Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Soft shellac finish

Posts

Soft shellac finish

#1

Soft shellac finish

GolfSteve in Calgary

>I've only finished two projects with shellac. One was a side table that I French polished. The other was a turned candy dish.

If anything is left sitting on the table for any length of time (eg. a week), marks will be left in the finish deep enough that they need to be sanded out. I'm not talking about leaving your anvil sitting on the tabletop - in one case a quilted fabric coaster left thread and weave marks in the finish. This table was finished with orange shellac. The table is about two years old now, and the finish is still soft.

The candy dish was sprayed with shellac then polished up with abrasives. The finish had cured for at least 1.5 months . Last week we threw about 15 business cards into the candy dish. The corners of the cards dug through the finish (see picture below). The finish on the bottom of the dish is also marred just from sitting there. This candy dish was finished with dyed blonde shellac - so I cannot blame both the candy dish and table problems on a bad batch of shellac since they were made from different flakes. (Both shellacs were prepared from dry flakes, used Lee Valley's denatured alcohol as the solvent, and were applied within two months of the flakes being dissolved. The shellac seemed to dry hard).

Any ideas about this? I'm sure shellac is not supposed to be this soft.

The only thing I can think of is that in both cases I did some wet sanding on the dry shellac using low odour paint thinner as lubricant - might this have interefered with the finish hardening?


img

Re: Soft shellac finish

#2

Re: Soft shellac finish

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Steve,

Your shellac is long past its useful life. Mixed shellac goes through a process called esterification which breaks down the resin's ability to harden. Your picture is a classic example.

Unfortunately, your only option is to remove it, and after you throw the old stuff away and mix new finish and refinish the items. I think you will find that it will come off rather easily with an alcohol scrub.

If you buy your shellac readi-mixed, like Zinnser's, make sure you check the dates on the can. The dewaxed shellac in SealCoat has an advertised shelf life of about 2 years, but Bull's Eye and others are much shorter. I mix fresh from flakes and do not use any shellac older than 4 months.

Good luck. Tough lesson. |;-}

Re: Soft shellac finish

#3

Re: Soft shellac finish

Larry Clinton At Frankfort (Central)., Indiana

>Wow Steve, I use a lot of shellac, Finished all the oak trim in my sons house, and have done several other projects - all of them are hard as a rock. I read your comments on what you used and on the face of your facts, it looks like you used a "fresh" batch. But the results sure look like the shellac had deteriorated. Possibly the flakes were stored in a hot &/or humid area for too long prior to mixing?? Or possibly the dissolved shellac was stored in a warm area or the container wasn't sealed and allowed moisture into the mix? As an example of the durability of "good" shellac, My son and I had finished the complete window trim over his kitchen sink with amber/orange shellac (we did wax it with Briwax after it was cured). His wife has set wet items on the window sill (including soap)- so far the finish has held up as well as any poly finish I have used. I don't think the solvent you used during sanding should have had any effect.

Re: Soft shellac finish

#4

Re: Soft shellac finish

GolfSteve in Calgary

>Mark,

The candy dish was finished with freshly prepared shellac made from dry flakes and denatured ethanol. Do you think the dry flakes were bad? I don't think the liquid sat around long enough to have esterified.

Thanks,

Steven

Re: Soft shellac finish

#5

Re: Flakes

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Dresdner can jump in here any time, but unless your DNA was contaminated with weird****, I think bad flakes is your only other culprit here. Yes, flaked shellac does go bad if not properly stored. You haven't said how old your stock was so I can't venture an opinion. I have dry flakes that are more than 3 years old (kept cool and dark) and are fine. I would contact my vendor to see if they've had any problem with the same lot of shellac.

You might also pose your problem to Jeff Jewitt at Homestead Finishing. I buy all my shellac from Jeff and it's always been first rate stuff.

mm

Re: Soft shellac finish

#6

Re: Soft

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>What did you use as a lubricant for your french polish?

Orange shellac has a wax content which makes it softer than dewaxed, but not THAT soft. Do the marks lessen over time after the offending item is removed from the surface?

mm

Re: Soft shellac finish

#7

Re: Soft

GolfSteve in Calgary

>I used mineral oil for the french polished table.

For the candy dish I sprayed the shellac then polished (with some wet sanding using low odour paint thinner).

I hate to strip the candy dish, but perhaps that is the best way to go.

For the table I was planning to sand down the old shellac until all the marks were removed, then top coat with lacquer.

Re: Soft shellac finish

#8

Table

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Mineral oil should not have effected the shellac, but its possible that some of it got tied to the wax in your orange shellac, further softening the finish. Doesn't explain the candy bowl though. If you don't remove the soft shellac on the table you're likely to get cracking in your hard lacquer film. As the lacquer gives up its solvent, the film shrinks down on the surface, in this case soft shellac, which doesn't form a solid base for the film so the lacquer may then crack or "check". You see this in old shellac finishes, especially ones where new shellac has been applied over an old (softened) finish Hate to say it, Steve, but it looks like you've got a strip job on your hands any way you go here. Just don't forget to wear a OV mask when working the alcohol. Having frenched a table or two, I feel your pain in have to remove it.

Re: Soft shellac finish

#9

Re: Sanding won't work

Dave Mount

>Hi Steve--

Sorry to hear about your problems. I doubt very much you'll be able to sand the table -- finish has to be hard to sand it. As it is, it'll just gum up your sandpaper in about three strokes. Stripping it is the way to take it off. And, as others said, you won't be successful leveling it and coating over it, the topcoat will fail.

Best,

Dave

Re: Soft shellac finish

#10

Re: Soft shellac finish

Ken Platt (Granby, CT)

>The flakes can go bad after awhile, although like Mark I have had flakes years old which mixed up just fine. The test for shellac to see if it's gone bad is to put a drop of it onto a nonporous surface like glass (I use a melamine shelf in the shop). Leave it overnight. It should be hard and brittle to scraping with a fingernail. If not, the stuff has esterified. It's a gradual process, so it can vary from just a bit softer than usual and still usable to completely unusable.

I had a tub of flakes, not terribly old, from Homestead (who, as noted elsewhere in this thread, is noted for providing excellent quality shellac) which had gone bad. Given the price, annoying. And I keep it in a cool dry dark basement spot.

Sometimes the liquid is good for months, sometimes not. I always test before using.

I got a can of Seal-coat for the 2 year shelf life. It may just be me, but it seems a bit softer than freshly mixed from flakes. Maybe something in the processing?

Good luck with the refinishing - at least you can feel like you know what the problem is now.

Ken

Re: Soft shellac finish

#11

Experiment

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>I would try and see if you could duplicate your results. Make samples with and without the mineral spirits and maybe one brushed instead of sprayed. I am suspicious of the mineral spirits. I can't imagine why you would want to use this. I have some flakes of shellac that I saved because of special color and have used occasionally for years; it should not go bad.

Re: Soft shellac finish

#12

Re: Sanding won't work

GolfSteve in Calgary

>Actually it sands very well as long as I am using something like Norton 3X paper. Non stearated sandpaper gums up extremely fast.

Re: Soft shellac finish

#13

MS

Mike Fitterling

>I have wet sanded tons of woodwork with both shellac and lacquer finishes using mineral spirits as a lubricant with no problems at all. On one very big project I did three "coats" of amber shellac, wet sanded with MS, then topcoated with 3 "coats" of lacquer and wet sanded once again with MS--no problems with either finish.