Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Book Shelf questions...

Posts

Book Shelf questions...

#1

Book Shelf questions...

ken raddon

>I am trying to build a smallish book shelf for my wife's piano studio. It will be 48" high, by 32" wide, by 17.5" deep. The TV will sit on top. It's not a huge TV but I want to make sure it will not collaps my first ever book shelf. Not to mention fall on a piano student and injure them.

Here's my question: Should I use screws in from the side or top/bottom (and plug/cover them) to hold the top, bottom and shelves on? Or should I use pocket hole screws? Or will biscuts hold just fine.

I havn't used my biscut jointer yet. I have used pocket holes and find them a little unsightly but quite secure.

The sides will sit on the bottom and the top will sit on the sides unless you all school me to a problem with that configuration.

Please forgive my long post and I hope I gave enough information for you to help. Thanks in advance.

Ken Raddon.

FYI The sides will be sitting on th

Re: Book Shelf questions...

#2

Re: Book Shelf questions...

Barry Irby

>I think you can use any of the methods you suggested.

I have made a number of bookshelves, but none were 17" deep. OTOH, none of mine have a TV on top of them.

I would rabbett the joints and leave a rabbett around the back to hold the back.

To hold the shelves I would use adjustable shelf or ratchet strips. I would leave them about a 1/32" proud so the ends of the shelves with scare the ends of the bookshelf.

Re: Book Shelf questions...

#3

Ellis Walentine

A few issues here

Ellis Walentine

>First, you might want to consider adjustable shelving, in which case you will need to drill rows of holes for shelf pegs or clips. If you want fixed shelves, you want to house the ends of the shelves in dados (preferably blind dados) in the cabinet sides.

If the top overhangs or sits atop the sides, you can screw directly down into the sides and plug the counterbores with wood plugs for a nice appearance. Biscuits may also be used here instead of screws if you don't want to see plugs on the top. Even better, you could miter the top and sides and use biscuits to hold the joint together; then you wouldn't have to see the endgrain of the top at the sides of the bookcase.

Whatever you do, make sure to put a back on this case to keep it from racking. The accepted way, as Barry indicated, is to house the back in rabbets all around. You can pin or airnail the back in place.

The other issue to consider is the weight of the TV. Assuming the weight of the TV is concentrated on a 16" wide footprint (just a guess), it will have a deflecting influence on the top, so you need to be sure you've chosen strong enough materials and that you have engineered the top well. If you're using 3/4" thick wood for the top, I'd suggest putting a 1 1/2" or 2" high drop-edge on the front to add some beam strength. If you don't want the visual thickness, you can put a vertical beam of some sort under the center of the top, dadoed into the sides, to help support the weight.

Also, consider mounting the bookcase on a plinth of some sort. This gets it up off the floor and allows you to compensate for an uneven floor by either using adjustable height glides or by scribing the plinth to the floor if it is to be a permanent installation.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Book Shelf questions...

#4

Re: A few issues here

ken raddon

>What a wealth of information. Thank you both for the advice.

BTW The wood is 3/4" mdf with Alder veneer. I will definately go with the extra support across the front. Thanks again.

Ken Raddon.

Re: Book Shelf questions...

#5

Lee Grindinger

A 30" MDF shelf will need help, lots of help

Lee Grindinger

>Plan on a solid wood edge at least 1 1/4" wide to help your MDF shelf over that span. Your top will need help too, even more with that TV. MDF has little integrity to resist weight over time and will sag under the weight of a TV or books quite quickly. Beef it up with solid wood or consider using plywood rather than MDF for your shelves and top. Even with plywood a solid edge would be a good idea. Another option would be to add a center divider to help with your span issues.

Lee

Re: Book Shelf questions...

#6

A couple of recent engineering feats…

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>I am not an engineer, nor do I play one on TV, so this may be overkill, but last summer I built a corner shelf for our guest bedroom for our 27" TV. It's vintage 1990, so it's a CRT, and it's heavy! Because it's a CRT, it's fairly deep—even more so throughout its width than one would expect. The consequence of that is the shelf is ≈18" deep, and to accommodate that depth in a corner has to be >48" wide. The TV must weigh almost 100 lbs (so much so that SWMBO bribed a couple of burly delivery guys on a different mission to lift it onto the shelf). The shelf material was ¾" maple glue up from my cousin's furniture factory—lot's of strength there—far more than any MDF/veneer combo—but I didn't think near enough to support that weight at that span. So, what to do?

I dadoed a groove 36" long on the underside of the shelf about 4" back from the front edge. It was fashioned for a slip fit of one leg of big box ¾ X 36" angle iron (also needs a bit of relief for the fillet at the junction). I drilled and tapped seven or eight holes in the other face of the angle iron, and using it as a pattern drilled through the maple, countersunk the holes from the top, and ran flat head machine screws through the maple into the angle iron. It's very stiff. There is no visible deflection, even after the six+ months it's been up.

I just constructed shelves for the equipment closet behind the big screen TV in the media room—four each 46" wide X 14-20" deep (players are deep, amps are not). The shelves are supported at the ends and on the back by ¾" cleats screwed to studs behind the sheetrock. The complement on each ranges from a couple of lightweight components (graphic equalizer and cassette player), to the shelf holding the two 200 watt/channel amps. The dual front channel/rear channel amp is on a shelf by itself and it's even heavier than either of the main amps (but not both). Same problem—relatively long span, fairly significant weight. In the case of the front/rear amp, it's concentrated at the center of the span. Solution? Same as for the TV. I suspect these shelves are over-engineered (and I invite analysis in that regard), but the TV shelf probably isn't.

The one mistake I made was that while the TV shelf was a full ¾", the media shelves were ¾" plywood (somewhat less thick), and the dadoes wound up being perilously close to the top veneer. As I figure it (again, I'm no engineer), since all of the point load is between the rear support and the steel, the integrity of the veneer and the ply in front of the steel isn't at risk. Were I to make another (and I may), I think I might cut a little less deep and shim the steel away from the underside by 1/8" or so.

I said all that to say that I think you need to seriously consider assistance for your TV shelf…but also to give an insight to a possible solution.

Rod

Re: Book Shelf questions...

#7

Re: Book Shelf questions...

Howard Acheson

>The primary issue is the TV. To ensure that the top will hold the weight of the TV, do a partial mock-up. Cut the MDF top to size. Cut a 2x4 into three pieces. Two should be the depth of the shelf and on should be the length of the shelf. Now let the two pieces represent the sides of the bookcase and the one be the back. Place them in the appropriate spaces and lay the shelf on top. Now measure the distance from the reference (either floor or table, where ever you have placed the 2x4's). Put the TV in place and again measure the same points. Any sag greater than 1/16" will be noticeable to the eye. Also, you should expect the sag to at least double over time with the constant weight. Using your mock-up you can add a front edge stiffener and/or a center upright until you have the bookcase top level.

As others have said, MDF is a material that has little longitudinal strength. In other words, it sags with relatively little weight and continues to sag by greater amounts over time.