Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

What size planer

Posts

What size planer

#1

What size planer

Josh in VA

>Well I was previously set in buying on of the new combination machines, but talked myself out of it. The biggest selling point is space savings, and fortunately space has not become that big of an issue for me.

Currently have a 6" Rigid Jointer and 12 1/2" Dewalt lunch box planer.

So I will be going the separates route. As much as I would like a 12" jointer, they are a little out of the price range. Oliver and Grizzly are the only 10" jointers I can find. (No luck finding anything used locally) I am looking to get an 8" jointer now.

I will also be acquiring a planer. As I have quite a few boards that are 9-20" wide, I plan on making a planer sled to surface them when the time comes.

My question is...Which size planer? Do I go with the 15" or 20". I do have a few boards over 15" wide. 90% of the lumber I use, I purchase from the mill and air dry it myself. I am able to get much wider boards at much cheaper prices.

I am inclined to go with the 15" and but a Byrd shelix head on it, especially since I will be getting just an 8" jointer. However I hate to pass up on the larger capacity planer for my larger boards (to me it is just wrong to rip wide boards and rejoin ).

Which route would you go and why?

Thanks for your input.

Re: What size planer

#2

Re: What size planer

Patrick Schupbach

>I cant imagine needing more than 15. Grizzly w/ Byrd cutterhead looks like a good machine. I own the GO490 jointer which is now available with the Byrd.I think this would make an unbeatable set up.Good luck!!

Re: What size planer

#3

Louie Lovas

Re: What size planer

Louie Lovas

>A year ago, I purchased the Grizzly G1021X 15" planer with a sprial cutter head. It's not the Byrd cutter, but Grizzly own. After a year's use, I am happy to report it was money well spent. The machine is finely crafted and cuts beautifully. I had previously owned a RIDGID 13" benchtop (still do actually, it's sitting in a corner of my shop collecting dust). The main reason I upgraded was to plane wide/hard lumber. While the benchtop varieties can "generally" handle wide lumber (and I'm talking about hard maple and exotics), they struggle a bit because of the rubber infeed/outfeed rollers. It's a lot of ask of a smooth rubber roller to push a dense wood (i.e. 10+ inches wide) through the cutter head without slipping. My RIDGID slipped a lot, even though I was constantly cleaning it with Naptha. The Grizzly I bought has a serrated infeed roller so it easily grips wide boards as it pushes them through. Most if not all, 15" and 20" planers have serrated infeed rollers. The other reason I went with the Grizzly was the infeed and outfeed tables, over 4 feet of cast iron.

Re: What size planer

#4

Re: What size planer

Josh in VA

>Question about Planer sleds...

How many of you guys have used them? and to what success?

Pros, Cons, etc...

I am tempted to forgo the jointer purchase right now and get the 20" planer and build the current planer sled in FWW.

http://www.taunton.com/finewoodworking/SkillsAndTechniques/SkillsAndTechniquesPDF.aspx?id=24118

I have a project (baby crib and changing dresser - first child ) I am waiting to start due to the 8" wide boards I have and no great way of milling them.

I know the sled will be a little slower and more cumbersome, but it may be the best route until I can find the jointer I want/can afford.

The baby is due mid July and I can't wait any longer to get it started.

Thanks again guys for your input...

Josh

Re: What size planer

#5

Re: What size planer

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>My son bought me a Yorkcraft (identical to the Grizzly) 20" planer and the Byrd head to go with it. He bought it for my retirement - he also uses my shop so he does get a little something back :~). I am not sure of the price difference - mine was about $2500 delivered, but I sure am glad it is a 20". I have used it to flatten many panels / tops after glue up. Does a tremendous job in a heartbeat. I realize the 15" would have probably have ran 98% of all my rough wood without a problem, but being able to re-flatten panels has been a godsend. Knowing how much I have used the 20" width, I would not now hesitate to purchase one myself. I also have an 8" Grizzly joiner with the Grizzly version of the Byrd head. In all honesty I can't tell the difference in the quality of finish between the Byrd and the Grizzly heads - if that info is helpful in your decision.