Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Is there an accurate 2' or 4' straightedge

Posts

Is there an accurate 2' or 4' straightedge

#1

Is there an accurate 2' or 4' straightedge

Dan Mitchell

>available w/o spending a mint? I see the Woodcraft store brand Pinnacle has 2' & 4' "precision" straight edges (no units) said to be accurate ti .001"/ft for $89.99 & $189.99, respectively, as well as a 2'"precision" straight edge rule of unspecified "straightness" for $45. I'm sure any of them would be an improvement over my 25 year old $6 craftsman 2' square & 4' wooden level. I'm mostly looking for something to help check/tune machines at this point. I have a couple dial indicators/bases, various micrometers & feeler guauges from my engine rebuilding days, but no really good straight edge. Any suggestions?

Thanks

Dan

Re: Is there an accurate 2' or 4' straightedge

#2

Cheaper by threes - DIY alert *LINK*

David Barnett - SW Florida

>Mild steel or 6061 aluminum can be got cheaply. Precision ground tool steel is nice but expensive unless you have a use for one or both 'extra' pieces.


Making Accurate Straight-Edges from Scratch

Re: Is there an accurate 2' or 4' straightedge

#3

Here you go.

Forrest Addy

>But can you afford it?

http://cgi.ebay.com/Vintage-Tool-Brown-Sharpe-Cast-Iron-Straight-Edge-36_W0QQitemZ320227389097QQihZ011QQcategoryZ12581QQrdZ1QQssPageNameZWD1VQQ_trksidZp1638.m118.l1247QQcmdZViewItem

Sorry, couldn't resist. This is not a good choice for a woodshop straight edge. Its reference is an actual face not an area more suitable for checking precison surfaces.

If you need an actual certifiable straight edge, better use a precision straight edge. If you can accept some error consider a piece of 1/4 x 3 cold rolled flat stock purchased from a specialy steel supplier.

Re: Is there an accurate 2' or 4' straightedge

#4

Re: Lee Valley - steel and/or aluminum

Al Stokka - Cambridge, Iowa

>Dan,

Lee Valley has both steel and aluminum straightedges at reaonable prices.

Aluminum straightedge

http://www.leevalley.com/wood/page.aspx?c=2&p=50074&cat=1,240,45313

Steel straightedge

http://www.leevalley.com/wood/page.aspx?c=2&p=56676&cat=1,240,45313

Al

Re: Is there an accurate 2' or 4' straightedge

#5

Lee Valley or maybe Woodpeckers

Scott in Montana

>I have the Lee Valley steel and aluminum straight edges and think they're great. I also have Starrett and Moore & Wright straight edges but use them very sparingly as they are just too expensive and therefore put safely away. This makes them troublesome to get out, so since the Lee Valley edges are as accurate,I use the them almost daily.

I also see that Woodpeckers has new straight edges and I'll bet they're very nice product as well. I have their squares and am very happy with the products.

Scott

Re: Is there an accurate 2' or 4' straightedge

#6

What's wong with a drywall T-square?

Tim Greif - West of Chicago

>I check my jointer tables with my Unifence and that's not really all that precise, but good enough to do what I want. If you need longer, I don't see why a drywall T-square wouldn't be accurate enough.

Re: Is there an accurate 2' or 4' straightedge

#7

Re: Is there an accurate 2' or 4' straightedge

Walt Turpening

>From my days doing drafting with paper, pencils, triangles, etc. I have some 12", 18", 24" and 48" steel straight edges. So check office supply houses that carry drafting supplies. They are still available and typically less expensive.

Re: Is there an accurate 2' or 4' straightedge

#8

Re: Is there an accurate 2' or 4' straightedge

Dan Mitchell

>Thanks for the replies. Since one task I'm concerned about is setting up/checking a new jointer, the 50" aluminum Lee Valley looks good and a good deal at $72. Is .003" accurate enough for this task?

The article on making your own looks intriguing. I'm just afraid my home made straight edge proving my new jointer (if I EVER GET ONE... )is out of whack may not cut much ice with the dealer/manufacturer. Given the way this purchase has gone so far (and already having owned a warped Delta), I'm already anticipating this battle.

Dan

Re: Is there an accurate 2' or 4' straightedge

#9

Don't like the steel one

GolfSteve in Calgary

>Is is just me, or is the steel Lee Valley straight edge hard to use?

The problem I have with it is that it is sooo thick at the working edge. It is around 1/4" thick. This means that when eyeballing light sneaking under the straight edge you must be looking straight at the edge, otherwise parallax(?) will block out the light.

I had a chance to use a Starrett straight edge once. What I like about it compared to the Lee Valley was that the working edge was thin so that the edge wouldn't block out light if you weren't looking exactly straight on.

I think Lee Valley should bevel one edge of their steel straight edge down to about 3/32" thick.

What about you?

ps. I like their aluminium straight edges.

Re: Is there an accurate 2' or 4' straightedge

#10

Mine's the LV aluminum unit

Howard In Toronto

>does everything I could ever hope tro ask of a straightedge

HTH

Howard

Re: Is there an accurate 2' or 4' straightedge

#11

Re: Don't like the steel one

Scott in Montana

>Gosh Al, I never thought about it. I guess it might be easier if it was thinner. I like the fact that it doesn't fall over as easily as my Starrett. Incidentally, I inherited the Starrett.

Scott

Re: Is there an accurate 2' or 4' straightedge

#12

Re: Don't like the steel one

Al Stokka - Cambridge, Iowa

>Steve,

The edge width, seems to me, depends on what you intend to do with the straighedge. Consider an inexpensive pool table with a flakeboard playing surface. This pool table surface isn't flat because the weight of the flakeboard itself causes it to sag. But, the wise manufacturer put crossbars on the underside and provided thumbscrew to flatten the table by tightening or loosening the thumbscrews at various locations. If it were you job to flatten the table, a straightedge with a wide edge that would stand by itself would be ideal since you have to crawl or reach under teh table to access the thumbscrews.

On the other hand, if you want to use the see-the-light method, a thin edge would work better. In the end, it depends on your use of the straightedge. One isn't better than the other; just made for different application.

Al