Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

OT: I hate modern medicine!

Posts

OT: I hate modern medicine!

#1

OT: I hate modern medicine!

Bob S

>This is way off topic but I needed to vent. My father is having some health troubles that have been plaguing him for some time and his doctors seem to be going through the standard experimental phase of try this and see if it helps, now try this other thing and see if it helps. Do doctors really go to school all those years just to learn how to experiment on their patients. My dad is 82 this year and his problems have been getting steadily worse over the last two months and his doctor finally realized that maybe, just maybe there is really something wrong with him. Now he is getting every test in the book but still they can't figure out what is wrong. I am kind of hoping someone will figure something out before he drops dead. It feels like we are back in the stone age with doctors that really just have no clue what is going on inside the human body. Modern medicine? Really?

I had the same problem with health issues of my own and went through years of tests to have the last doctor (head of gastro department at a major hospital) tell me it must be in my head. We aren't smart enough to figure out what is wrong so you must be faking. You're right, I am really not vomiting right now, its my imagination.

Sorry, just very frustrated, I like my dad and wouldn't mind keeping him around a bit longer.

Bob

Re: OT: I hate modern medicine!

#2

Re: OT: I hate modern medicine!

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla

>Why do you think they say they practice medicine? They call their business "A PRACTICE". Ask a doctor what day today is and he answers "Yesterday was Friday and tomorrow is Sunday" but he will never tell you today is Saturday. Afraid of a malpractice suit for giving false info. But they do amazing things at times.

Re: OT: I hate modern medicine!

#3

Jesper, Denmark

There are some things they do know......

Jesper, Denmark

>Writing bills is one on the top of the list.

Ordering specialist examinations, so their buddies can write bills is also up near the top.

They actually do cure some diseases and save some people.

Re: OT: I hate modern medicine!

#4

The other side....

Warren E. White

>My wife has been having chest pain when we walk. A couple of weeks ago, she had two stents placed (after one attempt didn't work, and we had to wait a couple of more days in ICU).

My appreciation of our Cardiologist and the nurses and technicians at the hospital cannot be adequately expressed. They were magnificent, caring and very professional.

They do 600,000 of these a year, but only one on my best friend, so I was, to say the least, concerned.

She and I continue to walk together and she is free of any symptoms. It is all just a week out of our lives.

I am sorry that they have not been successful with you or your father. I understand your feelings, and wish you the very best.

I just wanted to express my gratitude for what they did for my wife.

Warren

Re: OT: I hate modern medicine!

#5

Thoughts on this...

John E in SC

>Believe it or not, your Dad's doctors may be feeling the same sense of frustration. I'm a family doc, and we ALL run across some patients that for whatever reason, we just can't figure out. I can tell you, I've had that frustration, and I've laid awake at night worrying about it. Despite what you may think, all of us doctors aren't in this just to "write bills". I promise you, most of the folks I know with an equal amount of education that I have make more money and work far less hours than I do. I do what I do because I hope I can make life a little better for most of my patients. But none of us have all the answers. The human body is so incredibly intricate, and made even more complicated by the fact the emotions and psychology can magnifiy or minimize any particular symptom at any time. Please don't give up on doctors. If you feel like your Dad's doctors are concerned and competent - give them time to do the workup they've undertaken. If they don't measure up, then by all means, find one that does. Best wishes,

John

Re: OT: I hate modern medicine!

#6

Re: OT: I hate modern medicine!

Dick Coers

>I feel your frustration Bob. Sure hope your Dad can hold on. Probably a good likelyhood they will not find anything. You should probably consider going to another group and let some fresh minds look into his problem.

7 years ago I started having severe headaches after a 22 straight day thrash on a job a work. Woke up one day with blurred vision, woke up the next day with my right eye looking about 45 degrees to the right with almost no muscle movement. 5 days in the hospital and they sent me home on a strong run of steroids. That was it, nothing found. I ain't been the same since. I am finally better, but still can only work hard for about an hour at a time. Didn't think that at 55 I would be mostly done with my "good" years. I did switch doctors and hope I get better care, cause my insurance will not pay the $150 office visit for a "wellness doctor".

Best of luck to your Dad, sure miss mine.

Re: OT: I hate modern medicine!

#7

Re: Thoughts on this...

Howard Norman

>John, you sound like the kind of doctor that I like to deal with. Unfortunately I have come across several that didn't appear to feel that way. I usually don't go to those doctors very long. But I have had some that I know were very concerned doctors.

My hat is off to you sir!

Howard

Re: OT: I hate modern medicine!

#8

Re: Thoughts on this...

Dave Bair, Eaton Rapids, MI

>Thanks, Dr. John. We can tend to forget that physicians are human, too. We expect them to cure us immediately, like we were a car and they, a mechanic.

Re: OT: I hate modern medicine!

#9

Re: OT: I hate modern medicine!

Malcolm Timbers

>I had a problem with upset stomachs ever since I was a teenager. All the doctors said to go on a bland diet and take anti-acid tablets. The last doctor I consulted about it perscribed Valium. It wasn't untill many years later that I found out on my own that I was allergic to heliobacter pryloia which is a very common bacteria that is found in ground water. It is not killed off with chlorination, so I cannot drink any water or reconstituted juice products without first boiling.

Not only did this bacteria upset my stomach, but it caused all kind of bodily pain. The difficult in finding the problem was that drinking unboiled water didn't affect me until about a half hour later.

In other words, if the doctors can't find anything wrong but you are ill, suspect an allergy.

Re: OT: I hate modern medicine!

#10

Re: OT: I hate modern medicine!

Bob S

>Thanks everyone for the thoughts. I am currently seeing an OMD (Oriental Medicine Doc) for accupuncture and homeopathic remedies and it has made more difference in a couple weeks than the regular doctors ever did. No dairy, no suger and no coffee to start and that is the hardest part, no coffee! Tap water, I haven't drunk tap water for many years, too many reports about how bad it is, I can't even drink filtered water at my parents house without getting sores in my mouth but they are on well water.

As for my dad it is just frustration at watching him deteriorate while continually going for more tests with no diagnosis or potential hope for improvement.

Bob

Re: OT: I hate modern medicine!

#11

Re: Health care is badly broken in America

Peter Gregory

>Medical doctors memorize a big table of decisions, they try to figure out what is wrong with you, based on their memory of their memorized facts. As soon as you get very far afield and things get complicated, doctors become much less skilled at diagnostics. Clearly, some are better than others.

When you think historically about how medical offices were run in 1960, it wasn't very efficient. They were often way behind, long waits in the afternoons, etc. After a while, some smart MBA type figured out you could move more patients through the system by putting some operational efficiencies into the office systems. Now we have "streamlined" efficiencies of most medical practices that leave the doctor almost no time to do anything, but see as many patients as possible.

When you couple that doctors have limited diagnostic ability (AKA - they aren't perfect), with running a very "efficient" doctor's office, you start running into trouble. For example, I have yet to see a modern doctor who has really studied my medical history. Studies show that the average doctor decides on a diagnosis in 10 seconds, after seeing the patient (which means you might as well say nothing, they have already made up their mind). Basically, they use more time washing their hands, than they do listening to their patients.

I'm not allowed to complain about how much money someone else makes, but if doctors don't make much money, why are they building so many 7000 square foot houses? In our life times, we have switched from an economic metric of having doctors help our GNP, to having them hurt our GNP. It used to be only criminals and lawyers hurt the GNP. It is a sad story.

In 1965, doctors and college professors made the same average salaries. Now the average doctors salary is over twice a professor's. I get a kick out of doctors talking about how people with their education make more money, it isn't back up by the facts. Now if they said that other people save more, because they don't live as high on the hog, that I can buy.

Health care in America is badly broken. Many good people are working hard in medicine, but it is still badly broken. Someday, there will be a sea change and things will start to get better. Until then, you had better be the person who owns your medical problems and diagnosis, because there is no one else. Your doctor is just too busy to do it.

Re: OT: I hate modern medicine!

#12

Re: Health care is badly broken in America

John E

>"I get a kick out of doctors talking about how people with their education make more money, it isn't back up by the facts. Now if they said that other people save more, because they don't live as high on the hog, that I can buy."

Please don't respond with generalizations like that. I realize the stereotype is that all doctors make extravagant salaries, drive Mercedes, and live in mansions. And surely, some do. But I can assure you, most of those aren't family medicine or internal medicine docs. Our "effeciency" at seeing patients isn't because some accountant told us we could make more money - most of us are just trying to hold our own. Each year, Medicare and insurance companies try to pay us less for office visits, and yet our expenses continue to go up - everything from equipment to toilet paper costs more every year, and for some reason, my staff expects to get a raise every now and then. My salary is what makes up the difference.

My point in all this, is that while I agree there are some things about modern medicine that may be "broken", please don't consider your doctor the "enemy". Most of us really do have a genuine desire to help our patients, and have precious little control over the "system".

Take care,

John

Re: OT: I hate modern medicine!

#13

Re: Health care is badly broken in America

wilbur

>I�m a pediatric oncologist. If you are going to be making comments like this, you better have your facts correct.

The �doctors make a diagnosis in 18 seconds� comment that has been popularized by Jerome Koopman is referring to a study done in 1984 that looked at 74 office visits. (Beckman HB, Frankel RM. The effect of physician behavior on the collection of data. Ann Intern Med. 1984 Nov;101(5):692-6.) The physicians participating in the study included 2 faculty attending level internists and 13 internal medicine residents. The 18 seconds refers to the average length of time that a patient got into their opening statement before an interruption was made by the physician. Which sounds terrible, but an �interruption� was defined as �Any response that physically disrupted the speech stream or inhibited further topical development�.

This definition includes exchanges like these, which are given as examples in this paper:

Physician: What brings you here today?

Patient: My head is killing me.

Physician: Have you had headaches before?

Patient: No.

Patient: I've been quite nervous lately.

Physician: Tell me more about this nervousness.

Patient: I'm out of breath all the time.

Physician: You're out of breath all the time.

Patient: I've been having chest pain.

Physician: That sounds serious.

This is clearly not coming to a diagnosis in 18 seconds. It may not be the best way to elicit a history, but it�s certainly not making a diagnosis.

And to make comments like, �Basically, they use more time washing their hands, than they do listening to their patients,� based on a study of two practicing physicians and 13 physicians in training is completely unfair, especially since you didn�t have the findings of the study correct to begin with.

As far as your assertion about physician salaries impacting the GNP, the GDP for the fourth Q4 2007 was $14,084.1 billion. (FYI, GNP hasn�t been used as a measure since 1992.) Here�s data pulled from salary.com for median salaries for the 6 basic fields of medicine.

Internal medicine: $160,564

Pediatrics: $149,938

Surgery: $284,543

Family practice: $154,731

Ob/Gyn: $229,734

Psychiatry: $173,837

There were about 633000 employed physicians in the US in 2006. Even if they were all paid $300,000, which is above average for any of the above fields, that would make up only 1.3% of the GDP. If you can show how physician salaries negatively affected the GDP, I�d be interested to know, especially since the GDP has increased steadily in constant dollars from $3,108.2 billion in 1965 to $14,084.1 billion today, which is a 4.5x increase. If you can�t show that, you�ll have to retract your statement.

And yes, you can make as much money with less education. Becoming a physician means 4 years college, 4 years of medical school, 3-5 years of residency training, and 1-3 years of fellowship if you decide to go into a subspecialty. That�s 7-10 years of training after college. Add to that the cost of medical school, which leaves medical students with an average debt of $150,000. Law school is 2 years after college, and attorneys make comparable salaries as the low end of the medical field. Director level positions in many fields have salaries comparable to physicians, and certainly don�t require 7-10 years of school, and less debt.

By the way, I�m not complaining about my salary, which is actually below average for pediatrics because I work at an academic center. I�m lucky enough to be able to support my family on just my salary while living in one of the most expensive parts of the country. (My house, for the record, is around 1500 square feet.) But sweeping statements like �In our life times, we have switched from an economic metric of having doctors help our GNP, to having them hurt our GNP,� which not only are overgeneralizations but also factually wrong just irk me to no end.