Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

forrest blade sharpening

Posts

forrest blade sharpening

#1

forrest blade sharpening

Eric in Los Gatos

>Good day,

I have a Forrest Woodworker II blade that I have been very happy with but now needs sharpening. Forrest seems pretty adamant about being the only people who should sharpen their blades. Ever the cynic, I have to wonder how much truth there is to this. If I have a local good shop is there going to be a difference or not?

In the bonus round, if you think a local shop is the way to go and can recommend someone in the San Jose / Los Gatos, CA area I would really appreciate it.

Thanks as always for you help.

Eric in Los Gatos

Re: forrest blade sharpening

#2

Re: forrest blade sharpening

Ray Binnicker

>I have 2 Forrest blades. No one but Forrest has ever sharpened them. I'm sure there are lots of good sharpeners out there, but not in my area. I have to ship them out anyway so I choose to send them to Forrest. I am 100% confident I will get them back as sharp as they were the day I bought them.

Ray Binnicker

Re: forrest blade sharpening

#3

Re: forrest blade sharpening

Binen

>I have all Forrest blades and no one but them sharpens them. The way I figure is the very best anyone else can do is what Forrest will do. And a lot will do less. They don't charge that much and it is worth every penny. When they come back they are just like new, every time.

Binen

Re: forrest blade sharpening

#4

Sharpened by others: No longer a Forrest

Scott in Montana

>

Re: forrest blade sharpening

#5

They really do a great job!

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>Eric,

I've had my Forrest Woodworker II for about 8 years now and have only sent it to Forrest for sharpening. They usually do such a great job that I am hesitant about sending the saw blade anywhere but there. Plus, they have a quick turn around. I recently sent them my WWII to sharpen and it was back within a week. And the cuts I'm getting are once again out of sight!

FWIW, I'd suggest staying with them for sharpening.

See ya around,

Dominic

Re: forrest blade sharpening

#6

Baloney!

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>More marketing hype from Forest. They prey on the insecure woodworker.

We have a near-by saw shop, Misenheimer in Morristown TN. They make all sorts of wood cutting devices at their factory and sharpen them as well. It is common to see several hundred blades in their receiving department awaiting sharpening. I asked if they could sharpen a Forest blade. They said they sharpen hundreds of them a year. So I asked what was special about sharpening them. They replied, nothing. Now that is not to say that anyone can sharpen this blade or any other carbide blade. But it is a pretty safe bet that any company that makes blades can sharpen one.

They did show me what was different about the Forest blade compared to a typical carbide blade. That report is in the Articles section. BTW, several competitors now have blades similarly constructed for those who feel smoothness of cut is their most important blade criteria.

To find a reliable saw shop ask at large volume woodworking operation-cabinet shop, furniture factory, etc.- where they get their stuff sharpened .

Re: forrest blade sharpening

#7

Re: Baloney!

Barry Irby

>Bill, I agree with you that any competent shop should be able to sharpen a Forrest blade.

OTOH, years ago I took two hollow ground blades to a local shop and they gave them back, nicely set. They went from being trim blades for my chop saw to poor imitations of a chain saw.

I think I will send my Forrest blade back to Forrest.

Re: forrest blade sharpening

#8

Re: Baloney!

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>I've had one, count 'em, one blade for my saw for the last 20 years, a Systimatic combination. It's an odd duck, not many mfgers make a 9" blade anymore.

Anyway, I lucked upon a local sharpener, actually a local branch of a worldwide operation - Leitz tooling systems. They sharpened my very good Systimatic I'll bet as well as any Forrest. That sucker cut like never before.

There's one just as good, also nearly local - Eide Saw in Mpls - that does a fantastic job.

I agree with Bill. There's nothing magic about the Forrest service. What Forrest does, however, is match their original grind. If you like that, well, then that's the ticket.

Bruce

Re: forrest blade sharpening

#9

Re: forrest blade sharpening

Robin Corell in Atascadero, CA

>Acme saw on E. Julian. It is near the new Adobe building on Julian and Guadalupe Pkwy. All their machines are CNC, same as what forrest uses. They sharpen for a lot shops in the valley and have been in business for decades. I used to use them when I lived in San Jose, they are the best in the area.

Just for the record I don't own any forrest blades so you may want to make sure thay can do the grind you want on your blade.

Robin

Re: forrest blade sharpening

#10

Re: forrest blade sharpening

Chuck Kettler Greenwood IN

>Perhaps Bill Tindall can recall years ago my whining about burning of boards during ripping using a Forrest blade. I used every adjustment possible, but could not figure out what the problem was so I shipped the blade to Forrest and asked them to do a test rip and fix the blade if it was the problem. Test cut or whatever revealed a bad tooth which they replaced. Nine years later still ripping like it was new.

Re: forrest blade sharpening

#11

w/ coomon sense "baloney" but in reality.....!

HC Sakman

>...I've tried 3 different sharpening services which all claim they can do the same job. They claim they have the same cnc machine etc... Result: 2 ruined blades and the rest never cut the same as with their original grind did.

Logic says what you said should be correct, but my actual personal experience proves otherwise.

These sharpening services are known to sharpen other brands' blades better than their original state. (I personally know as well as other reliable sources' confirmation.) So, what am I supposed to conclude from this dilemna? I know it's not a rocket science...so what's the difference? Why actual resultd match with Forrest's claims and suggestions?

I think Forrest takes the final grind with very fine grit that most sharpeners don't due to its expense (as I was told by one of the sharpener's in a confession moment) and more importantly, at Forrest, they check and do side (of the teeth) grind, tensioning and balancing for minimal run-out, which is as important as sharpness for very smooth cuts. That's where the difference is....I think.

So, after 8~10 blades I think it's not baloney. Forrest does an excellent job with their blades and in my opinion, nothing else cuts like it. I've tried many others.

The lousiest blade I have ever used is the Austrian made "Felder" brand. My sharpener suspects it's actually Chinese made. What I know for a fact is that not only it doesn't cut nice also it does get dull faster than anything else I've ever used.

Chico...

Re: forrest blade sharpening

#12

Ellis Walentine

No mysteries, but...

Ellis Walentine

>... as someone mentioned, if you want the exact same performance from your blade, your sharpener will have to match the radial and tangential taper of the original grind. The Forrest Woodworker II cuts as smoothly as it does because the tangential taper (you could call it side relief) is minuscule compared to other production carbide blades. A properly tuned multi-axis grinder can be programmed to imitate this taper exactly, but it wouldn't hurt to discuss this fine point with your sharpener beforehand, if you want the same output quality you're used to. Most sharpeners don't bother with this level of attention to detail, and some are simply unable or unwilling to do so.

There are also two other variables that matter here. One is the grit of the grinding wheels. Many industrial sharpening shops use grits in the 200 to 320 range; high-quality sharpeners use finer-grit wheels, in the 600-grit range. A finer wheel puts a stronger, sharper edge on the carbide tip, as coarse-grit scratches give the tooth a serrated edge that is more prone to dulling, as the exposed serrations heat up faster and loosen the cobalt binder that holds the carbide grains together.

The other variable I mentioned involves the amount of carbide that is removed in sharpening, and where it is removed from. Industrial sharpeners may grind off more than is necessary in order to remove all chips and imperfections in a single pass. A reputable sharpener will only remove what is necessary, and it will be primarily from the top of the tooth; face grinding changes the tooth geometry and shortens the life of the blade.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: forrest blade sharpening

#13

I'm just sayin.....

Barry Irby

>I'm not trying to suggest the Forrest blade is mystical of magical and that nobody but Forrest understands it or that nobody else can sharpen it or that it is any better than any other blade, but I have one and I like it.

I could find a local shop and they might do as good a job of sharpening it. But there would be some effort in finding that shop and trying to confirm their reputation. Then I would have to drive or send the blade to them and retrieve it. Based on the fact that Forrest made the blade, I have some faith they can sharpen it. The effort involved would not be significantly different. I know where Forrest is and I can mail them the blade.

The guy that ruined my other blades was just some redneck with a saw sharpener, but he came highly recommended.

As far as saying "they have the same CNC machines Forrest uses" is like saying "you have a Oneway lathe, you must really make beautiful turnings.

I dare say that if I took my blade to a local shop and they made it cut worse, they would not happily replace it and they had already demonstrated they could not sharpen it. We would be arguing about how Forrest does it differently and the radial and tangential angles and the side grind..... All of which I know nearly nothing about, but I really don't want to and should not need to to put a good blade on my saw, made by someone who knows that stuff, so I can just cut wood. If I send the blade to Forrest, I could say you made it and you screwed it up and if you don't make me whole, I'm telling everybody I know....on Wood Central.

Re: forrest blade sharpening

#14

Lee Grindinger

Help me remember

Lee Grindinger

>I remember that removal of a certain amount of carbide is necessary because while the carbide may be alright the cobalt binder becomes pitted and without removal of at least .0005? the blade dulls quickly.

I think the best advice for the questioner is to return the blade to Forrest unless he feels qualified to select a sharpener, few of us are.

Lee

Re: forrest blade sharpening

#15

Lee Grindinger

Few of us

Lee Grindinger

>Few of us are actually qualified to determine if a sharpener can deliver the goods as well as the promises. I too have had these experiences, Chico, and opted for the return to Forrest for my sharpening.

Promises from sharpeners are cheap, blades are not.

Lee

Re: forrest blade sharpening

#16

Louie Lovas

Re: forrest blade sharpening *LINK*

Louie Lovas

>I've used Burns Tools, they've always done a great job and I've gotten my blade back promptly. I have a (too) large collection of Freud, CMT and Forrest blades. See link below.


Sharpening at Burns Tools

Re: forrest blade sharpening

#17

And a good thing that was

Henry Higginbotham

>I bought a WWII some years back. Great cut for about ten minutes, then it loaded up and burned its way, slowly, through everything. I cleaned it repeatedly and treated it with various products promising to prevent gumming, all to no avail.

It hung on the wall for two or three years before I decided to send it to Ridge Carbide, asking if they could turn it into something useful. It came back a different blade (as expected). Now it cuts very nearly as smoothly as that first ten minutes, cuts much faster, and never appreciably gums up.

Re: forrest blade sharpening

#18

Well said, Barry

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>

Re: forrest blade sharpening

#19

Avoid?

ScottS

>I had Acme sharpen the $150 carbide-tipped metal-cutting blade I use on my dry cut saw. They assured me they could match the original profile of the teeth on this specialized blade. The price was reasonable ($20?) and turn around was 1-2 days.

Once home, the blade made only 4-5 cuts before appearing to be completely dull again! It was the blade that came with the saw, so it might have been a piece of junk, but needless to say I wasn't impressed with the results. My only guess is that they ground the teeth to the wrong profile and the cutting edge only held up for a couple of cuts. Normally, I'd have followed up with them about the problem, but phone communication was difficult due to their lack of staff and the amount of shop noise.

Based on my experience, I'd be tempted to send a Forrest blade back to Forrest for sharpening rather than asking Acme to do it, but perhaps they're better with woodworking blades?

Re: forrest blade sharpening

#20

Re: forrest blade sharpening - curious here

Carol - now in NC Nebraska

>Why is their resistance to sending it back to Forrest?

Their price is competitive. It comes like new. They will make it right if you're not happy. What's the downside? Mailing it off and waiting for it? Waiting a couple of weeks (I was in California, so that was an issue with the shipper, not Forrest)? It was a 2 week turn around using the 'local' service. They too had the fancy CNC machine. The problem was they had a minimum wager employee do it, who was told, "just put the blade in here and push this button."

Mine go home to Forrest for some loving and come back working like new. Others I send off the Scott Whiting in Arizona.

My 2 �.

Re: forrest blade sharpening

#21

Re: forrest blade sharpening

Eric in Los Gatos

>Thanks all for the input.

My inclination is to send it back to Forrest. I did call the local shop Chris recommended but the guy I talked to didn't know anything and said to call back tomorrow when there will be someone a bit more knowledgeable about what they do and what their capabilities are. We'll see. That being said I really take the comment about my being able to evaluate a sharpening service to heart although Ellis' response gives me some specific questions.

I'll post the results of that call in case anyone is interested.

Eric in Los Gatos

Re: forrest blade sharpening

#22

Re: I love 'em

Brian in Brighton

>I've got nothing but good things to say about them. Of course, I had some bad experiences in the Denver area.

Brian in Brighton

Re: forrest blade sharpening

#23

Re: forrest blade sharpening

Ace Foster in Port Orchard

>When I was in that area, I had several years of good luck with Sharpening Mechanics, over around Union & Foxworthy. When I moved over the hill, I used Santa Cruz Saw & Tool.

Never have sprung for a Forrest blade, tho'. For one of those I might just play safe and go to Forrest.

Ace