Re: Biscuit joiner - what to buy (or not)
Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach
>Back in the '90s, I was all hot to trot to buy a biscuit joiner after having watched Norm (Abram—did I have to spell that out?) use one. I went to the local tool mega mart (Berland's House of Tools—a Chicagoland treasure) and, on the advice of a very knowledgeable salesman, bought an Elu 3379 (which is what the Dewalt 682 is now). I've joined a few boards with it with unremarkable results—nothing bad, just nothing spectacular. I guess I don't know what I was expecting. The pitch has changed, too—as Norm is now saying, the glue provides more than enough strength in long grain to long grain gluing.
After not using it for a while, I discovered its best second life when I started installing hardwood flooring. It does a really nice job trimming the bottom of casings to provide enough room for the flooring to slip underneath. It actually cuts just a touch higher than would be optimal (although it would probably be perfect for a thicker product), but it's good enough and keeps me from having to buy another tool.
I've changed my attitude about using it for enhanced joint strength, as related above, but I've revisited the alignment properties in a couple of recent glueups, and where before, my results were indifferent, I found with a little more care in use, it really does help with alignment.
As I recall, P-C, when the 557 first came out, wound up being sued by Black & Decker, the parent of both Elu and Dewalt, for patent infringement. B & D won and forced a minor redesign of the 557.
What Norm demonstrated in this season's kitchen cabinet series was pocket screws for face frames and then biscuits for attaching and aligning the face frames in the carcases. To me, that probably represents the high water mark in biscuit joiner utility.
Rod