Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

O.T.: Bruised shingles question

Posts

O.T.: Bruised shingles question

#1

O.T.: Bruised shingles question

David G. Sparks

>There was a hail storm at my mom's house a few months ago. The insurance man said she had bruised shingles on her roof, and he recommended replacing the front half of the roof ( The wind blew the hail against the front part mainly ). Unfortunately, she had a $1500 deductible, so the insurance money will not come close to covering the work. There are two layers of shingles that will have to be removed. The roof is only five years old. I can't see any damage myself. Have any of you had this problem? If the roof isn't leaking, is there a problem? I want to do whatever is necessary to fix it but only if there's really a problem. Thanks for your help.

Re: O.T.: Bruised shingles question

#2

Re: O.T.: Bruised shingles question

Joseph Mulherin, Sr.

>David, the insurance man was saying that the shingles had some composite granules missing. This does not indicate that the roof will leak, just that it does not look nice. Is also a way to stimulate business.....

Re: O.T.: Bruised shingles question

#3

Re: O.T.: Bruised shingles question

Joseph Mulherin, Sr.

>David, Google this and up will come a site which will fully explain your possibilities and recourse...."bruised roof shingles"....

Re: O.T.: Bruised shingles question

#4

Long term problem

Virgil Johnson, Versailles KY

>When the granules get knocked off this exposes the layer underneath which will degrade faster than normal from UV damage.My house got damaged last year during a hail storm. I'm in no hurry to fix the roof. I do notice a lot of granules on the deck after a rain now.

Re: O.T.: Bruised shingles question

#5

Re: Long term problem

jared

>I have put on a few shingles before. It is common that after a hail storm they wont really show much damage but after a year or two of summer sun the edges will start to curl up and they will look really bad and will start to deteriorate at a fast rate. A few years ago, we had a really severe hail storm. THe shingles were only a year old and didnt really show much but the gutters had a lot of sand in them. I got paid 60% damage and ended up replacing them after 4 more years so I guess if you figure a 20 year life on them the adjustor was about right at the 60% level. THey will not leak immediately and not need to be replaced right away but the life is shortend a lot. Jared

Re: O.T.: Bruised shingles question

#6

Re: O.T.: Bruised shingles question

John K Jordan

>Some years State Farm voluntarily inspected the roofs of all their local clients following a hailstorm. The first I heard of it was when a check arrived in the mail for enough to replace all the shingles. I climbed up and inspected it myself and saw no visible damage other than a few isolated "smudge" marks.

When I called State Farm, they said the damage was not visible but would degrade the roof which may then leak a few years later. Their action was primarily to prevent much larger claims to the interior from future water damage.

JKJ

Re: O.T.: Bruised shingles question

#7

Thanks for all the help!

David G. Sparks

>