed. I will be sure to post the response I get from the Forest Service. They do not work as quickly as you do; I do not expect an answer for another week or two, at least.

Re: Need help identifying wood, please

#22

Wood ID--finally a word from Forest Service

Joanne Adler in Pt. Pleasant, PA

>Back in March I posted some pics of a tree cut down on my land, requesting help with identification. Many of you took a stab at it. The most popular guess was Elm. John Jordan posted a link to the US Forest Service and said they will ID up to 5 samples a year for free. He also volunteered to try to do his own analysis. I sent a piece off to both John and the Forest Service. You may remember John's scientific and thorough description of his findings. He said it was Elm and he counted 38 rings.

I just received my answer from the Forest Service (took a bit longer than their promised 3 weeks, but at least they replied). They were not as generous as John in their explanation:

"Ulmus--a species of Elm. More like 37-41 years."

I guess such verbosity is why they probably spend more time with trees than people.

My thanks again to John, and everyone else who took a shot at the ID job.

Re: Need help identifying wood, please

#23

Re: Wood ID--finally a word from Forest Service

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Hi Joanne,

The Forrest Service probably didn't want to go out on a limb too far.

Regards to Fred. :<) Love that Table top!

George

Re: Need help identifying wood, please

#24

Re: Wood ID--finally a word from Forest Service

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla

>A lot depends on which branch of the service did the report.

Re: Need help identifying wood, please

#25

Hardly any research involved

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>they just leaf through their books.