Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

new SCMS or old radial arm?

Posts

new SCMS or old radial arm?

#1

new SCMS or old radial arm?

Mitchell from Canada

>I have a 35th anniversary Sears radial arm saw that we bought new long ago. It needs a tune up for accuracy and was used a fair bit for about one year so it's in almost new shape.

Thing is I keep seeing the new SCMS and wonder if I'd be better off using one of those for crosscutting/ chop cuts instead of the radial saw? Far as I can tell, they would take up almost the same amount of space once I mount a SCMS on a bench.

Thanks.

Mitchell

Re: new SCMS or old radial arm?

#2

Re: new SCMS or old radial arm?

George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA

>Good Morning Mitchell,

If you are satisfied with the performance and accuracy of your present radial arm saw, why change? OTOH, the radial saw is known for easing out of adjustment regularly. I had a Sears RAS and couldn't keep it in tune. I blessed the day I sold it and bought a SCMS. The SCMS has maintained its accuracy, takes up less space in my shop, and is used daily. It won't do dados, though. It is really your question to answer. If you are satisfied already, why spend more money?

George

Re: new SCMS or old radial arm?

#3

Re: new SCMS or old radial arm?

Barry Irby

>I have an old Sears Radial Arm Saw and I like it.

The subject or the RAS is controversial. Its the tool many love to hate. Its treated with such disdain that many will curse them and few will reluctantly admit to liking them.

My saw has a cast arm with ground in groves the rollers run in. Its sturdy. I have seen many that were built later that have a rod tack welded on the arm that the wheels run on and they appear to be flimsy. So, perhaps the reason I like mine and it lives up to my expectations is that I have a pretty good one and maybe the people that hate them only dealt with one of the crappy ones.

I have never had or even used a SCMS or any of the derivatives. I do have an old shop saw. The SCMS models I looked at appear to be flimsier than my RAS and more likely to get out of adjustment. And they appeared to have a large footprint. Based on no experience and appearances only, I would not trade my RAS for a SCMS. (And I have not) I also believe the RAS will do some things The other saw will not, such as rabbeting.

Re: new SCMS or old radial arm?

#4

Louie Lovas

Re: new SCMS or old radial arm? *LINK*

Louie Lovas

>I've had a SCMS for about 8 years, the Bosch to be specific. It's a great saw, more accurate and safer (in my humble opinion anyway) than a radial. You cut on the push stroke, not the climbing (pull) cut of radials. I have recommended SCMS's to many friends (now they all have newer models than me).


Flinthill Furniture

Re: new SCMS or old radial arm?

#5

Re: new SCMS or old radial arm?

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>I replaced my Sears RAS with a Delta about five years ago, even though I also have a SCMS. For me, the main advantage of the RAS is that it will cut wider stock and plough dadoes and lap joints. The SCMS gets used more, but I wouldn't get rid of the RAS.

Your situation looks to be a no-brainer; if you have the room, keep the RAS and get a SCMS. The Makita 10" is a great machine: accurate and portable. The Hitachi 12" with laser is is meaner but not as portable.

Clint

Re: new SCMS or old radial arm?

#6

Re: new SCMS or old radial arm?

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>Climbing cuts on the RAS are usually not a problem once you know what it wants to do. For heavy or hard stock that's not too wide you can set up for a push cut for total control.

I find on my 10" Makita SCMS that pushing the blade through the stock tends to bind and burn at the trailing edge because it tries to push the wood into the gap for the blade. This is easily overcome by doing a push cut about 3/4's of the way vertically for the full width of the board and finishing with a climbing cut.

Clint

Re: new SCMS or old radial arm?

#7

Re: new SCMS or old radial arm?

McKay Sleight

>I had an "Original" brand RAS and blessed the day it went bye bye. The reason? I teach high school shop and every time that saw started, my heart would go up into my throat. I replaced it with a upcut saw that has air logic safety. I never have to worry about some kid pulling that blade into a cut and having it climb in over a mis-placed hand. The air logic is such that should their hand be in the wrong place, the saw blade is immediately disabled and the air system must be re-set. As for cutting rabbets, molding, or ripping on a RAS, I would never take the chance. Too many better and safer ways to do the cut.

Re: new SCMS or old radial arm?

#8

Re: new SCMS or old radial arm?

John Foster

>I have used a RAS both at home and at work, and have never understood the safety concerns. If the RAS binds, catches, has a dull blade etc. it will try to climb up on the stock being cut, and almost instantly stop and throw the overload. I never use the SCMS without worrying where my left hand is, at anytime during the cut there is nothing stopping it from deciding to climb up and come back at you. A co-worker's dad, and a good customer are short a few fingers due to the SCMS. I will admit that some of the exotic RAS setups look a bit scary.