Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Table top glue up wisdom sought

Posts

Table top glue up wisdom sought

#1

Table top glue up wisdom sought

Pete in Holland, MI

>Guys -

Building a couple end tables & a coffee table in the Mission style out of quarter sawn red oak. I have several planks that are currently at 8% moisture content. The planks are 6-8" wide.

In your experience, should these planks be ripped narrower, then re-glued together, flipping every other boards over, or will the quartersawn stay pretty flat if I leave them in their current widths? Table tops will be about 22" wide when done. I am planning on cleats to hold the top to the table frame & allow for expansion.

My thoughts are that the quartersaw will be the most stable cut from a board, and that I should be all right.

Your thoughts ?

Re: Table top glue up wisdom sought

#2

Re: Table top glue up wisdom sought

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Morning Pete,

If your wood is down to 8% and has otherwise stabilized I would not rip it to more narrow boards, I doubt cupping will be much of a factor, if at all, especially at that low moisture content in 1/4 sawn stock. I would lay our the boards for the most pleasant grain and color pattern primarily,

George

Re: Table top glue up wisdom sought

#3

Re: Table top glue up wisdom sought

Clay Foster

>I would do as the Colonel suggest. Spend some time arranging and rearranging what you have to get the nicest match of the grain patterns. You'll end up with a flat table top and a beautiful piece of furniture.

Re: Table top glue up wisdom sought

#4

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Table top glue up wisdom sought

Jesper, Denmark

>I am with the other two as well - anything that small and with quartesawn stock you are OK.

Re: Table top glue up wisdom sought

#5

Lee Grindinger

Don't rip them but watch your grain

Lee Grindinger

>Don't rip the boards but do pay attention to the orientation of the grain on the edges if you're staining the piece. Chatoyance can affect oak very heavily and reversing the orientation of the edge grain in your glue-ups can make the boards look like a poor match because one will look much brighter than the next, a look that reverses when you observe the table from the other side.

Lee

Re: Table top glue up wisdom sought

#6

Re: Table top glue up wisdom sought

Roger Lance in GR, Michigan

>Pete...there should be no need to further rip your stock...and since they are QS, no need to flip everyother one...but use an odd number of boards for the top (3 or 5) for visual appeal...I'm assuming that the cleats are part of the carcase and that you will be elongating holes for screws for expansion - should work. Take some digital pictures of this project, I know of a guild that would like to see them.

Re: Table top glue up wisdom sought

#7

Louie Lovas

Re: Table top glue up wisdom sought *LINK*

Louie Lovas

>I enjoy building tabletops with wide boards (8" - 12"). I've only had to rip one down once due to heavy cupping. Once it was glued back together, the glue line was invisible.

I've always used cleats with tabletops made of wide boards. I've always erred on the side of caution, providing plenty of "cleat" support to keep the tops flat.

I've also tried to ensure I've planed equal amounts off both sides and let the lumber acclimate for at least 2 weeks before planing to final thickness.

I've also used the sun-and-lawn technique to remove small amounts of cupping. Lay a cupped board on your lawn on a sunny day, concave side down. The warm sun and tighten the convex (top) side, while the moisture in the grass relieves the concave side. It only takes a few minutes to notice the movement. Once it's flattened enough, it back in the shop weighted down, or if it's a finished top, attach the cleats right away. You can only do this in the summertime, obviously :)


Flinthill Furniture

Re: Table top glue up wisdom sought

#8

Thanx Guys !

Pete in Holland, MI

>Tis good to have access to other woodworkers & share their wood working experiences.......good AND bad.

Pete

Re: Table top glue up wisdom sought

#9

another possbility....

Roger Lance in GR, Michigan

>to help ensure flatness would be to apply a finish to the underside of your tops...obviously you don't have to be very fussy here but if the top is combined with a drawer that will hold cloth, you probably should avoid oil-based finish on the bottom of your tops to limit smell issues.

Re: Table top glue up wisdom sought

#10

a fact commonly overlooked, example

Bill Tindall, E.TN

>When fretting about a table top cupping over time consider how much force it would/will take to flatten the top or hold it flat. It turns out this force is very small, and easily accomplished by any commonly used top fastening approach. Hence, one can assemble the top to look best without worry about it staying flat. It will be easily held flat by the fastening devices.

The top in the table shown was assembled from one plank that was cut in half and reassembled by gluing the two plank pieces side by side. The effect was pleasing and I was highly motivated to orient the planks as shown. However, the end of the plank was severely bowed up, about an inch or more. Never-the less, I was able to pull the top flat against the frame, even in this light weight frame, with table top fasteners. This out- of- flatness was way worse than one would ever encounter from a top wanting to bow a bit from moisture change, yet the top became flat and has stayed so for some years.

I have all sorts of furniture tops assembled from boards as wide as 20" and all remain held flat on a frame.

Bottom line, assemble to look best and don't fret flatness.


img