Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

OT - Hunting and GPS, do I need one?

Posts

OT - Hunting and GPS, do I need one?

#1

OT - Hunting and GPS, do I need one?

Brian in Brighton

>For all you hunters out there. Do you have and use a gps? My wife and I are working on getting back into hunting and I was wondering if I should get a gps unit. If so, any recommendations?

Brian in Brighton

Re: OT - Hunting and GPS, do I need one?

#2

Re: OT - Hunting and GPS, do I need one?

steve mackay

>As an old Boy Scout and retired GI I'd say the money is better spent on an old M-2 compass and the best maps you can get your hands on of your target area. Even with the GPS still need the map. And no worries about hooking enough sats on a cloudy day. Probably spend as much for the M-2 and maps and more dependable.

Re: OT - Hunting and GPS, do I need one?

#3

Re: OT - Hunting and GPS, do I need one?

Randy Johnson Connersville, IN

>I guess it depends on where you are hunting.

One thing I'll always remember from the many Friday night flights from Shreveport to Indianapolis was that there was never an area that the lights on the ground didn't look like the Milky Way. On maps, the country might have looked wild but you would never be too far from some kind of road. The further east you go the more that would probably hold true. And exception would be a big chunk of Maine and some of New Hampshire. (Check http://www.ntsb.gov/ntsb/brief.asp?ev_id=20001208X07226&key=1 and read about a jet aircraft that it took a few years to find.)

For those areas that are more sparsely populated I agree with Steve. GPS is kinda neat I guess but a map and compass have worked fine for untold centuries. I would not want to trust everything to an electronic gizmo that might fail when I needed it most. Plus, a map and compass won�t weigh as much.

Re: OT - Hunting and GPS, do I need one?

#4

Re: OT - Hunting and GPS, do I need one?

John K Jordan

>If you ask me, why yes, certainly! (Of course, I'm the guy with the GPS addiction, five units at the moment and thinking of getting another one.)

I don't hunt any more, but I always take one with me when I'm getting way out in the woods or trails (along with topo maps and compass.) It gives more freedom to explore with the convenience of dropping markers and plotting trails while adding a measure of security and safety.

I can give several examples where a GPS came in handy. Once, when taking a friend on some serious off-road jeep trails we made one big loop about 10 miles long and came down a hill I would have hated to back out of. With a huge tree blocking the way, the GPS told me we were just a few hundred yards from where we started the loop. With this knowledge, I had incentive to find a way around the tree where I normally would have backed up and retraced my path.

Another time I was riding with a friend perhaps 15 miles off the main road when he foolishly tried to plow through a soft spot in the trail. That was the last that truck moved under it's own power, sunk up to the frame in mud. Fortunately, my GPS and maps told me we were less than a couple of miles from some houses. Instead of an all night effort and a 15 mile hike, we walked up the mountain, knocked on some doors, and got someone to bring a truck down and pull us out of the mud.

Years ago when I did engage in occasional deer murdering, I used the GPS to put a waypoint at my destination if it was new to me, to mark the vehicle location, and to mark promising sites while scouting.

I guess it depends on the kinds of places you hunt. If you never hunt tracks more than five miles across, you probably won't need a GPS to find your way back. However, if you hunt wilderness or are one who can get lost in a Walmart, it might be really useful!

JKJ

Re: OT - Hunting and GPS, do I need one?

#5

Re: OT - Hunting and GPS, do I need one?

Mike Fitterling

>Nothing will replace the map and compass, but a GPS is very handy and adds a measure of safety. There is a tract of land here that we used to hunt--50,000 acres--and there have been times when a GPS would have saved some time and effort. Nice thing about a GPS is the ability to easily follow your tracks back if you get lost. They are light, small, and cheap now, so why not have on in your pocket? I have sailed thousands of miles with just a sextant and timepiece or just ded reckoning, but a GPS would have been a nice backup.

Re: OT - Hunting and GPS, do I need one?

#6

Re: OT - Hunting and GPS, do I need one?

Ells (not Ellis) in Boulder

>Steve,

While I don't completely disagree, you should be aware of couple things.

1. Clouds don't interfere with GPS reception.

2. You can get GPSs with built-in complete USGS topo maps

So they are pretty darn useful now. I know more and more outdoor adventures that won't go without out them for safety purposes.

That said - I lost interest in flying small aircraft in part because the GPS just made navigating too simple and although I could go without, because it was there I used it because it was so simple, okay that's my issue but points 1. & 2. stand.

Re: OT - Hunting and GPS, do I need one?

#7

Re: OT - Hunting and GPS, do I need one?

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>I have given up hunting (can't do the walking any more) - still shoot target and fish. I have never been totally lost when hunting/fishing, but I have certainly walked a lot farther than I needed too at times. Had they been available when I was younger, I certainly would have owned one. I would still be sure I carried a compass - and map if in unfamiliar surroundings. The GPS (with the addition of a topographical map) might save you a lot of time getting to the area's you select to hunt in as well as avoid getting lost. If you are going to have to lug a deer or elk out of the woods, it sure would be nice to avoid hills, creeks etc. My youngest son and a friend took a week long canoe trip down the Wabash river here in Indiana a couple years ago. He carried a Garmin GPS and found it quite valuable. It indicated when they were approaching towns/cites (re-supply points) - dams, rapids etc.. He said he wouldn't go again without one. I know I sure wouldn't go without one in my vehicle again.

Re: OT - Hunting and GPS, do I need one?

#8

Re: OT - Hunting and GPS, do I need one?

Gene Gauss

>I hunted in NYs Adirondack Forest Preserve for over 40 years until my knees went bad, mostly from a camp we set up several miles back in. I was always able to get back to camp by full dark using a topo map and compass, but it was pretty close a couple of times. The biggest problem in wooded land is being able to see some of the terrain you need to be able to find yourself on the map. I have new knees now and a Garman etrex GPS, and intend to use it that way. I used it last fall during a vacation trip in the southwest. We had a 4WD SUV, topo maps, and the Garmin. It came in handy a couple of times to locate ourselves on dirt roads/trails in some of the wilderness out there, especially where there were forks in the road that didn't show on the topo maps. I've just signed up for elk hunting/fly fishing in the Bob Marshall Wilderness of Montana this fall, and the Garmin (with extra batteries) is going with me along with a good compass and some topo maps, even though much of the trip will be guided.

Re: OT - Hunting and GPS, do I need one?

#9

More to the point, do you want one?

John in NM

>If so, then by all means get one, you'll probably find it useful.

Myself, I've no use for the things. Maybe it'd be different back in

the tree'd east, but out here a map, compass, and sense of direction is all you need.

Re: OT - Hunting and GPS, do I need one?

#10

Re: OT - Lots of info

Brian in Brighton

>Thanks for all the comments. First, we live in Colorado and plan on hunting on the Western side of the Continental Divide. In this area, unlike back East, you can fly over and not see a single light as far as the eye can roam. There are times when you can expect to be miles from the nearest human. Hunters do get lost and sometimes get found. The maps are not a problem for me, as is the compass. I plan on using the gps as a backup and for the wife to see which way we came to help get back to camp. She can't read a map worth a darn and no matter how many times I tell her that the top of the map is ALWAYS North, she still rotates it all over the place to try to figure it out.

I guess I'll just get a used e-trex off of Craigslist and start playing with it.

Brian in Brighton