Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

New Jointer or Combo machine...long

Posts

New Jointer or Combo machine...long

#1

New Jointer or Combo machine...long

Josh in VA

>Ok guys and gals...here's my predicament.

I currently have a 6" jointer which served me well for the past 5 years. I have a lunchbox planer (single speed) and a 15" heavier duty (about 20 years old - off shore, so I am not sure about getting spare parts).

I have a couple hundred board feet of Maple, Cherry and Walnut I had cut from trees on the families properties. Some of the maples are 20"+ with majority of all boards being in the 7-9" range.

I know I can rip the boards, joint, plane, rip, glue back together, but I really do not want to do that with all of this lumber that I will be using over the next couple years.

I am trying to decide whether to go with the Grizzly G0609 12" parallelogram jointer or the G0633 12" Jointer/Planer Combo machine.

G0609 - 1,000+ lbs, 3HP, 83.5" table length

G0633 - 600+lbs, 5HP, 59.875" table length

When I do my projects, I joint a face, joint an edge square to the face, plane, then rip to square. I do all of my stock at once (at least until I screw up a piece...haha).

So changeover does not bother me.

Space really is not an issue as I am settling into my new shop and have a decent bit of room (32'x28'). However, we all know our shops shrink with time.

With that I like the weight of the standalone. However I like the size of the combo. Bed length does not bother me as I cut my stuff down before milling...and I feel confident I can joint a longer board if needed.

I am trying to keep this under $2K and this be a machine I will likely never get rid of. I have a baby (first) on the way (gloat) and know I better get this machine before he arrives or it may be a while before I get another chance.

One day I am set on the combo, then change my mind to the jointer the next.

Which route would you go? And why?

Thanks for your time and inputs.

PS...I have ruled out the JET combo machine as I do not like the fence and the lighter weight.

Re: New Jointer or Combo machine...long

#2

Re: New Jointer or Combo machine...long

Steve Schoene

>I've been happy with my combo. It's a good thing to have equal capabilities of jointer and planer. I don't know the Grizzly changeover proceedure, but It's pretty much a snap with my Hammer, and I have never had a feeling that the Combo gave up any accuracy by having the jointer tables move.

Re: New Jointer or Combo machine...long

#3

Re: New Jointer or Combo machine...long

Scott in Montana

>Hello Josh,

I switched over about 10 years ago due to space restrictions. I have a European manufactured 12" combo unit made for Delta. I've never missed the separates. If I was building a large quantity of jobs, I would probably stick with a 12" jointer and a heavy duty planer for speed considerations.

I would not let weight be a deciding factor, my Delta has piston grade forged aluminum in-feed and out-feed tables and they have been perfect. I think many of the European machines use high quality aluminum in place of the more traditional cast iron. And I've never seen aluminum rust. :O)

Scott

Re: New Jointer or Combo machine...long

#4

Re: New Jointer or Combo machine...long

ScottS

>Not having worked with a larger machine like this, I have to wonder if weight is such a bit deal. 600lbs sounds plenty heavy to me. Will another 400lbs really make the machine that much better?

That said, I'd probably go with the G0609 over the G0633. Here's why:

1) Four-knife for the G0609 versus three-knife cutter head in the G0633.

2) You can start with the base machine and upgrade to a Shelix cutter head when/if you need it. With the combo machine, it looks like there isn't an upgrade path from the G0633 to the G0634 w/spiral cutter head.

3) Longer beds make it easier to joint long boards. I hate having to pull out roller stands and try to align them to the bed when jointing a board that's too long for my 6" jointer, so longer beds are a big plus for me.

4) If you buy the G0609, you can still justify an upgrade from the lunch box planer at some point in the future. If you buy the G0633 combo machine, you've pretty much closed off all jointer and planer purchases!

Now if the G0634 were also on the shopping list, I'd have a tough time deciding between that and the G0609... Having both a jointer and a planer with spiral cutter would be very attractive!

Re: New Jointer or Combo machine...long

#5

Re: New Jointer or Combo machine...long

Josh in VA

>ScottS,

Though I have not spoken with Grizzly about this, I do believe there is an upgrade path to the Shelix head. I will likely give them a call before I pull the trigger on anything.

So I am assuming, if the G0633 is upgradeable, you would go the combo route?

Thanks,

Josh

Re: New Jointer or Combo machine...long

#6

Re: New Jointer or Combo machine...long

David G. Sparks

>I've had a Minimax 13.5 planer/jointer for many years, and I love it.

Re: New Jointer or Combo machine...long

#7

Re: New Jointer or Combo machine...long

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>A lot depends on each individual's work flow. I debated the same question a while back myself. Either way you choose is fine. Combos can give the same results as separates. In my case, space was a concern. But in the end my work flow/style prevailed in my decision. I chose to stay with separates. I simply prefer to work back and fourth from machines without making changes. But that is me.

From what you say, you are not bothered by making the conversions. So maybe the combo will work for you. But that is at least something you need to decide when making your choice.

Tom

Re: New Jointer or Combo machine...long

#8

Re: New Jointer or Combo machine...long

Chad Pearson

>I have a 16 inch European combo and am quite happy with it. If I were in a production environment I would prefer separate machines.

My only regret is that I did not keep my little 6 inch ridgid jointer. For edge jointing little boards it was good enough. Since I operate in a 3 car garage (and my tools get wheeled out from the third stall in order to use them) it would have been easier to pull out for the small stuff.

I did keep my lunchbox planer on the recommendation of the Felder guy. This was good advice because it is far easier to use for an 8 inch board than is the big iron.

Re: New Jointer or Combo machine...long

#9

Re: New Jointer or Combo machine...long

ScottS

>It would seem like a logical upgrade to offer. I was just surprised not to see the Shelix head as an option on the G0633 page like it is on the jointer product page. Having just had to plane some figured wood, and deal with the resulting tear-out caused by my lunchbox planer, the upgrade to a Shelix or spiral cutter head is definitely on my mind...

Re: New Jointer or Combo machine...long

#10

Thanks for the input

Josh in VA

>Thanks for all of the input. I am leaning more towards the combo as I don't necessarily trust my planer to last me and I don't know how long it may be until I could purchase one.

Thanks again