Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Cutting granite - question (link)

Posts

Cutting granite - question (link)

#1

Cutting granite - question (link)

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>I was at Home Depot this evening and something caught my eye.

They sell prefinished 8' granite counter tops for $399. I've been thinking about replacing the counter in the kid's bathroom and this might be perfect. They have a flyer which states that it's easy to cut, no special tools required. I find that really hard to believe.

Does anyone know how easy it is to cut granite countertops to put a sink in? I'm not lookig to put in this under-the-surface type sinks, where the hole will be visable and must be critical, but I'm thinking of putting a couple of sinks as shown in the link Kohler Sink, so the cutouts can be fairly rough.

I'm thinking of one of those carbie or diamond router-type bits in a drywall cutout (overpowered RotoZip/Dremel tool).

Anyone know if this is doable?

I guess I'll be hitting google and the library for books on DIY grantite counters. Perhaps this is just another dream in the never ending list of things that need to be replacing in the house.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Cutting granite - question (link)

#2

Re: Cutting granite - question (link)

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>I just finished a job involving 12" marble tile of standard thickness, using a heavy duty stationary wet saw with a diamond blade to do the cutting. It was noticeably more resistant than dard bodied ceramic tile. Granite must be harder yet. For the your project, I would suggest an angle grinder with a diamond blade and plenty of water.

Clint

Re: Cutting granite - question (link)

#3

Re: Cutting granite - question (link)

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Cutting it dimensionally is no harder than porcelin ceramic tile; all you need is a big enough wet saw and a diamond blade (forget the carbide). But when it comes to interior forms, like your sink cutouts, you're going for a pin router overhead type machine with water, as far as I've seen anyway. You can rent a wet saw (they charge you by the micron of wear on the blade), but I've never seen the overhead machines for rent.

Go to a stone place and give'em your template with your cutout(s), It'll be way cheaper in the end.

mm

Re: Cutting granite - question (link)

#4

Re: Cutting granite - question (link) *LINK*

Joe Pack

>The three major minerals in granite are quartz, feldspar (the type of which normally gives granite its color) and mica (minor amounts). On the Mohs scale of hardness quartz is a 7, feldspar about 6 and mica. All of these can easily be cut with a diamond coated blade (diamond has a hardness of 10). You need a blade made to be used either wet or dry, although wet is far more preferable.

For smaller cuts, you can put a diamond coated blade in a circular saw and do the job. For anything larger, though, you will need a wet blade. The wet blade setup does not make any difference to the diamonds, but it does make a difference to the adhesive that bonds the diamonds to the blade body, and, as a side benefit, it keeps dust down. That's why lapidaries use water or oil cooled saws.

This can be done by the DIY guy if you really want to try. You need a grinder, good diamond blade and enough putty, modeling clay, etc. to make a good water dam. This Bob Villa video shows how.


Sink Cutout in Granite

Re: Cutting granite - question (link)

#5

Re: Cutting granite

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Thanks, Joe,

Hadn't seen it done that way, but maybe all I saw was the cutouts for underslung stuff. Does look like it takes two guys with the sponges there.

mm

Re: Cutting granite - question (link)

#6

Re: Cutting granite

Rich Schneider

>My own two cents on this, as a guy who has worked with a lot of granite and busted a piece once or twice...take the piece to a stone cutter, pay the price to have them make the cut and be done with it...unless you have pockets deep enough to accept the risk of wrecking a perfectly nice slab of granite experimenting. Typically it is not that expensive to have them do the cut relative to the cost of the granite depending on whether or not you want a finished edge treatment on it, etc. If you said you were going to be attempting this with soapstone then that would be a different matter...

Re: Cutting granite - question (link)

#7

I agree

Joe Pack

>I agree. If it was mine, I just KNOW I would mess it up. With the price of the slab, the extra cost to have a pro do it would not be that much. What many people don't understand is that stone has tremendous vertical strength, but very little horizontal strength. You couldn't crush a 1" thick piece of granite with a ton sitting on it, but you can snap a12"x 1" piece with a decent whack with your foot if it is not supported completely.

The video was neat, though. If the stone cost is not critically important, no reason not to try it yourself.

Re: Cutting granite - question (link)

#8

No on the roto-zip

John in New Mexico

>Unless you are really patient. Perfectly feasible with an angle grinder and dry cut diamond blade, though some practice would be a good idea before starting on a slab you had to pay for. I don't think I'd try it with a carbide blade, but that's just me.

Re: Cutting granite - question (link)

#9

Thanks.

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>Thanks for your thoughts on this. It would defintely be worth hiring a pro to make the cuts, etc as long as the price is only a litte bit more. I'll pay a couple of hundred extra if that's what it takes, but from past experience (quotes, not actual work) I thought it would be much more.

I've liked the idea of granite countertops, but the prices I've seen thus far have made me shy away from it for the moment, until I saw these.

This really peeked my interest, especially at the price. $400 for the granite, $175/ea for the sinks and $80/ea for the faucets looks much more achievable ($900+) than having someone come in and do it all for a couple of thousand. But perhaps with more competition these days prices have come down. I think we'll call and get some more up-to-date quotes and then compare that to this.

The Kohler sinks that we like are shallow and mostly sit up ontop of the counter, so the hole underneath for the plumbing seems minimal and do-able.

Thanks again.

Happy Woodworking!

Re: Cutting granite - question (link)

#10

How big a hole?

John in New Mexico

>"The Kohler sinks that we like are shallow and mostly sit up ontop of the counter, so the hole underneath for the plumbing seems minimal and do-able."

I was imagining a drop in sink, but this sounds more like one that's like a bowl on the counter. If the hole you need is under 3" or so, you should be able to use a wet core drill bit in a hand held drill. The bit will be fairly expensive, but not as much as hiring someone, and there is less risk of disaster than with a grinder cutting an oval hole.

Re: Cutting granite - question (link)

#11

Re: Cutting granite - question (link) *LINK*

Nathan Pettigrew

>Check out the installation video of the company that's doing this with Home Depot. Looks pretty easy with an angle grinder and the right cutting disk.

Nathan


Granite 2 Go

Re: Cutting granite - question (link)

#12

Great link. Thanks.

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>I went to the HomeDept website when I got home, but couldn't fidn any mention of this. Thanks.

Happy Woodworking!