Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

shop vac misery

Posts

shop vac misery

#1

shop vac misery

les winter

>I have two shop vacs both with clean stream filters. The filters require cleaning frequently.

Are the feins and festools really superior? Or is there a pre filter that I should be using? I'm willing to make an investment if it makes a difference.

many thanks.

Les

Re: shop vac misery

#2

JL

Re: shop vac misery

JL

>I clean mine frequently also, but that's the idea.

I usually take a leg of the LOML's old pantyhose and "bag" the filter. It seems to make it a bit easier to clean. I also remove the filter when cleaning it.

Re: shop vac misery

#3

Re: shop vac misery

Paul Woolson

>This might be worth checking out. www.clearvuecyclones.com and look for the Mini CV06. I make a lot of very fine dust in my shop. So I was going through vacuum filters like crazy. Like any other cyclone, this separates the fine stuff so it drops out before it reaches the vacuum. But it's sized in a way that the CFMs from a standard shop vac are just right. I'm pretty sure Bill Pentz (the source that EVERYONE has gone to when researching cyclones) is involved with the product.

Re: shop vac misery

#4

Re: shop vac misery

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi Les,

I am continually amazed by the little Ridgid shop vac that I have hooked to my Ryobi B3000. The vacuum canister and filter can get totally and completely full before I EVER notice stuff flying at me from the blade.

One would assume that the cleaning cycle on your vacuum would be primarily related to the volume of material that you are asking it to inhale. I'm not familiar with the particular equipment you are using.

Gary

Re: shop vac misery

#5

Re: shop vac misery

Phil Thien

>I designed a cyclone separator that works nearly as good as a conventional cyclone, and you can make it yourself.

Information here:

http://www.cgallery.com/jpthien/cy.htm

Re: shop vac misery

#6

Re: shop vac misery

Bart Leetch

>Les

If you can get a pair of pantyhose cut the legs off long enough to tie a knot in & pull the pantyhose up around the filter & put the top band over the top edge of the filter & tighten the filter in place. When the shop vac starts to sound a little strained raise the top of the vac & snap the nylon to clear the dust off. This should keep you from having to clean your filter as often. I have been using this method for several years now & it seems to work pretty good.

Re: shop vac misery

#7

Oneida Dust Deputy

Joe Pack

>I don't care what brand you have, they ALL clog! I have a Fein, a 16gal Ridgid w/1micron HEPA filter and a 12 gal Craftsman. I bought the Fein for sanding work, the Ridgid for general cutting and had the Craftsman for several years in the garage. One clogs up on the filter as fast as the other, and bags/filters cost a fortune. I switched to a Teflon coated filter, but it clogs just as fast. The filter would be completely clogged while the tank was only 1/4 full.

Then, I found out about the Oneida Dust Deputy. It cost a chunk (although I found it on "sale" for quite a bit off). It looks like an overpriced piece of metal, and it probably is. But I can say for certain that this thing works! I was showing it off to a friend a few days ago. I opened the Dust Deputy drum and showed him the drum about half full. I then opened the Ridgid vac that I use almost exclusively now and there was less than two TABLESPOONS of dust/chips in the tank. And the filter looked almost as good as new!

I have emptied the Dust Deputy drum three times now, and have only a couple of tablespoons of chips/dust in the Ridgid tank, and an almost brand new filter. While I paid a fair chunk for the Dust Deputy, I consider this the best buy I have made for my shop in years. Combined with the HEPA filter I put in the Ridgid, my dust output is all but zero when I'm using the Dust Deputy/Ridgid combination. (I also use a noise muffler on the Ridgid, which makes it just as quiet as the Fein.

There are two drawbacks on the Dust Deputy. First, getting hoses to fit is a royal pain in the patooty. Nothing fits without adapters, taping, grinding off ridges, etc. I bought the Ridgid to DD adapter along with a smaller adapter. They go on, but don't seal well. That's what duct tape is for. Second, the DD is not on wheels and it is inconvenient to drag around. To help with this, I bought two lengths of decent hose at HD and just leave the DD in a central location so I can reach just about anywhere in my shop. Eventually I will put the DD on a plywood/caster base so I can move it around. Actually, I will put both the DD and the Ridgid on the same base; they need to be side by side anyhow.

The Dust Deputy works beyond my wildest expectations. I can't imagine running a shop vac for woodworking without it.

Re: shop vac misery

#8

Re: Oneida Dust Deputy *LINK*

Joe Pack

>Check with Oneida for a sale price. I did and got mine for considerably less than the price listed on the web page.


Oneida Dust Deputy.

Re: shop vac misery

#9

The filter is the Achilles heel of vacs

Forrest Addy

>The filter is the Achilles heel of shop vacs. The construction, blower, sound level etc are the differentiating considerations in establishing price and longevity but the damn filter is what makes day to day operation effective or a PITA. The dust laden air flows through the filter leaving behind its burden as a cake that builds up on the fabric. As the cake thickens it restricts air passage.

Case in point. I like the cheap 12 Amp Sears shop vacs for the reason I can stand the noise and they do offer a lot of bang for the buck plus they have an excellent warrany. I had just changed the filter when my bro in law used it to suck out the fines from under the table saw. In seconds the note of the fan motor rose 1/3 octave and the CFM throuugh the vac dropped to about 1/10 that with a fresh filter. Bro, oblivious to cause and effect, asked "What's wrong with this vac?" Merely a filter that clogs in seconds. That's why I use a broom and dust pan for shifting large amounts of sawdust and save the vac for detail cleaning.

The drywall bags aren't much better. They also clog with the fines that build up in a cake restricting air passage. Supposedly there are formula and rules of thumb to select a filter and size the developed area for and application. I suspect the filter usually found in a shop vac is way undersized for the volume of contaminants it has to filter from the airstream. Someehow the crap has to be removed from the airstream without a huge pressure drop or something that has to be removed and cleaned.

The filter is definitely the weakest link in any dust system. A cyclone before the filter captures most dust but the very fine stuff remains suspended to clog the filter. I don't know what the solution is. In large commercial dust collection systems they used to use a water wall dust trap after the cyclone. While they save on large scale filtration they were a maintenence headache requireing labor intensive cleaning and there was the sediment and large amounts of potable water going into the sewer. Nowadays large commercial installations use a baghouse with a shaker to agitate the filter material so the fines cake falls off into a trap. But that's a long way from a pleated filter in a shop vac.

I have no solution that doesn't involve regular filter changes, filter blow outs, and filter washings. So I guess that's what you have to do. You can't get something for nothing: surrender to the need for regular maintenence.

Re: shop vac misery

#10

Re: shop vac misery

les winter

>what a great idea. I can see mounting a seperator and my vac on a roller stand, and enclosing the works in a sound reduction baffle. My problem would be solved.

thanks for the great info. Nice website too.

les

Re: shop vac misery

#11

Re: shop vac misery

Bart Leetch

>You can throw lots of money at it or use a pair of pantyhose. My filter doesn't clog & I haven't cleaned it in 3-4 years.

Why is is a mortal sin to use a simple fix? It seems now days if you can't spend big bucks to fix something your doing it all wrong.

At least give it a try whatcha got to loose nothin for a used pantyhose top..............

Re: shop vac misery

#12

Re: shop vac misery

Bart Leetch

>Oh & by the way does anyone ever read all the posts before they add their 2 cents worth.

Sorry Forrest but I had to "I have no solution that doesn't involve regular filter changes, filter blow outs, and filter washings. So I guess that's what you have to do."

My regular maintenance involves a free pantyhose top from the LOML & less than 30 seconds to raise 1 side of the vac top & reach underneath & snap the pantyhose top in 3-4 places to knock the dust off, pretty simple really.

Re: shop vac misery

#13

Re: The filter is the Achilles heel of vacs

Kevin Rabenaldt

>The answer may be a series of cyclone type separations. Each stage is designed to handle certain volume, pressure, and dust size. I would think the larger size particles would be removed first. Just some thoughts.

Its funny about things. When I was a young engineer working for a major oil company, we investigated the types of oil and water separation equipment. I thought in my mind of a something like the cyclone but never pursued it. Still may work.

Kevin

Re: shop vac misery

#14

Re: Oneida Dust Deputy

Paul Leuba

>The Dust Deputy has been a successful addition to my Shop Vac. I empty it many times before I need to change the bag and filter in the vac itself. I've also experienced some diffuculty in adapting different sanders and vacuum attachments to the Dust Deputy inlet hose. I have discovered that a piece of 1 1/2" PVC pipe is a very nice snug fit onto the hose. I have been adapting my other attachments to this short piece of PVC.

The configuration that I have been using consists of the Dust Deputy attached to a Shop Vac with a 2 1/2" hose. The Shop Vac has a dry wall dust filtering bag, and also a ClearStream HEPA cartridge filter. After a couple projects I opended the Shop Vac and found almost no material on the cartridge and very little material in the bag. The overwhelming majority of the vacuumed particles stay in the Dust Deputy cyclone container which is a snap to empty.

Paul in Hunt Valley

Re: shop vac misery

#15

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

Interesting...

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

>In the course of my painting career, I've been through quite a few of the drywall bags, vacuuming miles of wall-floor junctions prior to spraying. My experience is that when I use both a drywall bag and a pleated filter, the suction power does not significantly drop off until the vac is so heavy I don't care to be picking it up. One bag can get me through a large house after drywall has been sanded. Without the bag, a pleated filter will barely last a room.

I'm with you on the "bang for the buck", though. The newer ShopVacs and Craftsman vacs are much quieter than their predecessors of just 10 years ago. Although, after they've sat in the back of my pickup through a rainy night, they do get louder...

Jason

Re: shop vac misery

#16

Re: shop vac misery

Bob S

>I have used Shop Vac brand vacuums for years with the internal bag and a cartridge HEPA style filter for the motor with no problems. I have it hooked up to my ROS and Palm sanders and even my belt sander when I use it. The only time I clean the cartridge filter is when I replace the internal bag when it's about half full and even then it only needs a quick vacuuming. I vacuum my shop floors after sweeping up most of the big stuff so all the fine dust goes into the vacuum. On average I bet my vacuum runs 4-5 hours a week minimum. The internal bag makes all the difference for keeping dust off the cartridge filter though and makes cleanup as quick as pulling one bag and stuffing in another.

Bob