>I've been looking at buying a jointer for some time. I owned a Delta 6" jointer for a time, but sold it before moving & had barely used it. I see that the primary variation among jointers is cutter width. Bed length (longer = better), horse power (more = better), blade design (helical is said to be superior to straight) some say parallelogram adjustment is better (I'm not too clear on this one) etc. are also variables, but the basic definition is width.
My understanding is that the primary use for a jointer, as the name suggests, is preparing the narrow edge of a board for jointing; truing the edge so it is perfectly flat & perpendicular to the board's face for gluing panels and so on. If this is 99% of the real world use of a jointer, what real advantage is 8" over 6"? I can see that for this operation a longer bed is better, but how often are you likely to edge anywhere near a 6" board, let alone an 8", 10", or 12" one? I remember back in wood shop a zillion years ago, this machine was called a "jointer planer". Of course, an 8" jointer can face a board 2" wider than a 6" jointer, but isn't a planer really better for this anyway? What am I missing here?
So 50% of a jointer's use if for flattening the edge of a board, and 50% of a jointer's use if for flattening one face. And then the planer does the job of the other face.
>Before you can true an edge of any, board one must joint the face of same board so that when truing the edge you obtain an edge that is square to the face. That is why the wider the better when it comes to jointers.
I use my jointer in almost every woodworking project I undertake. You are correct, it is used to make the edge of the board perfectly flat when preparing for a glue up. The other important use, and I think you may missing this one, is when working with rough lumber, a board that may be cupped, bowed or otherwise un-flat, running the board face down over the jointer will make the face flat. Once the face is flat it is then run over the jointer with the flattened face against the fence and the edge over the knives. This will give you an edge-to-face that are exactly 90 degrees to each other. Proceeding to the table saw and placing the flat edge against the fence and running the board through the saw trimming up the opposite side will make the board equal width. You would then go to the planner and with the jointed face down run the board through the planner until both sides are parralel. I hope I said all this that makes sense. Sometimes I have trouble putting in words what is in my head. Others may chime in.
>For my work I benefit from the longest jointer I can afford. It makes straighting long pieces vastly easier. In general 8" jointers have longer tables than 6". I sold a 6" and bought a 8" to get a longer table. I don't flatten the face of lumber very often. I have a planer with big infeed and outfeed tables and I rely on the planer for flattening in most cases. I have only a 1.5HP motor on my jointer and it is more than enough for any edge jointing. It does load some when face flattening.
Other than length, I would buy the jointer with the most convenient knife setting features. Mine happens to be exceptionally inconvenient and it is annoying.
>Hi Dan I'm not a pro by any means, but I do work with rough lumber exclusively. The basic facts are that a jointer/planer is normally used to flatten (remove bow, twist and cup) from one face of rough lumber. The thickness planer does exactly what the name implies. When you run lumber through it, the board becomes thinner, NOT straighter. It just makes the surface being planed parallel to the other side. If you run a bowed or twisted board through a thickness planer - You will end up with a thinner but still bowed /twisted board. (I have been successful removing cup from some otherwise straight boards, using the planer only). The Jointer/planer, properly used will flatten one surface of the board, removing all "twist, bow and cup" and then can be used to "join" one edge at 90 degree to the flat surface. Some people do use a thickness planer to flatten the first surface of a board by making a "sled". They do the flatting by mounting the raw board into the sled, then shimming the board so it is held rigid on the sled. the planer will remove the high spots and flatten it. But the normal procedure used is to first use the joiner/planer to flatten one side of the board, then join one edge at 90 degree to the flat surface. This is quite time consuming, and normally done to avoid cutting a prized wide board to the width of the joiner/planer they own. Then the board is fed through the thickness planer to make the second surface parallel to the flat surface established by the joiner. The saw is then used to make the second edge parallel to the first edge. I have an 8" Grizzly joiner with the segmented spiral head and a 20" surface planer with the Byrd (also a segmented spiral head). IMHO the spiral head does produce a much smoother surface, especially on lumber that has gnarly grain. I had a 6" Grizzly joiner and (still have) a 12 1/2 lunchbox Dewalt planer. I have ran many boards that would have tearout using that equipment through the new equipment with no problems. As far as the Parallelogram design, many say it is easier to realign when needed. I have never had any problems with the gib design (It is used on virtually all major metalworking equipment, including all mills, jig bores etc. without any major problems). Many woodworkers (like me) start out with a 6" joiner, then later upgrade to an 8". The 8" normally have longer beds - I find this to make it far easier to straighten and handle long material. I also hated to cut down all material to 6" or under in width so that I could properly flatten it. The 8" wide joiner allows me to make most of my panels with less edge gluing and better matching.
>Dan, You have gotten good advice here. Read and Reread it.
You have raised the issue of "stock preparation" and there are a number of approaches. There is much to know about it that is only slightly related to the tools you use.
For example, When you dress or thickness a board, it is generally considered wise to take about the same amount of wood off each side so that the stresses are relieved in a similar manner and so that any inconsistency in the moisture content is exposed equally on both sides and this helps reduce any warping.
Planing is also important. Such as, chopping the pieces down to abut the right size before you joint of plane them. If a board six feet long has an inch of bow in it, you have to cut about a half inch off each end on the concave side and a similar amount off the middle on the convex side. Thus, a six inch wide board would be reduce to about five inches. OTOH, if you needed three foot long pieces and you cut the board in half first, you might find you only need to take a quarter inch off each side and end up with five and a half inch wide pieces. If you try to joint of flatten the faces of long stock, you can literally joint some or it away to nothing if it is crooked to start with. But if you cut it into short pieces first, you may be able to retain almost all the thickness.
Another thing that gets a lot of attention is the snipe left at the ends of many pieces by surfaces or planers particularly. I find it useful to cut pieces a Little over sized and then cut the snipe off later. I use rough stock frequently and it often has split ragged ends on it. I am eager to clean it up, but I leave it on and let it take the snipe and then cut it off. (Excellent planers produce very slight snipe and I sometime use myPerformax to sand it off.)
I think you got the characteristics of the jointer correct. As far as the dovetailed or gibbed ways verses the parallelogram method, I have the gibbed one, but I am not sure it matters a lot. My jointer stays set at a light cut 90% of the time.
And, I agree with Bill, the changing and setting up of the knives is important. Pick one that is easy. Easier to keep sharp knives on it that way. I don't have a spiral head so I can not comment. (wish I did)
And OTOH, the guys over on the Hand tool forum would tell us that we could do a lot of the flattening with a hand plane or two and in pretty short order. You really just need to knock off the high spots and create a surface that is flat enough to run on your planer's bed. (In case you haven't realized it, the problem with the surface is that in moses the board flat, planes it, and then lets it spring back.) So if the board has enough surface on the bottom to support it and not allow it to be mashed, you can plane the other side flat and then flip it. For example, you can take a cupped board and run it through with the concave side down, pane the convex side off and then flatten the concave side, if the board is sturdy enough to resit the flatten of the planer.
>and Mark for the link. The illustrations help a lot! I understand the procedure much better now than I did prior to posting. It sounds like an awful lot of people who start out with a 6" upgrade to an 8", so I guess it makes sense to try for one of those initially. I had been looking at the 6" Powermatic, it has a relatively long bed (66"), but it's $799. I see Grizzly has 3 8" jointers in this range, 2 for $695 & 1 for $795, with 72", 75" & 76" beds. I had some bad luck with my previous Delta jointer (2 warped fences) and I like the precision of my PM2000 TS so well I was leaning toward the PM jointer, but the Griz does seem like more bang for the buck. If anyone has any thoughts on the Grizzlys I'd like to hear them.
>I have an 8 inch Grizzly and I am very happy with it. I have seen a lot of posts here and elsewhere from folks who are very happy with their Griz jointers. I don't remember reading a single bad review of their jointers.
>I own the GO490 Grizzly Jointer. It is a great machine! Built in mobile base is a great feature.Extra long bed is real nice as well. Hope this helps,good luck!
>If you have broadband, there are a lot of decent short video clips that illustrate WW techniques. Many of the magazine sites (FWW, PWW, and WOOD to name some) have these on their sites. I just saw the video in the link below. It's a good brief intro if you are unfamiliar with the tools. I receive FWW's e-mail newsletter and this link was included.
Recently I toured through a series of video clips that Jet Equipment posted on YouTube about turning. Those were great for a non-turner like me!
Explore these sites for a vast array of what I think is pretty good info. No affiliation, I would expect that Woodworkers Journal and American Woodworking and others mags would also have similar info and videos.
>Grizzly has had trouble stocking their jointers. Several people here have selected Griz as their best choice only to have to go with a different brand because they were given 3-6 month waits.
>I remember way back when Delta and Powermatic were the machines of choice, if you could afford them, and Grizzly were only purchased by people who's patience exceeded their budgets. Now, it sounds like you can expect as high or higher quality from Grizzly than the once great manufacturers.
Guess there was a day, too, way back when Sears was a big quality store.
Will our kids look back when they're older and say "I remember there used to be a store called Walmart", and "I remember a store called HomeDepot that my Dad used to take me".
>I have a Powermatic lathe (restored PM-90 from a closed school woodshop). It was made in USA and has fine workmanship, fit and finish. I recently purchased a Powermatic Drill press, it was made in China. The fit and finish is not comparable to the old lathe. I have a 4 or 5 year old USA made Delta Unisaw, beautiful machine. I had an old Delta drill press, bench sander - great units. I have several Porter Cable tools (all US made). I looked at the current Delta - Powermatic and Porter Cable equipment at the Indianapolis tool shows this last year. IMHO, none of that equipment (including the joiners) had the apparent quality of the Grizzly, Jet or Steel City offerings. Again IMHO the WMH group - (with the exception of the Jet - which is unabashable Asian and lower priced) are worth the higher prices they are attempting to get. They apparently are trading on the name earned by the American designers and workers when the products were made in the US. They are trying to convince the public the products are somehow better than the competitors (probably built in the same Chinese factories). I think Grizzly, Jet etc. actually have an advantage as they have been building (and so state) there longer and are aware of the shortcomings/quality problems and have better designs and a better control system. I am one who tries to buy North American whenever possible. I am really put off by vendors that trade off their USA labor earned names to sell Asian products. I probably will not purchase any more major tools from Delta unless they are not available anywhere else.
>Yeah I've seen some of those, especially the YouTube ones. Only trouble is with some, the video can be kinda rough. I linked to a jointer related one yesterday, from Woodcraft as I recall. A guy I've seen on YouTube several times before was demonstrating straightening the edge of a curved board on a jointer. I knew what he was referring to when he gestured "notice the dip on this side... " etc., but you sure couldn't see it. The one in your link was great though, good definition & very informative. I'll check out the whole series there, thanks.