Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Table top orientation opinions?

Posts

Table top orientation opinions?

#1

Table top orientation opinions?

Doug in Denver

>I am going to build a realtively small, rectangular dining room table - 38" x 67" -out of cherry. Four corner legs - basically a pretty simple tradtional style. However, since we never remove the leaves in our current table, I think I will just build the top as one solid piece. 99% of commercial tables have the boards oriented across the width, but because most have leaves, they have to be oriented that way. As a solid top, I can oriented them either across the width or along the length. But for some reason I think that just a slab (e.g., no bread board ends) oriented along the length will look funny, although I'm not sure why. Other things - like a sideboard - would look really dumb with boards oriented to the width, but for some reason my brain wants to think a dining table top is supposed to be that way, although a coffee table should be along the length. Anyway, if you were building a solid cherry top out of boards 6" to 9" wide, which way would you go?

Re: Table top orientation opinions?

#2

Re: Table top orientation opinions?

Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn

>Aside from personal aesthetics, the main considerations are seasonal movement and retaining flatness, both of which would be more affected if the grain were oriented across the width. Wood never sleeps.

Clint

Re: Table top orientation opinions?

#3

Re: Table top orientation opinions?

John Pappas

>Along the length looks more appropriate to me. We have a small rectangular table in our kitchen (without breadboard ends) and it looks fine to me. I slightly rounded the edges and the corners and the end grain was planed and sanded well. I might add that I will also be interested to read what others have to say on this.

Re: Table top orientation opinions?

#4

Re: Table top orientation opinions?

Ed Mulligan, Cape Cod

>It's easier/cheaper to find short lengths to orient width-wise. I'd orient the long way and inlay stone or ceramic squares down the centerline for built-in hot pads.

Re: Table top orientation opinions?

#5

Re: Table top orientation opinions?

Steve Schoene

>I would lean toward running the top lengthwise. I've made one about that size and did that, with a thumbnail mold on the edges to minimize the appearance of the end grain. That would work whichever way you run the boards of course.

Re: Table top orientation opinions?

#6

Re: Table top orientation opinions?

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>I have a cherry (finished) drop-leaf dining table (wife picked it up at the Salvation Army outlet store for almost nothing). I think the orientation longways looks great. It does have a thumbnail profile on the edge which obscures the end grain.

Re: Table top orientation opinions?

#7

Re: Design Standards

Howard Acheson

>The general design standard is that boards run the long way on a drop leaf table or tables without leaves. For a table with insert leaves, the rule is to run the grain across the table.

Of course, it's your table so you can do what you want.