Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

help widow determine tool values?

Posts

help widow determine tool values?

#1

help widow determine tool values?

MN deepwoods (Dave)

>Hey everyone,

I haven't been around much lately as I'm spending a lot of time on a BB with people who have recently lost their spouse to death. (lost mine in 10/07)

One lady has a collection of mechanic's and wood working tools of her hubby's to get rid of. Any ideas on the best, and most honorable way, she can determine values?

Thanks, Dave

Re: help widow determine tool values?

#2

Re: help widow determine tool values?

Pete in Holland, MI

>On old tools, I've typically gone on the 1/3 the value of new, and on relatively new tools, 1/2 to 2/3 of new. Beyond that, why buy used tools that are almost new without the ability to take them back if they fail?

Was asked to come put a value on a man's metal shop several years ago. The guys I was working with decided it would be in the widow's best interest to find someone to buy the entire shop. Selling it piece-meal, the bigger stuff may go quickly, but all the odd tools & materials may take forever to dispose of.

A relatively large wood turning club I have a friend in had a member who passed away. It was determined with the widow to have a club auction at an up & coming meeting, as most all the wood turners from the area would be in one central spot, rather than have a "garage sale" evant and be stuck with a lot of odd pieces left to dispose of.

There's also always e-bay. Might find a grand kid who would do the project (list & ship) for a percentage of the proceeds.

Re: help widow determine tool values?

#4

Re: help widow determine tool values?

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>My condolences for your loss, Dave. I can't imagine what I would do in that circumstance.

To help answer your question, I acted as the executor of the ham radio equipment of the widder lady of a fellow ham fifteen years ago. Never again do I want to do that. Naturally everyone's situation is different, but in this case, the SK (Silent Key—what we hams call a fellow who has passed to that great ham shack in the sky) had kept a sort of running inventory of his equipment, what he bought it for, and what it was worth (he thought).

Unfortunately, in some cases the SK was a little optimistic about its worth, but worse, the widder lady took it as gospel. When ultimately I was not able to realize the full value of much of the equipment at time of sale, I was put in the awkward position of her perception that I had devalued the stuff for my friends. What she didn't understand was not only the vagaries of marketplace in general, but that I had a very good sense of the equipment market (I was a subscriber to a ham radio publication much like Trade-a-Plane which provided as accurate a picture of the ham radio used equipment as was possible in those pre-ebay days). She didn't overtly claim I cheated her, but that was the feeling I left with at the end.

Moreover, while some of the big ticket items (transceiver, amplifier, power supply) were relatively new, in good condition, and near the SK's documented value, other, particularly smaller, items were either old and tired, obsolete or worn out (coax weathers and loses its effectiveness), or just not widely in demand by the community.

In the end, after doing all the work of removing the antennas and tower, and disposing of same, plus handling multiple transactions of which I netted not a penny, I was left with a virtually unsellable inventory of equipment which was of zero use to the widder lady and little more to me. What to do?

By two months post mortem, all that was going to sell had sold, and with a slightly bad taste in my mouth regarding the aforementioned “discounted” sales, I tried to settle up with her. She told me to keep the small stuff and I promised to pass along the proceeds of any further sales. She did however, question my accounting on the sale of the tower sections, and her opinion was not in concert with my recollection. Again, I left with the feeling that she thought I had cheated her.

Frankly, although I didn't know her from Adam's off ox before my friend died, I had been recommended by a common acquaintance, and I felt we had established a good rapport. I had known her husband and had done some (gratis) tower work for him when he was alive. Whatever relationship may have developed initially when I took on the job was destroyed by the result. I didn't care for that and will never put myself in that position again.

I'm sure there must be some things which I could/should have done to minimize my exposure, but I didn't know then what they might be and I certainly didn't anticipate their necessity. I was operating on a hand shake.

Rod

Re: help widow determine tool values?

#5

Re: help widow determine tool values? - Update

Pete in Holland, MI

>Called my friend who had organized the auction for the widow's tools. Said the auction went pretty well. Most of his stuff was new or pretty new, and went for 70-80% of new. Many folks knew the man who passed, and Frank felt that helped prop up the sales. All stuff was sold, other than a pricy jig saw that no one had interest in, because there were no fret-work guys in the crowd.

I read the note later in this thread where the man with the HAM radio equipment felt like the widow thought he cheated her. Can understand how that could happen.

Word to the wise: When evaluating a price on an item in this sort of situation, have multiple people give their best idea on value of things. If several people draw the same conclusion, it may be more acceptable to the widow.

Re: help widow determine tool values?

#6

Re: Bought back some memories

North of the Border

>More than 10 years, I saw an ad about a garage sale on, among other things, some tools. I called the owner and asked if I could come a couple days before because I wasn't available on the advertised weekend when the sale went on. The owner, a widow, said it was fine. I could say it was the best tool deal ever, not that I paid little for what I got (a router, some hand tools, a level, drill bits, etc.) but that the purchase kick-started by my woodworking interest and hobby and I never looked back. I still have most of the tools I bought from this lady and the most treasured tool? A tape measure which is crudely scribed with its owner's initials on the side: H.W. and today I'm still using it to measure for all my projects. I wonder how other woodworkers found their woodworking passion ....

P.S. May be it isn't too bad a thing that when some woodworker kicks the bucket (we all will do one day) and his or her the other surviving better-half simply gets rid of the 'junk' without really minding too much about the financial side.

Re: help widow determine tool values?

#7

Re: Typo - last post should begin - Brought back

North of the Border

>

Re: help widow determine tool values?

#8

Re: help widow determine tool values?

Dan Mitchell

>I've sold a pretty broad array of things on Ebay, including a Unisaw & Delta jointer, each separately, doing quite well with both. I also sold a Pilates exercise machine on Ebay for my father in law, an item which I knew nothing about prior to listing it. It fetched a very good price & my FIL was well pleased. I've also sold 2 cars on Craig's List. In my opinion, you get a better return on Ebay. Especially for higher-ticket items, my approach is to monitor auctions for similar items for a couple weeks to get an idea of what they will bring, then price mine accordingly, keeping in mind any variations in condition, etc. For heavy items, you can specify "local pickup only", which eliminates the hassle of shipping them.

Dan