Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Sprung joints...what gives?

Posts

Sprung joints...what gives?

#1

Sprung joints...what gives?

Stuart Hough

>Why is a sprung (or spring) joint a good thing to use? I'm still learning, and would love to understand why this technique works. Will it hold up over the long term? Is it better than a perfectly parallel edge joint? Thanx in advance for any insight that might be offered.

Re: Sprung joints...what gives?

#2

Re: Sprung joints...what gives?

Sgian Dubh

>When joining narrow boards to make up wider slabs the traditional approach is the plain edge or butt joint. This is a good place to start because it helps with understanding other methods. It isn�t really an easy joint to prepare, and like every joint, proper preparation means reduced risk of failure. The idea is to prepare two edges that abut perfectly all along the length so that no pressure is required to close a gap. In practice, this is difficult to achieve and most workers aim for a �sprung� joint.

The sprung joint has an evenly graduating gap produced that's widest at the centre point of the joint line of the two boards. After preparation very gentle hand pressure should be enough to close up two adjacent boards. When cramping up several well prepared boards in one go it is sometimes possible to close up all the gaps with one centrally located cramp.

The sprung joints helps counteract the comparatively volatile width expansion and contraction of the last 50- 100 mm (2- 4�) of a plank�s length. The end grain of timber absorbs and gives up moisture the most rapidly. During glue up of the sprung joint, the ends are closed just a little tighter than the middle, and this helps to compensate for the disparate movement.

In addition to this, custom and practise show that where the two joined edges are convex at glue-up the joint usually fails fairly quickly. In this situation bringing the edges together requires firm clamping pressure at both ends to close the gap. The joint will close, but both ends of the joint are under tensile stress and want to open up. As soon as a slight opening begins at the very extremity of the joint it�s my experience that serious failure soon follows-- a gap anything up to a few inches long extending towards the middle of the length develops in just days. The worst case is complete failure of the joint.


A sprung joint. The gap is somewhat exaggerated here for clarity. When joining boards up to about 800 mm (32�) long the ideal gap at the mid-point should be about the same thickness as perhaps a cigarette paper. Longer edge joints tolerate a slightly wider gap. The ideal gap is one that will close with little or no more pressure than you�d need to hold something like a downward facing telephone directory with fingers and thumb either side of the spine.

The sprung joint on the other hand is much more durable. When formed correctly both ends of the joint should remain tight. Even with the greater volatility of expansion and contraction at the ends of a plank a gap doesn�t form. I use a zip as an analogy to explain what goes on. Close a zip and lock the tab at the end and the zip stays closed. Pull up the zip and leave the tag unlocked and the zip gradually opens.

Slainte.

Re: Sprung joints...what gives?

#3

Re: Sprung joints...what gives?

John Renzetti-Chadds Ford, PA

>Hello Richard, That's a great explanation of the sprung joint. I know that there is a misconception that you must see daylight between the edges in order for it to be a proper sprung joint. A British cabinetmaker and technician told me that a good test was to put the two freshly jointed edges one on top of the other. You shouldn't see daylight but there should be resistance on both ends so that the top board does not want to pivot. A friend has a Martin jointer where the infeed table angle can be electronically adjusted to vary the joint.

take care,

John

Re: Sprung joints...what gives?

#4

Don't sweat it

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>If the wood is well dried and absent internal stresses that want to warp it, parallel edges and Titebond glue is all that's required. I've never had such a joint fail or pull apart at the ends.

Clint

Re: Sprung joints...what gives?

#5

Re: Sprung joints...what gives?

Mike Fitterling

>Northfield jointers also had the option of a spring joint lever (although mine does not have the option) that adjusted the outfeed table to result in that joint. Tage Fird also explains the spring joint in his Tage Frid Teaches Woodworking, Book One. IIRC, the reason he used them was to eliminate the need for so many clamps, as the joint is somewhat self calmping with the application of a clamp in the middle. Gathering from what I've read, this used to be a very commmon practice.

Re: Sprung joints...what gives?

#6

Re: Sprung joints...what gives?

Sgian Dubh

> "this used to be a very commmon practice"

It still is in my work Mike, and I demonstrate the technique to the learners that pass through. Slainte.

Re: Sprung joints...what gives?

#7

Re: Don't sweat it

wilbur

>Hi Clint,

What you say is true, but "if the wood is well dried and absent internal stresses that want to warp it" I've found to be a bit of a leap of faith for me. Maybe I need to find better wood.

But in any case, it only takes a few swipes of a hand plane to make a sprung edge joint, and I've found that my sprung edge joints are tighter than when I don't make the sprung edge.

Re: Sprung joints...what gives?

#8

Re: Don't sweat it

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>Maybe I'm missing something and not to be argumentative, but how can a joint be any tighter if there is continuously intimate contact and under continuously equal pressure throughout its length?

Clint

Re: Sprung joints...what gives?

#9

Thanx for all the responses!

Stuart Hough

>I think I understand it much better now. Seems like something I'll have to work on. Thanx!

Re: Sprung joints...what gives?

#10

Re: Don't sweat it

wilbur

>Hi Clint,

Let me try rephrasing that.

I find that making a sprung joint consistently results in a thinner glue line than if I don't try for a sprung joint. Also, I find that making a sprung joint takes less time and effort than making a non-sprung joint, since I only have to ensure that the ends of the joint mate well, and not the entire edge.

The hollow space in a sprung joint is really pretty minimal. I only take 1-2 swipes over the middle part of the edge of each board to spring the joint. (Is that the proper term? If not, it should be.) At about 0.002" per shaving, that results in a gap that's still under 1/100th of an inch, which is probably still further compressed between fiber swelling from glue moisture and clamping pressure during glue up.

Of course, that sprung joints work better for me may just be a reflection of my inability to plane a straight edge. But the bottom line for me is that a sprung joint gives me better results with less effort, and may have the advantage of less chance for failure over time. To put it another way, it's a good way to get a perfect joint with less than perfect materials.

Re: Sprung joints...what gives?

#11

Re: Don't sweat it

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>Just to continue the discussion, I'll explain my approach and rationale. I never attempt to joint an edge by hand with a plane. I ain't good enough to do it well enough, but the jointer is. Even if the mating edges that come off the jointer aren't perfect, which is not uncommon, they are good enough not to show light. I cut biscuit slots close to the ends and about every 15" in between for registration, irrelevant of strength contribution. I run a thin bead of Titebond on one board only and give it a finger smear to more or less coat the edge. Enough glue gets in the biscuit slots so that when I set the biscuits some gets out to smear on the exposed sides of the biscuits. I mate the boards and clamp just enough to feel moderately strong resistance, but not so much that the clamps want to buckle the joint. There is usually very little squeezeout and the joint practically disappears. I immediately scrape off any squeezeout with a putty knife and wipe down the joint with a wet paper towel.

Using this technique in many different woods of varying grain and figure, I have never had a joint open at the ends or fail in any other way. As an aside, sometimes boards coming off the table saw are true enough to join to the same quality without further ado.

Finally, all are entitled to work in whatever fashion that makes one comfortable. There's no RIGHT way to do many things, and traditional hand working methods are not inviolaby carved in stone.

Clint

DWBH