Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

UPDATE Tablesaw Accident

Posts

Re: UPDATE Tablesaw Accident

#26

Let's think about this...

John E in SC

>You say insurance companies use the seat belt law as an excuse not to pay claims? Can't say that I've ever heard of that happening, and I'm a family doc who has seen and treated dozens of accident victims. Isn't running a stop sign or red light "against the law"? If so, why do insurance companies pay for fixing your vehicle if you do one of those and cause an accident, but not if you're not wearing a seatbelt? I'm not trying to yank anybody's chain, but I've seen the damage that being in a wreck can do, and there's just no doubt that having a seatbelt on can improve your odds. Notice I did not say that it will prevent all injuries, and there isn't the rare case where they may actually cause problems. But the bottom line, is they improve your odds that you'll make it home to your family, and some poor doc in the ER won't have to deliver the bad news. If that saves the insurance companies a few bucks in medical bills, then I'm all for it.

Re: UPDATE Tablesaw Accident

#27

Re: Let's think about this...

jeff

>John

Don't get me wrong.

I'm all for seat belts.

I also feel it's a shame that the government must pass a law to prevent injuries to the public that can't see the safety advantage.

I've been an EMT now since 1971 and have seen alot of car injuries.

I am well aware of how much wearing a seatbelt prevents injuries.

Jeff

Re: UPDATE Tablesaw Accident

#28

Who gets harmed?

Bill Hylton

>Larry, you've yanked my chain with this rant.

"I feel the seat belt law is a farce, who gets harmed if you don't wear one? I agree with a law making it mandatory for children, but as an adult it should be your choice."

Who gets harmed?!! What an ego-centric question! If I opt not to buckle up, get in a collision and-�because I'm not buckled in-�get ejected onto the highway, a whole lot of other people are affected immediately. Folks stuck in the stalled traffic; police and emergency workers who have to scrape my brains and entrails off the concrete; medical workers who are obligated to try to piece me back together; my wife and children and grandchildren and all my other loved-ones and friends. The direct and indirect costs are born by in part by everyone in my insurance pool, by the taxpayers funding the police and emergency and highway operations, by the individuals stuck in traffic who miss appointments, work, supper.

Bah humbug indeed.

There. I've had my say.

Bill

Re: UPDATE Tablesaw Accident

#29

Bill you forgot one other reason

Dustmaker Mike

>the person that gets tossed out of the car into traffic the person in the traffic that slams on the brakes and the person behind them that hit them. Wow three other cars + in the matter of seconds. Yes this did happen I was involved in it. Just one click

Re: UPDATE Tablesaw Accident

#30

Re: Who gets harmed?

r payne

>How about if we look at it from another angle? How much government do you want in your life? If you accept the premise that since seat belts save lives and reduce injuries government can mandate their use then where do you draw the life of personal responsibility? There are all kinds of other safety issues that could be mandated and enforced. Would you accept a fire marshel randomly checking the smoke dectectors in your house? That would save lives and reduce injuries. Maybe an electrical inspector checking to make sure you don't have too many appliances on one circuit, that is also a very real hazard. Or a wood working point of view, would you like to be formally trained to have a wood work shop in your garage since a lot of wood working related accidents happen to amateurs?

In other words are you willing to live in a socialist nanny state in return for not having to concern yourselves with your own personal safety? I would rather take the responsibility to make the decisions for my life myself and have the freedom that goes with it. And just so you don't get the wrong impression, I think anyone who choses not to wear a seatbelt is an idiot.

ron

Re: UPDATE Tablesaw Accident

#31

1.5 gallon flush toiltes

Dustmaker Mike

>I never said I liked government saying what I had to do. I just said they work.