What are they worth?
Kelly Handwerk
>Over the years I have upgraded my tools. Now I need to get rid of tools I no longer used, what would the going price of a Sears 10 in table saw and a 12 in band saw?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
What are they worth?
Kelly Handwerk
>Over the years I have upgraded my tools. Now I need to get rid of tools I no longer used, what would the going price of a Sears 10 in table saw and a 12 in band saw?
$50 for both...if you're lucky
Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn
>
$ 20.00 per.
steve mackay
>
Re: What are they worth?
henthorn
>I see them pretty regularly listed at $100 or more on Craig's list. Don't really know what they sell for though.
Re: What are they worth?
Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio!
>Hi Kelly,
It really depends on which 10" tablesaw you have. Some of the older ones were not to bad. I have one that I bought back around 1984. I added a few improvements... Vega fence... turned sheaves and the link belt and it was, and is, a very good saw for what I do. But I am sure I have more in the extras that the original price of the saw.
I also had one of the 12" tilt head bandsaws. It may have been the worst piece of equipment I ever used. It was one my Father in Law bought for the shop. I was amazed when I put it in an auction and got $150.00 for it.
Guess that isn't much help, but that is my experience. I would put them up on Craigs list and see if you get any nibbles. :)
Best wishes,
Dave
Re: What are they worth?
Bill Kay
>Good Morning Kelly,
You'll see the table saws on Craig's List priced anywhere from 75 to 150 depending on condition and model. The older ones with cast iron wings seem to move quickly.
It appears that the "anti craftsman" crowd is alive and well. Many of the folks that have nothing good to say about the older Craftsman saws will rave on about Ridgid. Rumor has it that at one time Emerson built both brands.
New woodworkers and those of us on a tight budget find that the older Craftsman saws can provide many years of enjoyment.
Regards,
Bill
Re: My Old Tilt Top Was Worth Giving Away
George@Colonel's Workshop-Havertown PA
>Hello Dave,
I was unaBLE TO sell my old 12" Craftsman tilt top so I gave it to #1 son. It did me well over the few years I had it, and is still being used. There is no comparison to my current Jet bandsaw, but I will admit that it did some acceptable work for me with a premium 80"blade installed. I especially liked the size of the table. Good saw for light duty home shop work.
George
Re: What are they worth? ____*PICs*
Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach
>> You'll see the table saws on Craig's List priced anywhere from 75 to 150 depending on condition and model. The older ones with cast iron wings seem to move quickly.
I think that price for a Model 100 ('50s/'60s era) is about right. Later models, indistinguishable to the typical buying crowd, aren't much differently paid off. I had a Model 100 (like this:)


In addition, I had a 1970s era bandsaw, much like this:

Mine had screw on knobs where the cast bosses are on this one, otherwise it appears to be identical.
> It appears that the "anti craftsman" crowd is alive and well.
Not for nothing are they so inclined. If you were to look at my shop in the '70s/'80s it would look like a Craftsman catalog. Why? Because that was what was available. Sure, Delta and Powermatic had been building the same high quality tools we've come to know them for, but they were aimed at institutions and commercial shops and there was no distribution network as there is today, so we got what we could.
To intimate that people are down on Craftsman unfairly is to imply that there is some sort of mysterious bias about them. There's not. My shop now looks like a Delta catalog. Anti-Craftsman? You bet. I used them. I worked around them. I got rid of them. Having said that, are they total trash? Well, if one wants to get started in woodworking and is on a limited budget (as you say below), they can represent some value and at least get one to cutting wood. But to say they were well built, well designed tools, intended for heavy work or long life is to fail to recognize tools that actually do meet those definitions and is to fail to grasp Craftsman's intended place in the market. And to imply that someone who observes (and experiences) those shortcomings is simply “bashing” doesn't give fair value to that experience. Finally, the floor tools were probably better than the hand power tools, many of which were utterly horrid. The anti-craftsman bias should be applied differently to the hand power tools vs the floor tools.
> Many of the folks that have nothing good to say about the older Craftsman saws will rave on about Ridgid. Rumor has it that at one time Emerson built both brands.
Well, I don't know that I've ever heard anyone rave about Ridgid in general, particularly if they had any experience with Craftsman. And, it's no rumor. Emerson was Sears' supplier for probably 30 years—maybe more. And yes, Ridgid is owned and built by Emerson. Particularly in their early models, the saws were virtually identical to the last ones sold by Sears. What a surprise.
> New woodworkers and those of us on a tight budget find that the older Craftsman saws can provide many years of enjoyment.
Enjoyment may be a little strong, but they can certainly do useful work. I would say that of all the Craftsman tools I owned, the band saw probably gave me the least trouble and the most reliable service. The jointer, on the other hand, fought me hammer and tong from the beginning. The thing I would want to point out the most is, if one has used nothing but Craftsman tools, they may be less able to assess their clear inferiority. Someone who has owned/used both Craftsman and Delta/Powermatic/General won't have a scintilla of doubt.
Craftsman bashing? No, voice of experience. But here's a test: there is an ocean of woodworkers with Craftsman tools who I suspect would love to move to Delta/Powermatic/General replacements. See if you can find any Delta/Powermatic/General owners who wish they had Craftsman tools.
Think Citroen 2CV vs Lincoln Town Car. They'll both get you around town, but it's pretty much a one way ownership path. Yeah, it's that dramatic.
Rod
Well said
Clint Searl, at the base of Haycock Mtn
>
AMEN! I HAVE AN IDENTICAL EPERIENCE!
Chicago Bob
>
Citroen 2CV vs Lincoln Town Car?
Jerry Nicholson
>Which one of those would you choose if you had to drive through a region where it was necessary to take the car apart so two men could carry it across a stream? The drivers of a Deaux Cheveaux (sp?) actually had to do that during one of the first trips into South America on the Pan American Highway. Supposedly they also mashed bananas into the transmission when they ran out of grease! Some 2CVs had a second engine in the back to make it a 4 wheel drive vehicle. For those that have never heard of a Citreon 2CV, it was an exceedingly ugly little grossly underpowered uncomfortable front drive French made piece of crap. The big Citreons were, however, very interesting and highly advanced machines with the comfort of a luxury car. I think the last time I rode in one was 1964.
Jerry
Forgot to add...
Jerry Nicholson
>I still use a 1964 Sears table saw and late 60s vintage Sears 12 inch bandsaw. I added the low end Unifence to the table saw several years ago and that really made a major difference in cutting accuracy. The Formica covered MDF right, left, and rear extensions help a lot too!
Jerry
Re: My Old Tilt Top Was Worth Giving Away
Robin Corell in Atascadero, CA
>There was a time when craftsman was aiming for the industrial market and carried some pretty good tools. This would have been in the 40's and 50's and included the craftsman badged parks 12" planer and 18" parks bandsaw. I curently have a craftsman/parks 18" bandasaw and have found it to be a very high quality machine. it was made inthe late 50's weighs close to 400lbs ad has a resaw capacity of 12". There are not many craftsman tools I would be willing to buy but there are a few vintage ones that are truely industrial quality tools, and they are also the less common and harder to find craftsman tools.
Robin
Re: What are they worth?
knotscott
>It depends on the models, the condition, included accessories, and your local market. I frequently see the old Emerson made 70s and 80's full size cast iron contractor saws selling in the $100-$150 range in good working condition...sometimes more with an upgraded fence. The 12" BS doesn't seem to fetch as much.
As a note of clarification - The Emerson made saws have much in common with the Ridgid saws. FWIW, Emerson stopped making the Ridgid saws 3-4 years ago, and signed an agreement to have Ryobi's parent company make them under the Ridgid name for Emerson.
As a editorial comment - Not everyone who comments on the Craftsman items has stayed up with recent developments and offerings. Previously owning a '71 Pinto does not make me an expert on the 2008 Ford Fusion or F350. If they can't get facts straight, their opinions should hold even less weight...
Horses for courses…
Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach
>> Which one of those would you choose if you had to drive through a region where it was necessary to take the car apart so two men could carry it across a stream?
Ha, ha (also in response to the amusing section I snipped). You're absolutely right. That's no place for a Town Car!
> For those that have never heard of a Citreon 2CV, it was an exceedingly ugly little grossly underpowered uncomfortable front drive French made piece of crap.
I couldn't have characterized it any better…except for the carrying it across a jungle stream part. Check this link for some pictures.
> The big Citreons were, however, very interesting and highly advanced machines with the comfort of a luxury car.
As a matter of fact, those big, hydropneumatic suspension, adjustable ground clearance cars are what they used as limousines, much as we use Lincolns or Caddies, the Germans use Mercedes', and the British use Bentleys or Rolls'. Check this link for some pictures of the classic DS.
Thanks for the info.
Rod
Re: What are they worth?
Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach
>The original poster didn't specify the vintage of his tools, so in that sense, you may be correct in what I was intimating—that is relevance to his tools. On the other hand, I bought my first Craftsman tool in 1972, was selling them in 1965, and owned a Model 100 table saw that dated to the early '60s. My last purchase was probably in 1980. However, I watched their product line closely from the late '60s through perhaps, 1990, at which point I pretty much gave up on them for a variety of reasons. That did not end my awareness of them or where they went until they and Emerson split the sheets (mid '90s, as I recall).
That I didn't own a 1995 Pinto (or the metaphorical equivalent) does not make me either unaware of or unqualified to remark upon the path their product line followed. Moreover, whether it's 2008 or 2028, my 1995 experience with a 1962 tool isn't affected by the 2008 product line. I can also tell you that I left a lot of information out of my post to keep it readable. I have many more tales of Craftsman quality I can relate.
Now, if that wasn't aimed at me, forgive me. And I freely admit I know nothing of Craftsman tools since the Emerson split. I don't think I've even speculated about it. I can say that a sour taste memory doesn't go away just because the dairy started using different cows.
Rod
Re: Horses for courses�
Jerry Nicholson
>I checked your link on the 2CVs. I used to think that the 2CV was the world's ugliest car but there are a few now, like the Pontiac Aztec and that Honda thing that looks like a UPS truck, that can readily compete for that title.
Jerry
Re: What are they worth?
Ellis Walentine
>The Craftsman I grew up with was my grandfathers, probably from about 1945 or so -- no probably earlier because of the war effort and steel rationing. My father and I used it in our basement shop for decades. My biggest complaint was the 1/2 HP motor, which we replaced with a 3/4 HP motor. Somewhere along the line, either the arbor or the bearings got whacked and I couldn't get it to cut true anymore, so out it went in the dumpster. If not for that, I'd have asked $75 and hoped for $50.
Ellis Walentine, Host
Great post, Rod. Thanks.
Ellis Walentine
>
Re: What are they worth?
Kevin Rabenaldt
>Well, I have a 1973 model with 1 hp. I have built a wide extensions on both sides (with rollers), formica top, Biesemeyer 52 inch fence, magnetic starter recently, converted to 220v. For my use, I do not need a new saw. I have added these things when I could over the past 25 years. Bought the saw used with a Sprunger 6" jointer and Mongonmery Ward 14 inch bandsaw for $450. All work fine, but I am not a professional all day shop.
Kevin