Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

What is the perfect pad sander?

Posts

What is the perfect pad sander?

#1

What is the perfect pad sander?

Bill Hammond, Oregon Coast

>I think that this weekend I'll get a new 1/4 sheet pad sander. I know better than to ask which is the best. However, anyone know which makes the least noise and still sands reasonably well, has a dust pickup and falls in to that $50 to $70 range?

When I read the Amazon reviews it seems that the reviewers are not talking about the same tool, or perhaps don't know what they are talking about.

Locally my choices seem to be Bosh, DeWalt, Milwaukee, Porter Cable, Sears Craftsman, and Ridgid, along with the usual low end brands. These from my local Home Depot, only 30 miles away and the in town Ace Hardware.

Hope the person who stole my 1/2 sheet Milwaukee a few years back has hurt himself with it -- often!

Bill, who lives in the middle of nowhere, but at least the sun is shining.

Re: What is the perfect pad sander?

#2

Re: What is the perfect pad sander?

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>Don't know about perfect, but in terms of longevity, you'd have a hard time beating the Makita. I've had my 1/4 sheet pad sander (BO4510) for 25 years. The bearings have been rebuilt twice because of the beating it has taken. I've even used it to wet-sand the epoxy on my cedar strip canoe. It just keeps on keeping on. There may be quieter ones on the market, but there can't be many more reliable.

Bruce, shoveling out in MN - thank goodness for Toro snowblowers.

Re: What is the perfect pad sander?

#3

Re: What is the perfect pad sander?

Chuck in ND

>In this day and age if you can find one thats made in the USA you might do ok with it. I have a Porter-Cable PC303 that I'm very happy with. But who knows where they are made now.

Re: What is the perfect pad sander?

#4

Had a P-C 1/4-sheet sander returned it after 1 day

Howard In Toronto

>Got the Makita.

Much better.

Way less vibration.

The P-C just about killed me on a 20-minute sanding job.

The noise level is okay.

Take a look at the 1/4-sheet sander most pro wwers seem to have on their bench in photos - it's almost 100% the Makita unit.

HTH

Howard

Re: What is the perfect pad sander?

#5

Re: What is the perfect pad sander?

George W. Dart-Havertown PA

>Good Evening Bill.

The smoothest I have ever used is the P+C 330 Speed Bloc Sander. The one which has the grey hair of age and retains the energy of youth is my Makita.

George

Re: What is the perfect pad sander?

#6

Re: What is the perfect pad sander?

Stuart Hough

>I'll back up the Makita sentiment. My son gave mine to me for Christmas about 6 years ago. It's not terribly loud, nor is it terribly quiet, but MAN will it sand! Vibration isn't bad, sandpaper attaches easily, and the switch is well-placed. Real nice gift!

Re: What is the perfect pad sander?

#7

I agree, Makita.

Scott in Montana

>

Re: What is the perfect pad sander?

#8

Re: What is the perfect pad sander?

Bill Spievak

>When I am looking for smooth and quiet I go to my Porter Cable Speed Block, it is nearly 30 years ole, has been to the repair shop twice, for brushes and bearings. I like the way it fits in my hand and since it isn't flat on top I am not tempted to add preasure and create swirl marks.

Re: What is the perfect pad sander?

#9

330 dust pickup?

Bill Hammond, Oregon Coast

>The PC 330 looks like what I want, and it's still available. How does one attach a vac to it?

Re: What is the perfect pad sander?

#10

Re: 330 dust pickup?

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

>There is none, it's old-school. Folks missed your stipulation that it have dust extraction capabilities.