Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

New house, new shop!

Posts

New house, new shop!

#1

New house, new shop!

Rob Sandow

>I am finally getting my shop back. I had to pack it all in PODS 2 years ago because of a divorce but I finally have a new house under contract with a detached 2-car garage which will become my shop. There is much work to do, running electric and gas out there, putting up interior framing, insulation, and walls in the bare concrete block structure, but at least I have a starting point now.

So my thoughts are to maximize interior space I would put up stud walls with 2x3s and fill with solid foam insulation. Then use plywood as the wallboard rather than drywall, since I can then use the plywood to attach cabinets etc.

I will want to install a vent free gas heater. I had one in my last shop for many years and it worked great. Vented ones are nice but expensive and not really worth the installation hassle in a garage. I think a 50 amp sub panel will be sufficient. I'll have to run that too.

Any advice is appreciated.

Rob

Re: New house, new shop!

#2

Re: New house, new shop!

Bob in NE Ohio

>Congrat on getting your shop back! My only thought is that the 50 AMP box may not be enough and you can't add another sub panel to it later.

Consider putting in 100, the cost will not be that much more now copared to what it will cost to upgrade later

Bob

Re: New house, new shop!

#3

Re: New house, new shop!

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>It'll be nice to have you back, Rob. Seems like way too long since we've had any exchanges.

I sort of half agree with Bob—I think 50A may be enough insofar as current capacity is concerned (Rick Christopherson usually opines that it is more than enough for a one man shop), but I think the more important thing to look at is space for breakers. The thing to do is buy a main lug load center (that is, without the breaker) in the size that will provide for all possible present and future circuit breakers—I bought one that has 16 slots. Sounds like a lot, but five 240V breakers later (jointer, planer, saw, compressor, DC—I prefer dedicated circuits when possible), I only had two slots left for three 120V circuits.

I wound up using two slim double breakers, but I don't care for that solution. I wish I had gotten a panel with 20 or even 24 slots. There's not a large disparity in price, one size fits all when it comes time to decide what size main breaker to put in (price differences are relatively inconsequential for the various sized main breakers), and the extra slots you don't use are hedges against unforeseen future demands.

Back to the 50A issue, new work is the time to size the supply. With copper prices the way they are now, it may very well be that the difference between the feeders for 50A and 60, 80, or 100 may be significant enough to require some compromise. But, for example, if you have any interest in welding, 50A may have you up against it if the compressor kicks on while you're deep in some ¼". Only you can assess those factors.

Please keep us apprised of your progress.

Rod (not Rob)

Re: New house, new shop!

#4

Re: New house, new shop!

Chuck Kettler Greenwood IN

>There is no substitue for doing it right the first time. Pull 100A and you will be glad you did.

Re: New house, new shop!

#5

Re: New house, new shop!

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>Rob, I know many believe a 50 amp service is sufficient for a shop. I disagree as the number of circuits are pretty limited in a 50 amp. A hundred amp service box is within $50 of the 50 amp (granted the wire size required may increase the installation cost somewhat). But once the 100 amp is installed, you will have circuits available for lighting - separate breakers for 230 amp equipment, the availability of power for a welder etc. The labor is the same. To me it is kinda like making a sideboard using poplar rather than Cherry. With all the work involved the cost difference is minimal. You may regret going undersized on the wiring putting a 50 amp service in, - but if you probably will forget the money difference in a few weeks and be darn glad you up-sized to a 100 amp - if you just need to add one circuit more than the 50 amp allows. I have a 100 amp in my shop and have used every breaker opening - almost wish I had added a couple more service panels.

Re: New house, new shop!

#6

Clarification, re load center.

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>One of the other replies made it seem as if you needed to get a “200A” load center in order to get the necessary number of breaker openings for your shop. I know this from direct experience with the Square D QO line of panels because it's what I did, but I can't speak specifically to other brands (although they probably do the same thing). When you're selecting your load center, look at the “Main Lug” panels. Those are the ones without the breakers. They may still be labeled as 60A, 100A, 200A, etc., because that is how they are commonly paired with user applications. However, the busses and contacts are identical, both in capacity and size, so you can buy a 40/40 panel (40 breaker spaces, 40 circuit capacity) and put a 60A main breaker in it (I wouldn't, as it encourages putting in too many circuits), or you can by a 30A panel and put a 100A breaker in it.

For my sub panel, I bought a 16/16 panel, which if it came with a main breaker would probably be a 60A panel. However, buying it as a Main Lug and putting in my own 100A breaker, I got the number of breakers capacity I wanted (and not too much) while getting the current capability I wanted, as well. In other words, in my situation a “100A” panel would have had too many breaker spaces, but a panel with the number of spaces I wanted wouldn't have had as large a breaker as I wanted. Truth be told, I probably could have functioned very well with only a 60A service, but there's not much difference in price between the breakers.

Rod

Re: New house, new shop!

#7

Re: New house, new shop!

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>Although I really enjoy the hand tool side I would have to say if you are putting in a new service in 2008 it might as well be 100 amp. My shop is served well with a 50 amp service but if I was putting in a new one and had to do all that work any way I would make sure it was 100 amp. Mainly as stated, room for adding circuits, plus it would surely not cost all that much more to put in 100 amp than 50 amp.

Re: New house, new shop!

#8

Re: New house, new shop!

Joseph Mulherin, Sr.

>Back in 1987 I decided to add on my shop. Also, decided to upgrade my elec. service to 200amp. Bought the 200 and rewired all of it properly. House was built in 1952 and wiring standards were different than in the 80s, so I added a box above new circuit box to run old wiring into and upgrade to modern day codes. As I was working on panel I saw someone watching me from behind....it was the local building inspector from the city. He said I was doing everything correctly and he signed off on the report before I was totally finished. Had the elec. turned off at 730am, ripped out old and installed new boxes and had elec. turned again by 330pm. I took my old 100amp box and installed it in my new shop with each outlet being on its own circuit breaker....7 in all...and a 230V. for the older RAS I had.

So, if and when any of you decide to upgrade your elec. services in any area of the house or shop....go for the higher ratings and you will be glad you did.