Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

***Two New Video Reviews*** *LINK*

Posts

***Two New Video Reviews*** *LINK*

#1

Ellis Walentine

***Two New Video Reviews*** *LINK*

Ellis Walentine

>...one by Rob Cosman on Drawermaking and the other by Hendrik Varju on Jointer and Planer Secrets. Thanks to Barb Siddiqui for her good work.

Check 'em out.


WoodCentral Video Department

Re: ***Two New Video Reviews*** *LINK*

#2

If I may say...

Bri in Mtl

>The video "reviews" are not really reviews at all. They just simply describe what is on the videos.

I highly respect Barb and value her opinion. personally I'd be more interested in what Barb's actual opinions are of the videos she screens.

Re: ***Two New Video Reviews*** *LINK*

#3

Forgot..

Bri in Mtl

>I should of added something like her giving the videos ratings of 1 to 5 stars or something similar.

Re: ***Two New Video Reviews*** *LINK*

#4

Barb Siddiqui

Re: If I may say...

Barb Siddiqui

>Hello Brian-

Thanks for your comments, but when Ellis and I discussed doing book reviews years ago, we set some guidelines, and I hope they work for most viewers here, if not all. My intention is to review, not critique. That means trying to get across what is in a book or DVD, and what may be left out, so buyers can judge whether a title is what they thought it might be, or is of use to them at their skill level.

The problem I see with assigning 'stars rankings' is that it is only one person's opinion, and would obviously express that critic's bias in terms of preferences for what is good and what is unworthy. What I might find of no use to me, in the way I work wood, may be of high value to another. This is why I've tried to avoid actually ranking what I review. I've only done that a couple of times; over on Amazon.com you'll find a review of Bill Hylton's 'Chests of Drawers' from Taunton Press. I wrote it because with 'star rankings' some idiotic critic didn't like it in comparison to Taunton's 'Treasure Chests,' and said the book was worthless. It riled me so much I had to jump in and swing the other way, telling what a superior book it is. I felt Hylton was completely misrepresented and slandered in that case.

So what I'd hope for here is message board discussion by those who have seen these videos or read the books, giving their own opinions as to their value. Certainly, if you have questions or want opinions, the message boards are the place to ask.

I hope that explains my intentions in writing these reviews.

-Barb Siddiqui

Re: ***Two New Video Reviews*** *LINK*

#5

Ellis Walentine

To the point and useful

Ellis Walentine

>That's all we need, Barb. You can't go beyond your expertise with judgements in yur reviews. But you are a proven expert on documenting content, delivery and applicability. These are the three biggest questions readers have.

Keep up the good work.

Ellis

Re: ***Two New Video Reviews*** *LINK*

#6

Re: If I may say...

Bri in Mtl

>"My intention is to review, not critique." Webster defines the word review as "a critical evaluation (as of a book or play)".

I guess we simply have different interpretations of the word.

This isn't really all that big of a deal, I just felt it necessary to point this out.

Re: ***Two New Video Reviews*** *LINK*

#7

TV list of current library

The MountainMan

>Hey Ellis

I just rejoined the TV site - everything went without problems.. I can not figure out how to get a list of the videos - or even a TV schedule... I assume you are going with a streaming format so members can see what they want to see-?? All I can get is lots of Maloof's.

Regards

The MountainMan

Re: ***Two New Video Reviews*** *LINK*

#8

Re: TV list of current library

Stuart Johnson

>Take a look just above the video window. There are a bunch of little tabs. When you select one it will show the list of video in that section. Whatever is playing will keep on playing until you press play on a different one.

Re: ***Two New Video Reviews*** *LINK*

#9

Suggestion

wilbur

>Maybe the articles should be called "Video Summaries", "Video Recap", "Video Capsules", or something like that.

I agree that the term "review" indicates that there would be some sort of critique.