>Youngest son sent a plan of an entertainment cabinet, the plasma screen will sit on top and the components behind frosted glass doors, nickel legs/feet and hardware, etc. What D-I-L wants is "black" wood. I believe she wants to see the grain of the wood so that rules out laminate, and I'm sure she wants a deep black. So:
>If she has the "Pottery Barn" deep brown, not quite black (expresso) finish in mind then thare are done on a diffuse porous wood such as maple or poplar. One way is to start with an aniline dye to get the basic darkness and limit "blotching" to a degree. Then after sealing a gel stain can be used as a glaze or toner to even the color and add some depth.
I'd be sure to make some finish samples for her to sign off on before starting the project. May make your son's life easier.
>My woodworking club recently visited a professional finishing supply company. They do tons and tons of work locally and gave us some good demos.
They swear this finishing schedule doesn't cause any problems, and it certainly resulted in a very dark finish on hard maple with about one minute of work for a cabinet door. Maple is usually very hard to get a dark finish on, and getting an ebonized finish that quickly was impressive.
1. Sand to no more than 180-220 (he stressed that roughness was key to getting good bite with stains).
2. Wipe on a dark water based wiping stain. Wipe off well.
3. After a minute or two, apply a dark oil based wiping stain.
The net result was an intensely dark, evenly applied stain on hard maple using only one coat of dark water based followed by one coat of dark oil based wiping stain. After letting dry for ~30 minutes, they top coated with water based lacquer.
In my mind, I wonder if the use of water based wiping stain couldn't be replaced with a quick wipe with a wet rag - the effect being to raise the grain creating more roughness for the oil based stain to bite into, but I didn't ask that question during the demo. I'm sure these guys have experimented enough that the choice of water based stain followed by oil based stain is optimal :-)
The combinations of oil/water products and short drying times go against most of what I've read, but they are pros and do this all the time without failure.....YMMV
They said their biggest challenge was applying the water based stain fast enough to keep a wet edge. They ended up modifying an airless sprayer to apply stain at a huge rate so they could keep an entire conference table wet.
>The maple doesn't have to look like plastic if the dye/stain isn't fully opaque.
I do like the black ash look as well, though it is a lot different than the Pottery Barn/Restoration Hardware look that is so popular. I assumed the latter, but you may well be right that the original poster has the former look in mind.