>Evidently, Varathane changed their oil-based polyurethane formulation to reduce VOC, and it's now called "High Solids". But the new solvent is so obnoxious, that even slight remote bit of its odor makes my wife allergic. Have anybody seen its MSDS? Old polyurethane simply had mineral spirits as solvents, and was reasonably tolerable.
Can anybody recommend a different brand that's not that bad?
>I'm not sure if Minwax has followed suit in changing formula. The last I bought was about a year or two ago, hadn't changed at that time. I have always used the solvent based Minwax. In a review by one of the magazines a few years ago, Minwax Poly was the winner in about all categories (ease of use, appearance, tint, durability etc.). I have thinned the Minwax and sprayed it, thinned and wiped on, mixed with BLO and thinner (wipe on finish) brushed (do even thin for that) etc. and have never had a problem. It was tested against the leading Poly finishes, and was also one of the, if not the cheapest. Although Poly is not one of my favorite finishes, (I like shellac, nitrocellulose lacquer or BLO, Tung oil etc. better) there are some applications where the durability is needed. You might try picking up a quart or so of the Minwax - Wally world and all the borgs carry it - to see if it meets your needs.
>Yes, all makers of oil based finish products have had to change their formulations to comply with various state's VOC regulations. Some have done this primarily by adding oil to the varnish and reducing evaporative thinners.
To understand this, "solids" in finishes are anything that remains after the solvent/thinners evaporate. Varnish is made by mixing a resin and an oil together, heating it to a certain temperature at which the resin and oil combine to form a new compound called varnish. Evaporative thinners are then added to make it able to be brushed. In this case, the "solids" that remains after the thinner evaporates is the varnish.
To reduce the thinners, some makers are adding oil to the varnish as a partial thinner and adding less evaporative thinner. The added oil is a "solid" under the definition as it does not evaporate leaving both the varnish and the added oil as solids.
It's a clever marketing ploy to advertise the new formulation as having more "solids" as it implies it's a more durable formulation. In fact, it's probably a less durable formulation as it will be softer with the addition of the oil.
BTW, "oil modified urethane" is a just a fancy way of saying poly varnish. The addition of the urethane resin to the oil which is then heated "modifies" the oil into varnish.