Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Linseed oil to pop figured woods *LINK*

Posts

Linseed oil to pop figured woods *LINK*

#1

Louie Lovas

Linseed oil to pop figured woods *LINK*

Louie Lovas

>Hello,

Just a general question regarding the use of linseed oil to 'pop' the figure in curly/figured woods (cherry, maple, etc.). I have used this technique with both good and poor results, just looking for anyone else's experience. Most (if not all) the pundits on finishing recommending flooding the surface with oil to pop or enhance the figure. Box Flexner, Jeff Jewitt and Michael Dresdner all recommend this approach in books and articles I've read.

However, in my experience doing this on tight-grained woods like curly maple, flame birch, etc. just seems to muddy the grain and figure. I've tried all sorts of pre-finishing techniques - sanding to different levels of grit (i.e. 180, 220, 400), scraping, etc. The results are generally the same. By muddy I mean the figure looses it's clarity and crispness (sorry if this is a poor description). I have used this technique successfully on open-pored woods like figured walnut and oak.

I have slightly modified this oil technique. Instead of linseed, I've used tung oil but just a very light/thin coat. This has worked better for tight grain woods.

Just looking for anyone with more experience or insight into this technique for popping the figure.


Flinthill Furniture

Re: Linseed oil to pop figured woods *LINK*

#2

Re: Linseed oil to pop figured woods

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>I don't know about the others, but Jeff Jewitt doesn't always recommend flooding the oil on. In his "Great Wood Finishes" book he has an Oil, Shellac, Wax finish. There he uses oil to pop the grain and instructs NOT to flood the wood, just get it wet and then wipe it off. Any time he does recommend flooding, he also recommends wiping off the excess several times. I don't think he recommends flooding, unless oil is the primary finish. Not all finishes work for all woods. What are you applying over the grain after you pop it with the Oil?

Re: Linseed oil to pop figured woods *LINK*

#3

Re: Linseed oil to pop figured woods

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>I routinely use oil to pop figured woods. I just did it last night with some curly maple. It helps to make sure the surface is very clean of dust.

I have not noticed muddying of the figure with oil. I apply it, rub it in well and wipe off any excess oil. Your choice of anything you might apply on top of the oil will more greatly affect the clarity I believe.

Tom

Re: Linseed oil to pop figured woods *LINK*

#4

Re: Linseed oil to pop figured woods

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>Throw out the oil. It only serves to darken and muddy everything. In blind taste tests, clear film finishes always come out ahead of oils in emphasizing grain and figure. Water white lacquer is the most effective. Figure can be further enhanced by first staining with a dilute water soluble aniline dye. Wood with distinct changes in density across the figure will differentially absorb the stain, making the less dense areas darker. Here's an example on white ash.

Clint


img

Re: Linseed oil to pop figured woods *LINK*

#5

Beautiful shop!

Tony - Memphis

>And what a setting. Like those nice big windows. I've made lots of small turnings with curly maple I get on Ebay (scraps from guitar blanks I think) "cheap." I just apply a gel varnish and I get incredible depth. I just did a piece of curly koa last night and it is amazing.

Tony

Re: Linseed oil to pop figured woods *LINK*

#6

Louie Lovas

Re: Beautiful shop! *LINK*

Louie Lovas

>Thanks for all the replies, but it confirms by belief that finishing is a 'black art'.

I typically apply a seal coat of blonde shellac over the oil base coat and then use various oil varnishes as a top coat. I spray (HVLP) the shellac, sometimes with a tint depending on what final color I'm after.

The "issue" had recently come up for me while completing a pair of 6-drawer chests. I built them using old-growth birdseye and I wanted to ensure the grain 'popped' and I did not loose the crisp clarity of the figure. In the end, I used a thin coat of (raw) tung oil as the base coat. See pic below of one of the top pieces.

thanks for the comments on the shop. I've invested big $ over the past 10 years. I've gotten to the point where I've turned my hobby into a side-business, helped to fund the shop.


img

Flinthill Furniture

Re: Linseed oil to pop figured woods *LINK*

#7

I like linseed oil

r payne

>It may just be me, but I don't see any muddying with oil. I rather like the look of 6 or 8 coats buffed out. Do you have any links to pics of side-by-side blind samples that show the muddy effect?

One thing about oil finishes I have noticed is that they aren't as shiny as other finishes. And since most people are attracted to shiny maybe the oils get rated lower because of that.

ron