Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

Posts

***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#1

Ellis Walentine

***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

Ellis

>Well, in the better-late-than-never category, here is this month's survey question. I'm interested to know your thoughts on woodworking classes. There are degree programs (e.g., College of the Redwoods), private schools (e.g., Mark Adams), weekend tutorials (e.g., Ellsworth), seminar programs (e.g., Woodcraft and Lee Valley stores) and probably other outlets.

Which, if any, of these types of classes have you availed yourself of?

What do you regard as the pros and cons of the different types of programs? Do you consider them cost-effective for what you learn?

Do you have any recommendations for other channels of woodworking education? What does the future hold?

As usual, we will grind, chop, puree and digest your replies into a column for the next issue of Woodworker West magazine. You can visit previous survey topics in our News & Views department.

Thanks for participating in our survey.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#2

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

John E in SC

>Last year, LOML gave me as a gift a weekend woodworking class at the Dogwood Institute in Atlanta. I consider a moderately exerienced amature, and the Dogwood Institute requires that everyone start at the "Foundations I" class, so I really wasn't expecting much. I was wrong. I learned a ton, and loved it. I finally learned how to sharpen chisels and planes, and tune and use a hand plane correctly. Honestly, it opened up a whole new area of woodworking for me. Now, I find an excuse to use my hand plane on every project, just because it's so much fun to use. I never get tired of making those "see through" shavings. I read a lot of books, and have learned 99% of what I know about woodworking through them (well, including the huge amount I've learned through Woodcentral!), but particularly for some of the "finer" aspects of WWing, there's nothing like some hands-experience and instruction from someone who knows what they're doing. I would recommend something like that for anyone.

John

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#3

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

>Hi Ellis.

I've never attended any of the subject courses. I've only attended one-on-one from Jeff Jewitt in his shop and the (to me) educational evening I spent with you. So I can't provide you anything... but...

"What does the future hold?"

My first thought/reaction to that question is web resources. Web video, shows, tutorials, and so on.

Joe

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#4

class content must meet expectations

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>People taking a class typically will have an expectation and the class will be successful if the expectation is met. Disappointment prevails when the class content was not adequately described in its advertisement or the content not adequately understood by the student.

Recalling classes I have taken or considered, they fall in two categories, classes with the objective of making something and classes where the objective is to teach a skill with or without hands on learning. I have taking several of the latter category and they have moved me up the woodworking learning curve faster than I could have moved myself. I considered all but one of them very good value. This latter category is probably harder to teach and students need to be more diligent to be sure the class is going to teach skills that they are interested in.

The class that was not good value (in fact it was worthless) was so because it was inflexible and the instructor dwelled on topics that were of no interest to the class. The instructor refused to make on the spot modifications to the syllabus to accommodate student interests. To provide a positive example, I took a class on general wood turning. The class included a section on bowls and I had (and have) no interest in bowls. I asked to skip that part and focus on spindles. The instructor (Nick Cook) accommodated this request without hesitation and I thought the class a great success. So long as the request can be accommodated without being disruptive to the overall class an instructor should try to meet individual or group needs that the instructor may not have originally intended to cover. In fact, recalling classes I have taken, the best and most useful parts were when a specific request was met. The ability to deal successfully with these unanticipated requests for information distinguish the best teachers, and the best classes.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#5

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

John E in SC

>Last year, LOML gave me as a gift a weekend woodworking class at the Dogwood Institute in Atlanta. I consider a moderately exerienced amature, and the Dogwood Institute requires that everyone start at the "Foundations I" class, so I really wasn't expecting much. I was wrong. I learned a ton, and loved it. I finally learned how to sharpen chisels and planes, and tune and use a hand plane correctly. Honestly, it opened up a whole new area of woodworking for me. Now, I find an excuse to use my hand plane on every project, just because it's so much fun to use. I never get tired of making those "see through" shavings. I read a lot of books, and have learned 99% of what I know about woodworking through them (well, including the huge amount I've learned through Woodcentral!), but particularly for some of the "finer" aspects of WWing, there's nothing like some hands-experience and instruction from someone who knows what they're doing. I would recommend something like that for anyone.

John

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#6

Ignore this one - don't know why it double posted

John E in SC

>

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#7

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

Hank Knight

>I have been an amateur woodworker for over 50 years. Until two years ago, everything I learned I learned from reading and by trial and error from doing it myself. I've never had the opportunity to work with anyone else, so I've never had been exposed to others' methods or style of work. Moreover, I have a serious day job, so my shop time has always been pretty limited. Nevertheless, I consider myself a moderately advanced amateur.

Two years ago LOML gave me a 1 week workshop at the Center for Funriture Craftsmanship in Maine - "The Art of Drawer Making" taught be Craig Vandall Stevens. We built a vacation around the workshop. I didn't know what to expect, so I was open to the experience. I enjoyed it thoroughly for the following reasons:

First, it was the first time I've ever worked with other people who were interested in woodworking. I thoroughly enjoyed it, and I came away feeling better about my own level of competence. Second, I learned some great techniques that have improved my work. Third, I got to spend some long, quality time in the workshop - a very rare opportunity for me. Fourth, and probably most importantly, I really enjoyed Craig Stevens. He is a meticulous craftsman and his insistence on perfection made me rethink my own work philosophy. I've become a better craftsman for it.

Last Summer we returned to Maine for another week-long workshop at CFC. This one was "Precision With Hand Tools" taught by Garrett Hack. My experience was a repeat of the year before: great woodworking company, lots of shop time, learned a lot and enjoyed Hack tremendously. I'll probably go back for more.

I agree with Bill Tindall, I think the key is picking a program that is appropriate for your level of exeprtise and tailoring realistic expectations for the program. Both of the workshops I took were aimed at moderate to advanced woodworkers. There were some students in both classes who were overmatched by the level of competency required. I think they were frustrated and didn't enjoy the workshop. By the same token, there were some who were undermatched by the requirements and they were a little bored. Both of my workshops were fairly small - 10 to 12 students. This allowed both instructors the flexibility to work with each student at his/her own level. Both programs hit me just right, and I enjoyed them both. I think it helped that I didn't go in with a firm set of expectations. Instead, I was open to both programs and I came away very satisfid. For me the CFC workshops are highlights of woodworking experience.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#8

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH*** (long)

Don in Northern Arizona

>Ellis,

I have had two experiences with private schools. When I first retired a year and a half ago, I decided I wanted to learn to do spindle turning, and attended a week long class at Conover Workshops. The first two days were an intro to turning and then there were five days of spindle work. There were 3 instructors with 3 different teaching styles to accommodate different learning styles. A variety of assignments were given, but you could also focus on a particular skill, if you wanted to and help was available from the roving instructors. It was a great class that I discussed in Shop Shots 805. The biggest problem for me was that it was 2000 miles away. I was one of the few students not from Ohio, and the only one who did not drive to the school. The travel expenditures exceeded the cost of the class. I had to bring one of my projects home incomplete so I could fit it in my suitcase and get it on the plane.

I recently accompanied my wife on a business trip to Portland, OR. I consulted the Wood Central archives and found a message from Mike Wenzloff that listed some great woodworking related sites in the city. I found out that Gary Rogowski's Northwest Woodworking Studio was offering a one night woodworking design class on the first night we were there. I signed up and enjoyed the class a lot. I got to sit in a Curtis Buchanan Windsor chair and a Brian Boggs ladder-back arm chair (possibly the most comfortable wooden chair on earth) and realized that I could learn how to make both of these chairs in Portland as both Brian and Curtis teach there. Portland has got to be close to woodworker heaven, but it is 1300 miles away. If I have to fly to get to a program, it becomes too expensive, and I have trouble bringing projects like chairs home with me.

I would love to find a short duration program (up to a week) that is not more than a day's drive from me with a Motel 6 and a Subway next door, or better yet a college program that is local. I am really not interested in a degree program (two degrees were enough), but if I can audit or take classes pass/fail then I am cool with it. I think when the Boomers retire there will be many others like me with similar interests. Currently our local community college only has carpentry classes for young folks starting out in the construction trades. The community college in the county to the south of us has a GREAT cabinet making and turning curriculum, but the 190 mile round trip commute 3 times a week puts it out of reach for me. It is actually cheaper to fly to Ohio or Oregon or even Toronto for a week and stay in a pricey motel and eat at high end restaurants with gas prices as they are.

As to seminar programs, the closest Woodcraft is a 340 mile round trip and hasn't really had classes that inspired me to make the trip yet. I would love to get down to the Woodcraft in Tucson and catch a class from Wally Dickerman, but I haven't achieved that yet. It is a 500 mile RT.

I don't mean to make this sound like woe is me. I will continue to learn from this forum, videos, books, and articles, but I prefer to take classes and will do so whenever the opportunity presents itself. So, long story short, I prefer hands-on classes with excellent instructors, and based on my limited experience, I think they are definitely worth the price, but living where I do, travel is the sticking point.

Don

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#9

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

Roger Lance in GR, Michigan

>Ellis...as you mentioned, the local Woodcraft offers various classes...but, like most woodworkers, the actual working of the wood is not a particular problem for me but finishing is a problem...I would love to take a day or two class in finishing...for example, a class in finishing QSWO...and perhaps at another time, a class in shaker finishes on cherry...but I am unable to find such training...I know there are schools that offer long classes (a week or so) on multiple finishing techniques but those schools are very expensive in themselves and also require additional high costs in travel, lodging, food, etc....but the multitude of finishing techniques that are illustrated in these schools will certaining not be used by the average woodworker that is building in a particular style. Local one day finishing training in a particular style would be excellent.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#10

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

Mac in Indy

>I am a big proponent of taking classes to accelerate the learning curve. I have taken some intermediate/advanced classes and taught some beginner/intermediate classes. In every case even when teaching I came away a better woodworker.

Because of my day job I have difficulty dealing with week long classes. I took and taught weekend and long weekend classes. I believe the students liked this because, like me, they did not want to burn a lot of days off or just couldn't take a whole week away from the job. I think more schools should look at these 2/3/4 day weekend classes.

Student skill level is a hard thing for the student or school to asess if the student has never been to the school before. There will always be the overachiever in class as well as the skill challenged individual. Often I would have the overachiever help the underachiever as I rarely had an assistent. It has worked out well and it gives the overachiever something extra to do and keeps him from getting bored and it helps the underachiever "Keep up".

All I have ever taken/taught are project oriented classes that taught skills along the way. I really liked having something finished at the end of the class. I'm not sure I'd like a skills class where you did not have something in hand at the end of class, I need something tangible.

It looks like I'll not be teaching as much this year so I am looking for a couple of classes to take to broaden my horizions. I'm thinking a good chair class will be one of them!

Mac

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#11

Re: Crap! I just finished ignoring the other one!

Al Stokka - Cambridge, Iowa

>

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#12

JL

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

JL

>I have availed myself of classes at:

Highland Hardware - Good instruction though the parking (and the traffic) leave a lot to be desired. They have week-long classes, seminars, weekend classes and night classes. They have both project and technique classes.

John C. Campbell Folk School - Week-long classes, weekend classes - mostly project oriented with some technique classes. Instruction is good and the food is great.

Arrowmont - similar to the Folk School, but usually week-long classes.

If you are into projects, the week-long classes and weekend classes work well. If you want to do a lot of technique classes, they may not fit the bill.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#13

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

Don Orr

>Well, let�s see, back to where it all began. First formal woodworking classes were in Jr. High school, but that�s probably too far back for this thread.

I joined our local woodworking club, thanks to urging from my wife, at their local show several years ago. At the time they offered monthly classes on various topics such as scroll sawing, picture framing, and the like. We went to many of them and enjoyed them a lot, but no hands on. I took a pen turning class which was hands on and got hooked. Joined the local turning club which offered the occasional �Learn-&-Turn� workshop where I learned a lot. Also got to see several well-known turners demo. I go to the local woodworking show every year and attend the lectures and demos. About 6 years ago I took a beginning furniture class through a local community college which was held at a local Art Center. We didn�t build any furniture or use any power tools, but I learned a lot and got interested in hand tools. Last year my wife and I took a beginning woodworking class at the Connecticut Valley School of Woodworking and had a great time. Our local club now has a rented workshop with lots of tools and equipment and offers lots of different classes. I just finished a course on building a small Shaker style end table mostly with hand tools. I have even taught bowl turning there. We had a Woodcraft store in the area, but I never got to take any classes there before they went out of business.

Overall, I have been to many classes and workshops, but only a few in formal school settings. I would most likely take more classes in schools if there were any close by.

Hope this helps your survey.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#14

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

Frank Carpenter

>I have taken several 1-2 day classes at woodcraft which ranged from ok to great. The particularly outstanding classes were carving classes with George Slack at the Springfield, VA Woodcraft. George is a very fine carver and instructor.

I took the Woodworking Essentials class from Lonnie Bird. This class was beyond outstanding. I learned more in that 1 week than in several years of casual woodworking. There is a reason Lonnie's classes sell out so quickly every year.

Future Gloat. I am attending a Lonnie Bird class in May. Yipee!

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#15

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

North of the Border

>Here in Canada, Lee Valley seminars are the way to go, for some good reasons:

1) All proceeds from the seminars go to charities.

2) Most seminars are intended for beginners as well as amateur woodworkers. They are very affordable (that perhaps is the main complaint of other seminar providers) ranging from $20 (2 or 3 hour workshops) to $80 (8 - 10 hour workshops). Each class is about 6 - 8 in size. The combination of prices and level of workshops means these seminars achieve another important (intended or unintended) goal in addition to transmitting knowledge and skills: promoting the woodworking craft and hobby to the mass.

3) Many workshop instructors are self-taught but they're very knowledgeable and skilled in workshops they lead. In many cases, without formal training themselves, they understand better where workshop participants come from and how best these people can learn a new skill.

Of course, for advanced woodworkers (and who can afford the time and money), dedicated woodworking schools run by professional and seasoned funirture makers and woodworkers are the natural choice.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#16

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

Johanna

>I have been taking classes in fine woodworking for the past 8 years at Santa Fe Community College. Several of the instructors there came from College of the Redwoods, others are well-known woodworkers. They offer a structured program that begins with milling a board 4-square and ends with some terrific design classes. Once you have taken the basic series, you are free to take advanced classes as you please.

I have also taken classes at The Cutting Edge in Houston and at Woodcraft in Albuquerque. Some of the classes offered at The Cutting Edge were very useful. I have yet to get much out of the ones at Woodcraft.

The classes at Santa Fe Community College have been the best money I've ever invested -- and a very small amount of money that is. In fact, once you reach 65, tuition is $5 per credit hour! Although I have not taken any classes this year due to a heavy work schedule, I will be going back.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#17

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

Ellen

>During the regular school year I take classes at Cerritos College in Cerritos, CA. This is a community college with a program in Woodworking Manufacturing Technology which offers courses in furniture making, turning, and cabinet making. The facilities are first rate and I doubt that any other woodworking program has the number and variety of tools in a very large facility. The instructional staff is excellent and most have real world commercial experience in their fields. Since this is a Calif Community College, the fees are very reasonable, especially for those of us who are older, retired, and hobbiests. It is well worth the enrollment fees to get the level of instruction and the access to the equipment at Cerritos. Although most of us are making things for ourselves, several of our students have won prestigious national awards. I would highly recommend this program to anyone at any level who wanted to learn woodworking techniques. Additional information can be found at www.cerritos.edu/wood.

In the Summers I take courses at the Center for Furniture Craftsmanship in Rockport Maine. The Summer workshops that I have taken are one or two weeks long. Instructors are reknowned experts, many of whom are published in national woodworking magazines such as Fine Woodworking. While the cost of instruction is higher than in a Community College, the atmosphere is also different. Workshop enrollments are carefully controlled to allow for close interaction between students and the lead instructors. For example, workbench classes are limited to 12 people with at least one full instructor (sometimes two) and one assistant. Access to the well equiped and managed facilities is available to students 7 days a week and most of us work late into the night on our projects. Midcoast Maine is a beautiful place to spend a couple of weeks and this is a great learning/vacation experience. More information on the Center For Furniture Craftsmanship can be found at www.woodschool.org.

Both of these schools are excellent and both provide excellent instruction in very supportive environments. They are both recommended for beginners and experts alike.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#18

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

Paul

>During the regular school year I take classes at Cerritos College in Cerritos, CA. This is a community college with a program in Woodworking Manufacturing Technology which offers courses in furniture making, turning, and cabinet making. The facilities are first rate and I doubt that any other woodworking program has the number and variety of tools in a very large facility. The instructional staff is excellent and most have real world commercial experience in their fields. Since this is a California Community College, the fees are very reasonable. they cannot be beat.

It is well worth the enrollment fees to get the level of instruction and the access to the equipment at Cerritos College; with its 27,00 sq, ft. facility and OSHA compliant spray booth. Unless you have a mentor willing to teach you the craft (for free) the community college system is the best buy in town. Having said that it does take a commitment of time. I have always been a proponent of public education (I know that is a statement which is not heard all that often these days). I supplement my training in woodworking one week classes at for profit schools; this is a very good alternative for people looking for short term intensives. There are a number of wonderful schools throughout the country; The Breed School; Ben Hobbs School; The Windsor Institute William NG School; Woodcraft Supply; Rockler Supply; Don Weber; Patrick Edwards; and on and on.

We are very lucky to have such a vast variety of offerings available to us and the internet allows us to find out what is out there. There are number of really good organization, association, and clubs out there as well; my focus is Period Furniture so I belong to the Society of American Period Furniture Makers or SAPFM; www.SAPFM.org which is another source for mentoring and for educational events. Let us not forget the various woodworking shows traveling the country and offering free demonstrations as well as for fee seminars. For anyone within 50 miles of Cerritos California I highly recommend Cerritos College www.cerritos.edu/wood. For those folks a bit further south toward San Diego I recommend Palomar College; great program as well.