>I am building an oak blanket chest that will have an aromatic cedar lining. I think I read somewhere that you should not apply any finish or stain to the inside if there is an aromatic cedar lining because the cedar will cause the finish to soften.
Does anyone have experience with this? I am mainly concerned about the chest top not being finished on the inside and what effect that might have on the wood.
Thanks for any and all input.
I have not decided what type of finish to use on the chest yet but it will have an oil stain.
>Don't finish the cedar; the finish might fail and would compromise the intent of the aromatic attribute. I wouldn't worry about finishing the inside of the top.
>No doubt the notion that cedar can't be finished has some basis in fact under some conditions. However, I have never had any problem with spar varnish curing properly on cedar that was kiln dried, or equivalent.
>Rich, you don't want to finish the Cedar because you will seal in the aromatic part of the Cedar. We use Aromatic Cedar in blanket chests, etc., specifically for the insect repellant qualities of the Cedar. Bugs, 'specially moths, won't go near Cedar. In time, the cedar will lose its odour which can be restored by a light sanding with some 180 grit. Seal Cedar decks, siding, roofs, but ixnay on the lining of blanket chests.
I agree with all of the above. You should not destroy the anti-bug value of the cedar by putting a finish on it. My wife's cedar chest is solid cedar throughout, except for a tiger maple top. I lined the inside top with cedar planks. To seal the maple surface of the inside top, I used water based poly, which does not impart a smell. Over that sealed surface, I applied the 1/4" thick cedar planks, which were left unsealed/unfinished. I rely in the sealed maple surface to maintain moisture equilibrium. The outside surfaces were finished with oil based wiping poly. See Shop Shot 746
>As for the finish, for woodturning I like to use plain beeswax as a finish because I love the soft look and because it does not inhibit the fragrance, while it lasts. I sometimes use a shellac-based friction polish which darkens the wood but leaves a tough, gloss finish. This shellac finish has never been softened or affected by the cedar as far as I can tell.
I realize you didn't ask about how a finish might affect the supposed insect repellent properties of cedar, but some responses addressed this. I've read much about this in recent years. While cedar certainly has a pleasant smell and is traditionally popular for clothes chests and closets, many experts indicate the effectiveness in repelling clothes moths and other insects may be limited.
The Colorado State U. Horticulture Extension writes this:
"Cedar chests have long been recommended for use in clothes moths control. However, claims for the repellency of cedar compounds are frequently overstated. It is true that the heartwood of red cedar (Juniperus virginiana) contains volatile oils that kill clothes moth larvae, when the oils are in high concentration. However, these oils do not repel adult stages nor do they affect other woolen pests, such as carpet beetles. Furthermore, the effectiveness of cedar declines in older chests, as the concentration of the oils dissipates due to evaporation. One study suggests that chests more than three years are practically useless for killing clothes moth larvae.
"On the other hand, a well-made cedar chest can exclude clothes moths. However, the newly hatched clothes moths are very small and theoretically capable of entering very small openings greater than 0.1 mm. In reality, covers that fit tightly and do not have woolen threads exposed around the opening to attract the egg laying moths are largely safe from new attacks. Established woolen infestations within an old cedar chest can continue to develop."
When I built beehive boxes, I was told it was a terrible idea to use (eastern red) cedar, it would drive the bees out. After talking to people who have been using cedar for many years, I built them anyway and the bees love them. I like them since they are weather resistant.
BTW, when the aromatic fragrance dissipates as the oils dry, it can be restored with a little cedar oil. Rub some on lightly with a cloth or drip a little into the cracks with an eyedropper.
>If you finish the cedar the smell will be gone and the bug repellent nature will cease. Leave the inside unfinished. If the smell ever drops off you can sand the surface lightly with 220 grit and it will reveal fresh wood and scent.
You can finish cedar and the finish will dry. My father made all the "girls" in the family (four of them)cedar chests. They are solid aromatic cedar. He used Deft for the exterior finish. It had no problem drying and the chests are all now more than 30 years old and the finish has not failed or softened at any point in time. The inside still smells strongly of cedar if you open the chest.