Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Basic jointer question

Posts

Basic jointer question

#1

Basic jointer question

Dan Mitchell

>I posted earlier about getting a used General 80-100L when I had paid for new. The dealer does not have a new 80-100L in stock to replace the used one, but they do have a new 80-150L. Ordering the 80-100L would take 2-3 weeks.

Apparently, the only difference in the 2 is in the way the infeed & outfeed tables adjust. The one I had bought (80-100L) has 2 hand wheels on the front, one for each table ("Independent in-feed and out-feed table adjustment hand wheels"). The other jointer has a handwheel below the outfeed table to adjust it, & a lever below the infeed table to adjust it ("Quick lever table adjustment"). The double wheel system just seems inherently more precise to me, but my experience is limited. Is there any practical reason to prefer on design over the other?

Links to the 2 on General's site:

80-100L

http://www.general.ca/pagemach/machines/80100a.html

80-150L

http://www.general.ca/pagemach/machines/80150a.html

Thanks in advance, I'm sure everyone's getting pretty sick of my endless jointer-jabber. This is a major investment for me & I want to get the best I can.

Dan

Re: Basic jointer question

#2

Re: Basic jointer question

David Yoho

>I've got an eight-inch Delta that has levers instead of wheels. I think the wheels make for a little more precise adjustment of height but surprisingly, the levers work well too. I find I don't adjust my infeed table much. It's set for about 1/16" and that seems to be where it stays most of the time. When I do have an occasion to set it for a deeper cut, it is easily adjusted by using the depth scale.

I don't think the wheel versus lever issue should be a deal breaker because once you have the initial setup done, you really shouldn't need to move it much after that. My experience with the levers on my Delta has been a positive one.

David

Re: Basic jointer question

#3

JL

Re: Basic jointer question

JL

>I have the lever style on my infeed table. I don't really change the position of my infeed table that much. I'm mostly cleaning up rough jointed material and I prefer to make multiple passes anyway.

It's basically a matter of preference. The two jointers are very similar. I think you'd be happy with either unit (if it were new that is :)).

Re: Basic jointer question

#4

Re: Basic jointer question

Patrick Schupbach

>My GO490 has levers. I dont adjust my tables very often. The levers are easy to use.Hope this helps.

Re: Basic jointer question

#5

Re: Basic jointer question

Barry Irby

>Dan, I read (here on WoodCentral I'm almost sure) that the advantage tot he levers is that they adjust quickly and easily, but not quite as precisely as the handwheels. This is great for the infeed table since a few thousandths don't matter much on that side.

The outfeed table needs to be adjusted more precisely. Basically, you set the knives all at the same height and parallel to each other and the table. Then you tweak the table to match the height. This tweaking is easier with the hand wheel. (I'm sure some will say they have no trouble doing the outfeed table with the lever, but I talking in generalities.)

Like many, I leave my jointer set up to take a light cut almost all the time, but when I adjust it, the process can be slow with the handwheels.

I think the one you are looking at might be the best of both worlds. (Be warned, I know nothing of the specific jointer you are looking at.)

Re: Basic jointer question

#6

alternative view

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>I was going to stay out of this discussion but in the interest of diversity, since no one else has defended this view, I will jump in.

I adjust my infeed table a lot and would do so even more if I had a lever mechanism that worked quickly( I have wheels fore and aft). To get on with the task, I take an initial heavy cut on rough cut edges (about 1/16) and a much finer finish cut for glue joints . I do even more adjusting on face flattening. In fact it seems I am diddling with the depth most of the time I use the jointer.

I would pay extra for a rapid infeed adjustment if it worked well- adjustment was smooth and it stayed in place once set.

disclaimer: I have no experience with the machine you are considering.

Re: Basic jointer question

#7

Another alternative view

wilbur

>I leave my jointer for about a 1.5 mm cut. For finer passes, I use a hand plane.

Re: Basic jointer question

#8

Speed vs precision

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>In talking about the gib-style jointers (not parallelogram) I've always thought that the handwheels offer more precision at the cost of speed, and the levers are quick at the cost of precision..... so a jointer that has a handwheel for the outfeed table (which isn't adjusted often but precision is very important) and a lever for the infeed (where changes happen more often but precision isn't as important) is the best combination.

Don't confuse this with the parallelogram style jointers like the Delta DJ series where the geometry allows the levers to be quick but just as precise as a handwheel.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Basic jointer question

#9

A General 80 100L User

Mark McC

>The wheel system seems to feel and imply a more accurate and precise adjustment and this may be so, but I have not had an occasion with my 80 100L where the adjustment needed to be so precise and "dialed in".

Just the way I use the tool, others may differ.

I need parallel and square facing of a rough board and straight square edges for edge jointing...period.

While it has a graduated gauge for the wheel, again implying detailed and precise adjustment, the suggestion of "fine adjusting" is viturally useless IMHO.

Like others I keep the front table set for a light cut 1/32" and only occasionally have needed to take more then 1/32" off.

When I do it's not like I need to dial in precisely 39/64"

As I beleive the two models are identical in every other respect, I think I could live with the front lever.

But 2-3 weeks is nothing in a jointers life, so if mentally your locked into that two wheel system look..wait for it!

Good Luck... ain't sweating over large tool purchase decisions fun!!

Re: Basic jointer question

#10

Re: Basic jointer question

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>I have had both wheel (what I have currently) and lever. I found the differences to be a small issue.

But it seems to me that you're in this situation because Woodcraft sold you a used tool, correct? I know you are anxious for getting a new jointer but after all you have been through already wouldn't you want to hold out for exactly what you wanted in the first place?

Tom

Re: Basic jointer question

#11

Pick one.

Virgil Johnson, Versailles KY

>After you use the machine for a month you will get the hang of either style regardless of the adjustment method. Having said that I like the lever adjustment of my Delta.

Re: Basic jointer question

#12

I guess what matters is how you use your jointer

henthorn

>and what kind of stock you are using. I mainly used rough cut that I milled myself and it came in all kinds of thicknesses. I changed the infeed table frequently even though I had a planer to get really precise. It was just the way I learned to use a joiner. Sure don't claim it is the best way. I still prefer the wheels because that is what I learned on.

Re: Basic jointer question

#13

Re: Basic jointer question

Dan Mitchell

>Thanks for all the informative replies. Sounds like it's mostly a matter of personal preference & what you get used to.

I appreciate everyone's insights, very helpful.

Dan