Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Biscuit joiner - what to buy (or not)

Posts

Biscuit joiner - what to buy (or not)

#1

Biscuit joiner - what to buy (or not)

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>Ok, ignoring the POS craftsman router attachment, I have never used a biscuit joiner - nor felt the need for one. However I am going to help my son build all his kitchen cabinets and thought it might be useful. I do use the Kreg pocket hole system in most cases. I'm still not sure how much I would use one and don't know which one (Porter Cable, Dewalt etc.) is the best unit to purchase if I get one. In addition to the cabinet job, I thought it might be good for reinforcing picture frames, mitered joints etc. Sure could use the advice of the (far) more experienced people here.

Re: Biscuit joiner - what to buy (or not)

#2

Re: Biscuit joiner - what to buy (or not)

Paul Leuba

>Last year I was building a corner cabinet from plans in Wood magazine. The plans called for a bisuit jointer to install plates on the 45 degree angles in the face frame of the cabinet. After doing some research and posting a query on this site, I purchased a Porter Cable 557 plate jointer. It worked great. I had no prior experience with a biscuit jointer, however, I had no trouble figuring it out and using it successfully on the first try. It was a pleasure to use. I have since used it to attach 1" x 1" hardwood edging onto the plywood shelves of a book case and it worked great there as well.

I found the PC 557 to be an accurate and intuitive machine. After using it a couple times, I now agree with several comments I found in posts on this site that biscuit joints are most effective at ensuring accurate alignment of pieces being joined, and not so much about strength. I believe some additional strength is imparted, but I believe most of the strength comes from the biscuits contribution to good alignment and a good application of an appropriate glue.

That's my experience as a new tool user.

Paul in Hunt Valley, MD

Re: Biscuit joiner - what to buy (or not)

#3

Re: Biscuit joiner - what to buy (or not)

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>I'd almost be tempted to sell you my biscuit joiner because mine has been collecting dust for years. It seems to me that if you plan to use the Kreg system then I don't think you'll need biscuits anyway.

They say biscuits help with alignment. Well, that is if the biscuits are aligned. Otherwise they can also help with mis-alignment. There is no rocket science to aligning face frames etc.

I say save yourself the money.

Tom

Re: Biscuit joiner - what to buy (or not)

#4

Re: Biscuit joiner - what to buy (or not)

Robin Corell in Atascadero, CA

>I have a dewalt and rarely ever use it. It may be my machine but I find that it has a lot of sloop in the slide. I am usualy a big fan of dewalt and have several other dewalt tools with no complaints.

If you can find the money I would consider a domino. It looks like it will do all that a biscut will and more. I know it cuts more acurate than my dewalt.

Robin

Re: Biscuit joiner - what to buy (or not)

#5

Re: Biscuit joiner - what to buy (or not)

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>I have had the Dewalt for quite a few years. Easy to use and accurate. Never used it for face frame, but every time for edge/edge registration and miter joins. I think it adds considerably to miter joint strength, especially when the joint wants to open because the wood shrinks. It's been well worth the investment to me.

Clint

Re: Biscuit joiner - what to buy (or not)

#6

Lee Gordon

Re: Biscuit joiner - what to buy (or not)

Lee Gordon

>Both the DeWalt and the Porter Cable can accomodate size 0, 10 and 20 biscuits but the Porter Cable can also handle a biscuit called FF (face frame) that is a size smaller than a 0.

Re: Biscuit joiner - what to buy (or not)

#7

Re: Biscuit joiner - what to buy (or not)

Ray, SW Ohio

>I have the PC557. No play in the slide. Use it all the time joining fronts onto cabinets. My 2�.

Re: Biscuit joiner - what to buy (or not)

#8

Re: Biscuit joiner - what to buy (or not)

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

>I built my face frame kitchen using the Kreg and a less-than-$100 biscuit joiner from Menards (that looks like it was made by Freud). I gave up on the joiner fence and just registered everything of it's base and the top of my workbench. I believe it was Bob Lang who covered this method in a Pop Wood article a while back.

Re: Biscuit joiner - what to buy (or not)

#9

Re: Biscuit joiner - what to buy (or not)

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>Back in the '90s, I was all hot to trot to buy a biscuit joiner after having watched Norm (Abram—did I have to spell that out?) use one. I went to the local tool mega mart (Berland's House of Tools—a Chicagoland treasure) and, on the advice of a very knowledgeable salesman, bought an Elu 3379 (which is what the Dewalt 682 is now). I've joined a few boards with it with unremarkable results—nothing bad, just nothing spectacular. I guess I don't know what I was expecting. The pitch has changed, too—as Norm is now saying, the glue provides more than enough strength in long grain to long grain gluing.

After not using it for a while, I discovered its best second life when I started installing hardwood flooring. It does a really nice job trimming the bottom of casings to provide enough room for the flooring to slip underneath. It actually cuts just a touch higher than would be optimal (although it would probably be perfect for a thicker product), but it's good enough and keeps me from having to buy another tool.

I've changed my attitude about using it for enhanced joint strength, as related above, but I've revisited the alignment properties in a couple of recent glueups, and where before, my results were indifferent, I found with a little more care in use, it really does help with alignment.

As I recall, P-C, when the 557 first came out, wound up being sued by Black & Decker, the parent of both Elu and Dewalt, for patent infringement. B & D won and forced a minor redesign of the 557.

What Norm demonstrated in this season's kitchen cabinet series was pocket screws for face frames and then biscuits for attaching and aligning the face frames in the carcases. To me, that probably represents the high water mark in biscuit joiner utility.

Rod

Re: Biscuit joiner - what to buy (or not)

#10

Re: Biscuit joiner - what to buy (or not)

Tony - Memphis

>I feel about the same way. I have not used mine much (DeWalt). Its just real rare that I have a need where a biscuit is a good solution. I've never built kitchen cabinets, but I have been watching Norm do a kitchen. He uses a unique technique to attach the face frames with biscuits, but cuts the slots with a router all around the cabinet box (so no need for a biscuit jointer). I mostly have used mine for the few shop cabinets I have built and it allowed me to be lazy.

Tony

Re: Biscuit joiner - what to buy (or not)

#11

Lee Gordon

Re: Biscuit joiner - what to buy (or not)

Lee Gordon

>Actually, Norm does use a plate joiner to cut the slots on the backs of the face frames. He uses the router with slot cutting bit to cut the corresponding slots on the carcases.

Re: Biscuit joiner - what to buy (or not)

#12

Re: Biscuit joiner - what to buy (or not)

Pat Barber

>If you are going to be gluing up a lot of doors or attaching a

lot of face frames, a biscuit joiner is your tool. They have

a place in the shop and it really is just another part of the

tool kit.(Like always, it depends on what you are doing)

Re: Biscuit joiner - what to buy (or not)

#13

Re: Biscuit joiner - what to buy (or not)

Curt Harms

>I believe biscuit joinery was originated for use in sheet goods. I've had good luck using them in plywood. I've also used them for aligning face frames. I certainly don't see them as a replacement for M & T joints or dados and rabbets.

Re: Biscuit joiner - what to buy (or not)

#14

Re: Biscuit joiner - what to buy (or not)

Bill Spievak

>I have and use a Biscuit machine. I borrowed five or six machines before I bought. As far as what you should buy I suggest you consider how much you want to spend and what you'll use it for. Mine is used for wide glue ups, not to add strength but to help with alignment. When edge gluing 6 boards for a table top the machine reduces the amount of work to level the table tops. I wouldn't be without it for that purpose, and for aligning face frames on cabinets. I use it to repair wood floors as well, but that is another story. If I wanted the best available, without regard to cost, I would buy llamelo. I have used one and it is great, I would love to have one, but I can't justify the cost, in my own mind. If i wanted a middle of the road machine I would go with either the DeWalt or the Porter Cable, I used both and could be happy with either. I wanted one that I could set for alignment purposes and so I was only concerned with how accurately it put the slot in from the reference side. I ended up with a Makita that I got for $150 on sale. It has a round vac hole that accepts my Fein vac and it is accurate, so I am happy.

Re: Biscuit joiner - what to buy (or not)

#15

Re: Biscuit joiner - what to buy (or not)

Brian Aust - Nevada, IA

>My local woodworking club went on a tour to a cabinet shop recently, and I noticed that they install their face frames to the carcase with a Kreg jig. But a biscuit joiner would be great for alignment and if you ever want to install an Ipe deck with the hidden fasteners it would come in handy also.

Re: Biscuit joiner - what to buy (or not)

#16

Re: Biscuit joiner - what to buy (or not) *LINK*

Jerry White

>Larry,

If you do decide to go in that direction, I have a PC 557 listed over in the WC Classifieds as I post this. Good luck in your decision.


PC 557

Re: Biscuit joiner - what to buy (or not)

#17

Re: THANKS,

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>You have all given me more to think about. Seems like some really use the plate joiner, others let it collect dust. (not sure which category I would fit in yet). You have given me a few more reasons to want one. Think I'll look around for a bit before buying - Thanks again for all the information.

Re: Biscuit joiner - what to buy (or not)

#18

oops! Thanks for correcting.

Tony - Memphis

>

Re: Biscuit joiner - what to buy (or not)

#19

Re: Biscuit joiner - what to buy (or not)

Pete in Holland, MI

>Pretty happy with my Freud. Though have never used another to compare it to.