Re: Health care is badly broken in America
wilbur
>I�m a pediatric oncologist. If you are going to be making comments like this, you better have your facts correct.
The �doctors make a diagnosis in 18 seconds� comment that has been popularized by Jerome Koopman is referring to a study done in 1984 that looked at 74 office visits. (Beckman HB, Frankel RM. The effect of physician behavior on the collection of data. Ann Intern Med. 1984 Nov;101(5):692-6.) The physicians participating in the study included 2 faculty attending level internists and 13 internal medicine residents. The 18 seconds refers to the average length of time that a patient got into their opening statement before an interruption was made by the physician. Which sounds terrible, but an �interruption� was defined as �Any response that physically disrupted the speech stream or inhibited further topical development�.
This definition includes exchanges like these, which are given as examples in this paper:
Physician: What brings you here today?
Patient: My head is killing me.
Physician: Have you had headaches before?
Patient: No.
Patient: I've been quite nervous lately.
Physician: Tell me more about this nervousness.
Patient: I'm out of breath all the time.
Physician: You're out of breath all the time.
Patient: I've been having chest pain.
Physician: That sounds serious.
This is clearly not coming to a diagnosis in 18 seconds. It may not be the best way to elicit a history, but it�s certainly not making a diagnosis.
And to make comments like, �Basically, they use more time washing their hands, than they do listening to their patients,� based on a study of two practicing physicians and 13 physicians in training is completely unfair, especially since you didn�t have the findings of the study correct to begin with.
As far as your assertion about physician salaries impacting the GNP, the GDP for the fourth Q4 2007 was $14,084.1 billion. (FYI, GNP hasn�t been used as a measure since 1992.) Here�s data pulled from salary.com for median salaries for the 6 basic fields of medicine.
Internal medicine: $160,564
Pediatrics: $149,938
Surgery: $284,543
Family practice: $154,731
Ob/Gyn: $229,734
Psychiatry: $173,837
There were about 633000 employed physicians in the US in 2006. Even if they were all paid $300,000, which is above average for any of the above fields, that would make up only 1.3% of the GDP. If you can show how physician salaries negatively affected the GDP, I�d be interested to know, especially since the GDP has increased steadily in constant dollars from $3,108.2 billion in 1965 to $14,084.1 billion today, which is a 4.5x increase. If you can�t show that, you�ll have to retract your statement.
And yes, you can make as much money with less education. Becoming a physician means 4 years college, 4 years of medical school, 3-5 years of residency training, and 1-3 years of fellowship if you decide to go into a subspecialty. That�s 7-10 years of training after college. Add to that the cost of medical school, which leaves medical students with an average debt of $150,000. Law school is 2 years after college, and attorneys make comparable salaries as the low end of the medical field. Director level positions in many fields have salaries comparable to physicians, and certainly don�t require 7-10 years of school, and less debt.
By the way, I�m not complaining about my salary, which is actually below average for pediatrics because I work at an academic center. I�m lucky enough to be able to support my family on just my salary while living in one of the most expensive parts of the country. (My house, for the record, is around 1500 square feet.) But sweeping statements like �In our life times, we have switched from an economic metric of having doctors help our GNP, to having them hurt our GNP,� which not only are overgeneralizations but also factually wrong just irk me to no end.