Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

OT: Video storage solutions? DVR?

Posts

OT: Video storage solutions? DVR?

#1

OT: Video storage solutions? DVR?

Luke Herzberg

>I'm looking for suggestions on the best way to organize our video collection, whether by storing on digital media, or storing disks in a carousel.

When I say "our" collection, that largely means the 2 year old, and his ever revolving set of DVD's and VHS (yes, I realize the carousel solution would exclude those).

Is there a digital storage solution that can store DVD's in their "menu functional" format, rather than just recording the video output?

As I am definitely not a technology early adopter, HD, blu-ray, whatever the new formats are called...those aren't in the picture (ha!) and probably won't be for some time, and would not have to be considered in any product.

I'm open for ideas...Thanks in advance!

- Luke

Re: OT: Video storage solutions? DVR?

#2

Re: OT: Video storage solutions? DVR?

Tom

>You can rip dvd's to a hard drive. Commercial dvd's may include copy-protection schemes. VHS can be recorded, via a capture device. My only question would be why? If these are only the things he watches for now, you probably won't need them too long. My kids seem to outgrow videos fairly quickly (I put everything on dvd). If these are family things you want to archive, I'd store them on dvd and also rip them to a large storage drive...

Re: OT: Video storage solutions? DVR?

#3

Kids grow as fast as technology changes

Mark Goodall - ATL - tooljunkie

>I got sick and tired of all those darn VHS tapes hanging around, so a few years ago, I gave them all away. Most were kid's videos and my kids were growing up. I went and bought a few of the favorites in DVD format and was glad to have the extra space.

Now we have a large collection of DVD movies and I'm thinking of ripping them to a hard drive, like we've done with most of our music CDs. We keep the CDs for backup, but now with MP3 players and everything, there's not much need for the actual CD's. Looks like we're heading that way with DVD's too.

But before I spend too much time ripping DVD's to hard drive collections, I know many of them won't be watched too much in the future. Thank heavens. I can only watch the Barbie Princess Movie and Bud the Soccer/Basketball Dog so many times ;)

I'm eager to see who posts her and get an idea of how many people are moving from DVD discs to hard drives for the entertainment collections.

If the old media was based on linear tapes (8 tracks, cassette tapes) and then switched to plastic circular discs (guess that's were we started from with the LP's) such as CD, DVD and hard drives, I'm waiting until we switch to the new media..... gaseous state media players ;)

Happy Woodworking!

Re: OT: Video storage solutions? DVR?

#4

Re: OT: Video storage solutions? DVR?

ScottS

>Sounds like you need a DVD changer. Search on Amazon and you'll find models that hold 300-400 DVDs. The "Sony DVPCX995V 400-Disc DVD Mega Changer/Player" retails for $450 and sells for $300 at Amazon, for instance.

It's possible to transfer VHS tapes to DVD, though I must admit I don't know a whole lot about the process. If you don't have the requisite computer hardware and expertise, you might look into boxes that combine a DVD recorder with a VHS player. I've seen some that will do "one touch" copying from VHS to DVD. Prices seem to be all over the board on these, but I'd expect to pay $200-300. Check Amazon's "DVD Recorder" category for examples.

Re: OT: Video storage solutions? DVR?

#5

Re: OT: Video storage solutions? DVR?

Glenn Madsen, near San Francisco

>I LOVE the DVR TiVo sat box I've got. When the drive died, from 4 years of use, I bought a high capacity replacement. There are maybe 90 hours of quilting shows stored there, and still another 250 hours of capacity.

The grandkids have about ten programs that get recorded, and when they come over, there are many from which to choose. And when they're done, the get deleted, and new ones record later.

There are a few dvds that do get watched over and over and over. They know ALL the dialog to 'Finding Nemo', and love it still. Some things don't change.

Re: OT: Video storage solutions? DVR?

#6

Re: OT: Video storage solutions? DVR?

Rob Hix - King George, VA

>Hey Luke,

Take a look at SageTV (www.sagetv.com). I went to using it last spring and my wife and I have never turned back. It is a DVR system that uses your computer with a capture card in it to record TV shows, etc. You can rip DVDs to it, although I am not sure about them still being in their menu-able form. It can be set up to display everything on your TV through the use of the extenders so you do not have to watch everything sitting at the computer. My favorite part about it is that I am in complete control of the recording device and its operations. I can add hard drive space if needed. I can even extend its functionality if so desired.

Take a look at it. You have to fiddle around with it a little, but for the most part it is very straightforward. That, and there is a great forum for help.

As usual, no affiliation, just a VERY satisfied customer.

Rob Hix

Re: OT: Video storage solutions? DVR?

#7

Re: OT: Video storage solutions? DVR?

JoeW in Detroit, MI

>I have a Sony DVD/VHS recorder that can dub from VHS to DVD. I do this so we can use them in the van on long trips.