Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

OT - Hard drive crash?

Posts

OT - Hard drive crash?

#1

OT - Hard drive crash?

Pat Evans

>Recently my old laptop failed to launch Windows on bootup. Some error message about a missing or corrupt file. I tried to run the repair facility from the installation disk that came with the laptop, but to no avail. I could get to a DOS prompt, and I ran CHKDSK which showed no errors. The repair shop I took the laptop to called and said I needed a new hard drive. I didn't know enough to argue with them, and it wasn't too terribly expensive, so I had them install a new one. I wonder though, if CHKDSK would run and show no errors, could the hard drive really be bad?

Re: OT - Hard drive crash?

#2

Re: OT - Hard drive crash?

Chuck W

>Maybe a simple reloading of the OS would be enough to get the laptop going again. Does the laptop work now?

Re: OT - Hard drive crash?

#3

Re: OT - Hard drive crash?

Tom

>We have a shop around here that loves to diagnose a failed hard drive. A new hard drive with a fresh install of Windows will correct one hardware problem and all software problems. It's usually the latter though. They've incorrectly diagnosed that twice in one month for friends of mine.

A missing/corrupt system file could have been human error, a virus or something else. You may not even have had to do a fresh install. A simple repair of Windows may have fixed it.

Did you get the old hard drive back? Hook it up to a computer and format it. You'll find out if it's bad right away. A cable adapter set is probably less than $10.

Re: OT - Hard drive crash?

#4

Run the MFG test on it

Dustmaker Mike

>most HD mfg's have some sort of free (yes Free) drive test. The ones I use for Hiticha (IBM) and Seagate will fix a bad sector so the OS will not write to it anymore, and try to get the old information off of the sector if it can. If this test says the drive is bad it is bad. Some mfg's have a three year warrenty on there drives also.

I would try this test before reformatting or any other reload to to make sure the drive is good. Run the quick test it is enough to let you know if the drive is good or bad.

Re: OT - Hard drive crash?

#5

Re: OT - Hard drive crash?

John McGaw

>My experience with laptop drives is that failures tend to be more drastic than a single file failure. They are rather fragile devices given the use to which they are put and the conditions under which they operate. You didn't by chance note what the file was that the system was complaining about and at what stage of the boot it was noted, did you?

The file in question might very well not have been an operating system file and thus would not have been restored/replaced by your system restore disk. Many pieces of user-installed software inject themselves into the system startup chain and if one of those fails the process breaks down. This can even happen with a corrupted or missing data file that some process wants to use if suitable care isn't taken by the programmer.

Re: OT - Hard drive crash?

#6

Re: OT - Hard drive crash?

Rob Hix - King George, VA

>Pat,

Sounds like a drive that is still usable. You might want to try SpinRite from GRC. (www.grc.com). I am not a user, and I have no interest in the program, but I have friends that say this program is the stuff for fixing hard drive problems.

I know it is not free, but many system admin friends of mine says it is worth much more than the price you pay for it. Get a copy, chuck the drive in another machine, and run it. It may take a while, but it will probably fix it (if it is fixable).

Hope this helps,

Rob